5 ms·
You can play without paying money, right? That's much one definition of free, isn't it? Edit: Why the downvoted? I thought free = no money?
by paulcole 9y ago
You can play without paying money, right? That's much one definition of free, isn't it?
Edit: Why the downvoted? I thought free = no money?
- taneq 9y agoNot if they force you to do work for them in order to use it. They're basically employing you to look at ads, and paying you in game time.
- paulcole 9y agoI guess I'm not getting this. The game costs no money out of pocket to play, I'm just exchanging ads for playing? Isn't that a free (as in money) game?
- efreak 9y agoMoney is not the only currency.
- Majestic121 9y agoIt's free (as in money), but "free (as in money)" is a very limited definition of free
- Tinyyy 9y agoIt seems that most people would like it to be free as in charity, which would never happen.
- Majestic121 9y agoI agree, they need to make money somehow and I actually don't have any issue with the way Sega is doing it (ads if you don't want to pay money, or 2€ if you don't want to pay with ads). What I object to is mainly assimilating not paying money and being free : it's not free if there are ads, you're paying with time, mind share (because there would not be that much money in ads if it was not at least a little bit effective) and potentially security (as ads are a known malware vector) That's why I insist that free as in no money is a very restricted definition of free, and should not be considered equal to simply free, because it then undermines products that actually are free
- chc 9y agoYou may as well say that a game is not free if it poses a challenge, since then you pay in frustration. When we're talking about prices, "free" refers to money. You're certainly right that there are other interesting axes you could examine games on, but I don't see how they belong on the game's price tag.
- richmarr 9y agoTo pay in frustration the company would need to have a revenue model that could make money from your frustration. As things stand, they have ads, which require your attention not your frustration. That means time paying attention to the ads in addition to the time spent playing the actual game. And you keep referring to the price tag, but as everyone in software knows there are different meanings of 'free'. Not all of them refer to money, but all of them are important to understand. In this case the argument is clearly about things like child-appropriate content; at which point there is a clearly valid need to distinguish between ad-supported and non-ad-supported apps. You can argue about what to call them if you like, but 'free' and 'ad-funded' wouldn't seem far from the mark.
- croon 9y agoThere are tons of (actually) free apps and games. They can either be open source ("charity") or they could theoretically be marketing for new Xbox One/PS4/Switch Sega games. "Free" as in other-currency-than-money isn't free.
- Spivak 9y agoIf they just changed "Free" to "Ad Supported" I think most people here would be happy.
- Accacin 9y agoAnd what about Google? They basically employ you to look at ads and then pay you in being able to check your emails?
- mrisoli 9y agoYou can't really compare some classic games to Google's product offering, there's a huge difference in the scale of value here.
- intoverflow2 9y agoWheres the tipping point for when the product offering is enough for it to be ok to be supported by ads and data?
- Spivak 9y agoI wouldn't attach a value judgment in this situation. If you're making money off of ads and data then your product isn't free, regardless of whether you think the business model is good or bad.
- Spivak 9y agoI wouldn't call Google free either.
- emodendroket 9y agoIn that case almost nothing on the app store or Google Play store is free.
- Spivak 9y agoThat's precisely the point.
- StevePerkins 9y ago> Edit: Why the downvoted? HN isn't as bad as Reddit, but there ARE a handful of touchy subjects that will get you swamped by downvotes, even if your comment reasonably adds to the discussion. Advertising is one of those triggers. You just don't want to say anything here that could possibly be interpreted as supporting ads, if your care about your fake-Internet-points count. For what it's worth, I threw you an upvote because this didn't seem fair. And there's 50/50 odds that this comment will result in you getting a sudden wave of upvotes (psychology is weird).