3 ms·
Uhmmm I'm fairly certain that's not entirely correct. There may be terminals which batch transactions and send them later, but in most cases you can even see th
by gambiting 9y ago
Uhmmm I'm fairly certain that's not entirely correct. There may be terminals which batch transactions and send them later, but in most cases you can even see the terminal going "connecting to <bank> servers" and only after it obtains the connection it authorizes the transaction. Larger stores have a constant connection open so the transaction goes through straight away, in smaller shops the terminal actually has to connect with the bank first.
But I guess the best proof is that if you have zero money in your account you can't actually buy anything with your card, the transaction will get declined immediately(unless you have overdraft, obviously), so the terminal has to check with the bank if you have funds to pay or not.
- csydas 9y agoI agree with this - offlining transactions are a possibility for some instances, but in most cases, there is a significant difference in speed - I'm in Russia at the moment and when I have a transaction go through the terminal, my bank sends a notification of the transaction usually before the pay terminal is done with it's processing; so there must be some rapid communication happening to authorize the transaction within a short period, even if the actual transfer of funds transaction takes longer (which is expected). When I briefly returned to the US last year after the chip terminals were implemented, I was a bit frustrated to see that it did indeed take significantly longer than I was used to, neverminding how inconvenient it was to not have the ability to use the NFC or the card slot on the majority of terminals.
- YeGoblynQueenne 9y agoTo be honest, I don't remember how that works so you're right I might not be entirely correct. The point is though, when the pin pad says it's connecting, that usually means the transaction is taking longer than usual. It might also depend on the vendor, for instance, in the Waitrose I never see the connection message whereas in the news agent I always do.
- YeGoblynQueenne 9y agoAlright, I got a bit of a memory refresher (thanks wikipedia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EMV#Terminal_action_analysis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EMV#Terminal_action_analysis). I didn't entirely misremember this, but I'm not entirely correct either, like you say. In short, whether a transaction will go online, stay offline or be denied, depends on the settings on the card (configured by the issuer) and the settings on the pinpad (configured by the acquirer). The two of them together decide what happens. So in some cases the combined settings on the card may allow offline processing, which is the batch process in my previous comment. Others, like ATMs (according to the article) will always go online, and yet others may set a "floor limit" - a transaction amount above which the transaction should always go online. Another factor is the "terminal capabilities", so basically connection speed- if that's too slow transactions may default to offline only. So what I remember must be that if the transaction is under a certain floor limit, or terminal speed, it can stay offline, maximising some speed-vs-risk tradeoff. And what you note, that the card will deny your transaction when you don't have enough money in the bank, is basically the flip side of that. What would be harder to notice is the cases when a transaction goes through even when you don't have enough money in the bank, e.g. because the amount you spent is below the floor limit for your issuer and acquirer. But I'm not sure what happens after that- is the transaction declined later? Does the bank charge your account as if it's overdrawn? It's been a while and I don't remember those things very well I'm afraid :0
- PeterisP 9y agoThe card can and will remember your latest balance, so it's quite possible to have transactions accepted/denied based on your balance without checking with the bank. It does add some risks since the balance is "stale" i.e. may have old info, so it'd be configured that way only if the terminal physically can't connect online all the time, but it's certainly possible.