5 ms·
It's a big economy and changes take too long trickling down to those forgotten rural towns once part of the American economic engine. I'm pessimistic that the
by mc32 9y ago
It's a big economy and changes take too long trickling down to those forgotten rural towns once part of the American economic engine.
I'm pessimistic that the federal or even state governments have the will to do anything about it -in terms of policy to effect change.
Not that top down change always works (Japan for example, has made many, many half-hearted but ill-conceived attempts at restarting their growth engine) but smaller nimbler economies have been able to manoeuver economic obstacles (like Taiwan, Singapore and S. Korea) whereas others have stumbled and fumbled (Malaysia, Mexico).
That said, we need to try something. Trump tapped into this angst but does not look like he (or the party) will deliver in the least. Never the less, the issue is not going away and will only become more pronounced. Someone will have to do _something_ about it. People will get upset and more radical elements will be elected till someone begins to take notice and does something substantial about the economic decline of the part of the middle class which got by on medium skills.
- princeb 9y agoDo the changes need to trickle down to the dying towns? They are forgotten because they no longer have much value to people outside the towns. The town itself exists as a conduit through which people channel their energies together to bring value into their lives. If the conduit collapses, if the factories and the mills go, how can the people survive? The raison d'être of the communities has long passed away, but the community itself hasn't. Put them out of their misery, please! It is only by some miracle that these towns begin to bring value to the economy again (and not simply by the unsustainable method of spending and consuming), but until that happens they will continue to rot. Their minds can exist in the global hive-mind that is the internet, but their physical bodies need physical maintenance. And yet they exist too far away and too isolated to make it economically viable to do so. The major cities appear to have monopolized the exercise of human labour for value. Whereas early homo sapiens have loosely organized communities that work to maintain a loosely comfortable life, modern cities have concentrated human effort like a parabolic reflector in order to generate luxuries beyond the reach of mere casual cooperation. These small towns, without the buttress of a major industrial mill or any economic output at all, captures none of the benefits of living in a modern world. The consolation to the community that hopes to see the itself continue is that these towns are surprisingly hardy, producing generation after generation of brain-addled drug addicts. My sympathies are not with them.
- ryandrake 9y agoI grew up own one of these rural "rust belt" towns and it amazes me that it's still there, and that there are still plenty of people there doing god-knows-what. Once in a while I go home to visit my (retired) family and I wonder what in the world keeps all these people in these dying pseudo-towns, jobless, hopeless, angry at the world, addicted to meth, and blaming their lot on "the liberals". These communities are dead and they don't even know it. Maybe they do know it and they're just stubbornly clinging to a setting and lifestyle that has no future.
- kesselvon 9y agoThe breakdown occurred because we no longer prevent mergers and acquisitions on the basis of regional monopolies or impact on local economies, but on whether consumer prices are increased or decreased. Capital accumulates, and if you let it, it will suck everything out from the country and suburban areas and concentrate it in the major cities. The decline of rural America has everything to do with the flows of capital and not a lot to do with whether small towns are sustainable.
- princeb 9y agocapital goes where labour goes, and labour goes where capital goes. it's easy to forget that capital is not simply money but everything else that is not labour - buildings, facilities, machines, computers, etc. this is not a central planned economy. people organize where they want to organize and it turns out large cities are increasingly where people want to do that. people - the ones who choose neither to move to rural communities nor to bring custom - and not capital, are the systematic destroyer of local communities. mergers, like large cities, are just another symptom of humanity's unsatisfiable desire for efficiency. competition good, cooperation better.
- empath75 9y agoPay people to move to someplace where there are jobs, then return the land to nature.
- flyovercow 9y agoAs an open source programmer on projects with thousands of users and no income I find this hilarious. Just donate to people who are already making shit instead of inventing these bizarre schemes.
- x0x0 9y agoThere's absolutely nothing to be done. Most of those small rural towns -- and I grew up in one -- have zero reason to exist besides inertia. There's fewer skilled workers there every day, a combination of: * stupid, uneducated people / skilled people moving to population and manufacturing centers * devastation of unions which, whether you like their politics or not (I do!) often ran comprehensive training programs * the deskilling of the blue-collar workforce in America in order to boost corporate profits by outsourcing manufacturing * a decline in infrastructure, including a reasonably educated workforce, teachers + schools (see eg in WI Scott Walker cut many teachers salaries by north of $10k/year. Totes weird they keep losing skilled teachers, eh?) but also roads, power, etc Even if we were to fix the deliberate policies pushing outsourcing of manufacturing, I still see no reason it would return to places like rural Wisconsin. It would end up, rather, eg on the outskirts of Chicago, because of the same reason tech employees concentrate: you go to where there are skilled employees. Plus networks of supporting manufacturing businesses are close, good transportation and infrastructure, etc. And unlike tech, which may or may not eventually get serious about remote work, manufacturing can't do that. NB: This isn't the answer I would prefer, but it does have the benefit of being the truth. Also, while Democrats have not been a shining light in terms of supporting good jobs for people without a college degree, voting for Republicans is a pretty astoundingly stupid response.
- jjt-yn_t 9y agoA more hopeful counterpoint may I interject ? Nothing to be done... become educated [ re attract skilled workers... ] [ re establish unions ] [ excise tax on imports, >> rural centers for national infrastructure bring upto par again] [ de tax-avoidance plannings [ 'schemes' but don't use words of blame, so much as hopes for a future ] for large multinational corporations with an aim to de-deficit the country back to solvency and thus eventually un-welfare the rural portions to sustainability ... but way beyond my expertise, ... ]
- nihonde 9y agoI hate to say it, but it seems to be too late. I predict growth in discontent and discord, but little else ahead for the American experiment. The USA would be very lucky to fall as softly as Japan has since the 1980s. There's a complete vacuum of long-term thinking in America right now, and that erosion of thoughtful strategies will accelerate as desperation sets in. It's a shame to see such golden opportunities squandered, but humankind will have to adapt to the lessons from the fall of two Cold War superpowers if there's hope for a peaceful and prosperous future.