4 ms·
I think many people fail to understand Amazon's approach. From watching their business over the years, Amazon isn't about books, or online purchasing, or data,
by tomrod 9y ago
I think many people fail to understand Amazon's approach.
From watching their business over the years, Amazon isn't about books, or online purchasing, or data, or Whole Foods.
Amazon's secret sauce is lowering costs, especially transaction costs. Monetization and business case are easy to justify when lowered costs are provable (not just expected).
Google was the same for search and ads, but seems to forget these lessons in other fields and experimental ventures (Google Reader, etc.).
Both tend to bring high quality (from this user's experience). But the reason they are so fascinating to watch really is due to the reduction of transaction costs.
- dragontamer 9y ago> Amazon's secret sauce is lowering costs, especially transaction costs. Monetization and business case are easy to justify when lowered costs are provable (not just expected). I disagree. Walmart is obscenely good at this cost-lowering too. Indeed, I'm able to price-match a better deal from Best Buy, Target, and so forth today. I prefer buying used (and new) games from Gamestop, even online. Almost explicitly because even with free "Prime" shipping, Amazon's prices are slightly higher. These other online shops simply wouldn't exist if the prices were cheaper at Amazon. Amazon is people's first choice online now. It is no longer the cheapest deal in my experience. Instead, Amazon's main benefit is the social network, its marketplace (as full of counterfeits and cheap Alibaba peddled goods are... that's a lot of business Amazon has on its marketplace), and AWS. None of those things make Amazon the cheapest. (Cheap questionable crap can be bought from Alibaba at much lower prices. Especially since USB-C cables from Amazon may blow up your computer: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11021665 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11021665) Brand-name stuff is never cheaper at Amazon. The Brands are powerful, and they make sure that their prices are the same at Target or Walmart as they are at Amazon (ex: PS4 or Nintendo Switch). Designer Clothing from Amazon has questionable quality (See: http://amazonadviser.com/2017/06/22/nike-partners-amazon-help-fight-counterfeit-shoes/ http://amazonadviser.com/2017/06/22/nike-partners-amazon-hel... Nike recognized the problem, and is now directly selling on Amazon to try and stamp-out the fakes and counterfeits.) Again: if I wanted fakes, I go to Alibaba for cheaper prices. -------------------- Amazon just wants you to think they're good at lowering costs. But they haven't been a market leader in cost-cutting for... several years now.
- JOnAgain 9y agoI would disagree with your disagreement :) I consider one of the biggest costs of Walmart to be the time and experience of actually going to Walmart. I generally find the experience unpleasant, or at least a chore, and it is time consuming because Walmarts are so large and then you have to wait in line. I consider Amazon "cheaper" even when their prices are slightly higher because I save time and energy. Now living in NYC, transportation from stores is much less convenient than when I used to live in a city with a car. With Amazon, it just comes straight to my door. Then there is the competition on items. With Walmart, it's all sold by Walmart. Knockoffs aside, Amazon is bringing multiple sellers together where they are competing head to head on prices. That would be like going from Walmart to Target to compare prices on items -- such a time consuming activity that nobody would really do it except for large ticket items.
- WillPostForFood 9y agoIt's hard to compare like for like with used games, but Amazon is typically better at discounting newer games. If you are prime, Amazon kills GameStop with pre-orders. GameStop is almost always full retail - $59.99. Amazon discounts pre-orders to $47.99. Another knock on GameStop is their miserable in store experience with aggressive upsells, selling opened products as new, data breaches, and lousy treatment of their salespeople. It is impossible for GameStop to survive because they are fighting Amazon on one side, and the digital distribution platforms of the console manufacturers on the other. They are the next Blockbuster/Radio Shack.
- dragontamer 9y agoWell, what you say may be true with regards to investing advice. I would NEVER invest in Gamestop, and I would (and have) pumped more money into Amazon. But alas, my opinion as a consumer is grossly different from my opinion as an investor. As a consumer, I've had better luck browsing used games from Gamestop than on Amazon (yeah, I'll save $20 on used rather than buy new or full-priced digial). Be it in-store or online.
- georgemcbay 9y ago"Instead, Amazon's main benefit is the social network, its marketplace (as full of counterfeits and cheap Alibaba peddled goods are... that's a lot of business Amazon has on its marketplace), and AWS." I speak only for myself and do not presume to extend my experience into any kind of larger data, but for me the entire value proposition of Amazon is quick, predictable shipment of items. If I order something from Amazon I will receive it when they claim 99.9% of the time, and the only failures I've ever experienced were the fault of 3rd party package deliver companies (eg. FedEx, USPS...) This will be either same day, next day or two days. I don't use non-prime Amazon, not because it will cost me extra for shipping (I will often spring extra for same-day/next-day shipping on orders less than $35), but because I no longer trust the shipping estimates when it isn't Amazon fulfilled. The only two sites on the whole of the Internet that have ever earned my trust on fast, predictable shipment are Amazon and Newegg. Every other site I've used has failed me in one way or another on fulfillment and lost my trust on predictability.