3 ms·
Well, there's always the stark object lesson of Software Arts (Visicalc) and their publisher, Personal Software (later VisiCorp). Both companies were destroyed
by hga 16y ago
Well, there's always the stark object lesson of Software Arts (Visicalc) and their publisher, Personal Software (later VisiCorp). Both companies were destroyed because the deal they struck, at the dawn of packaged personal computer software, gave SA too much money. SA refused to renegotiate, PS used the contract to force SA to create ports of their stuff for every possible PC (and there were very many back then), it all ended in tears and Lotus ate their lunch.
So we have these issues and failure modes illustrated:
The market and business model was not well defined, making it difficult to get the contractual arrangement correct the first time.
The principles couldn't sustain a productive working relationship and focused on the contract rather than the market.
Games as packaged software have perhaps worked (a bit) better because the business model and separate roles of each company are fairly well defined, but that could be changing as their use of the net increases.
But mostly what people are trying to do is uncharted territory (that's generally where the biggest payoff is) and a developer/publisher model precludes the process of Customer Development; until that's done, there's not a clear enough line between technology and ideas vs. marketing and sales.
Overall, the interests of each party are divergent and their game is somewhat zero-sum, or at least all too often viewed that way. When their interface can't be well defined at the beginning of their relationship it doesn't look like it's a good model to follow.