7 ms·
For the amount of haters telegram had when they launched for their purported security failures, it's funny that people are looking to block it instead of silent
by raverbashing 9y ago
For the amount of haters telegram had when they launched for their purported security failures, it's funny that people are looking to block it instead of silently explore its flaws
- Dolores12 9y agoYou can't exploit something that doesn't exist, hence they block it.
- legulere 9y agoOr it is just a charade to make it look like Telegram is not controlled by the kreml
- nikcub 9y agoWhy would someone who has stood up to the Russian government multiple times, had a company taken away from him already for not being compliant and is now living in exile hand control of Telegram to that same government?
- brazzledazzle 9y agoThat's the cover story you see.
- jsjsjsjsjsjs 9y agoWhy would such someone would wave flag of security making it the biggest selling point and then go with questionable practices?
- nikcub 9y agoTelegram being secure or not is a separate question. Secure messaging is hard, most people when producing secure messaging will produce poor secure messaging - it doesn't mean they've been compromised by a government.
- admax88q 9y agoYes but Telegram continues to avoid fixing flaws that have been pointed out by cryptographers. It's one thing to get some security wrong because its "hard." It's another to not fix those problems when people explain how and why you did something wrong.
- Dolores12 9y agoI guess they will fix those theoretical flaws when someone make real exploit? RSA encryption is theoretically breakable by quantum computers, but people still use it and gonna be using it until someone break it.
- wu-ikkyu 9y agoWhy are you assuming that Pavel is the only possible exploit that could be used to own Telegram?
- nikcub 9y agobecause that is what they're implying when they say "controlled" by the kremlin
- Luff 9y ago"Probably the best-known test to see if someone was a witch was the swimming test Basically, if you found someone you suspected of being an old crone, you’d drag them to a pond and chuck them in. If they sank, they’re were innocent (and probably dead) but if they floated they were guilty…and quickly executed."
- sturmen 9y agoRussia, of course, has a long history of disinformation and propaganda. But it seems to me like there isn't a trust problem with Telegram right now, so why is the Kremlin throwing this charade if current targets are already using Telegram and trust it? Surely it would be in their interest to lie low and (supposedly) collect data through a backdoor than risk having their bluff called and being forced to ban it?
- brenschluss 9y agoSo that more activists will turn towards using Telegram actively.
- tptacek 9y ago"Purported"? http://www.reuters.com/article/us-iran-cyber-telegram-exclusive-idUSKCN10D1AM http://www.reuters.com/article/us-iran-cyber-telegram-exclus... People have written academic papers about how bad Telegram's underlying crypto is.
- EGreg 9y agoSomeone needs to publish an exploit, how come I have never seen a single one yet
- mullen 9y agoBecause the State actors that would be capable of making that kind of exploit would keep that to themselves.
- EGreg 9y agoNo one else is?
- kardos 9y agoIf someone had an exploit like that, there's money to be had by exploiting it in secret and/or selling it to people who do that. Why would they post it online for you for free?
- EGreg 9y agoBecause they are a researcher that wants to show that rolling your own crypto is bad. In other words back up the orthodox opinion with a PROOF and not just groupthink.
- tptacek 9y agoThis is an argument that suggests we should all keep on using SHA-1, since, after all, there's no public exploit.
- jszymborski 9y agoI think that when it is ever a remote possibility, by hook or by crook, nation states prefer to get private firms to compromise themselves as opposed to subversively breaking into a service. When private firms hand over data or introduce backdoors on behalf of their gov't, the gov't now has political cover and it's easy to make the bad guy the firm the bad guy. "We just asked for the data, and they complied." v. "We came, We saw, We stole your data"
- dsacco 9y ago> purported security failures > people are looking to block it instead of silently explore its flaws This is not a good heuristic for determining if security failures are "purported." In point of fact, Telegram is widely lampooned by every self-respecting professional cryptographer who has written about it. There's nothing "purported" about Telegram's security failures - they are empirically demonstrable, and have been exposed through multiple cryptanalytic reviews.[1][2] Frankly, I don't think I've ever seen anyone defend Telegram here on HN who actually has professional crypto experience (whether academia or industry), or any other similar proxy for credibility in the field. The popular contention is that (poor, harmless) Telegram is plagued by a persistent astroturfing campaign perpetrated by the likes of Moxie Marlinspike and Thomas Ptacek in order to elevate Signal's status. That's: 1) not true, in my opinion (though to be fair at least one of those people is obviously biased); and 2) irrelevant, because we have the benefit of empirical rigor to instruct our opinions of secure messaging systems. We don't need to rely on infosec ideologues on HN or Twitter. Telegram is very much like climate change. There is a widespread consensus among the informed (read: academic and professional cryptographers) that Telegram's security failures exist, and that these failures are empirically demonstrable. At the same time, there is a controversy led almost entirely by the uninformed (read: non-cryptographers) that denies Telegram's security failures and undermines attempts at demonstrating them through accusations of shilling or misdirection. To put it very succinctly: there are no valid arguments that Telegram has an optimal security model from the perspective of cryptanalysis and cryptographic design best practices. ____________________________________________________________ 1. https://www.alexrad.me/discourse/a-264-attack-on-telegram-and-why-a-super-villain-doesnt-need-it-to-read-your-telegram-chats.html https://www.alexrad.me/discourse/a-264-attack-on-telegram-an... 2. https://cs.au.dk/~jakjak/master-thesis.pdf https://cs.au.dk/~jakjak/master-thesis.pdf
- out_of_protocol 9y agoOk, valid argument: telegram servers DO receive and store plaintext version of every conversation done (except private chats), while, as a reference, whatsapp don't do this, applying end-to-end encryption by default. So, basically, hack telegram servers -> you have all the convos. Bribe some employers, locate and grab their servers -> see above. Also, how would you know they're not connected with some 3-letter agency already?