4 ms·
As the article points out the retail job crush is exactly because the Factorys closed, nothing more magical than there is less GDP so there is less work. Previo
by ChuckMcM 9y ago
As the article points out the retail job crush is exactly because the Factorys closed, nothing more magical than there is less GDP so there is less work. Previously those factory workers bought things at the store, but now that the factory is closed they can't (or they cut back) and the stores don't have some magical source of 'outside of market' money.
They call this out in a couple of places but they never seem to completely connect the dots, there is "He renovated the first floor to attract customers from farther away, customers who might have more money to spend and more places to go than Johnstown." to pull money from towns further away, or "But fewer people can afford his products now that the good jobs are long gone, and Mr. Apryle has had to make adjustments."
It's not Amazon, its not 'big box' chains, its that the city no longer has a production base and so the fraction of GDP this space used to produce has gone away.
- qubex 9y agoThis is exactly what I thought too: a drop in local GDP has caused a drop in aggregate demand for consumer goods and services. The only proviso is that some of the remains demand is served by out-of-county suppliers, including e-commerce operations that obviously have the advantage of convenience for the local consumers on account of their logistics.
- thirdsun 9y ago> It's not Amazon, its not 'big box' chains, its that the city no longer has a production base and so the fraction of GDP this space used to produce has gone away. I disagree. In my opinion this development is very much related to Amazon and e-commerce in general. I'm living in a rural region that saw a lot of retail disappearing, yet I really don't see people cutting back or buying less. They just buy elsewhere. And who could blame them? Researching products online provides way more information than your small store around the corner could offer. Selection is vastly superior on the internet - not just on Amazon and big brand stores, but countless of stores catering to niche interests. Those have never been around here. However even general goods like clothing, mainstream tech, etc. - very often I know what I want and find myself just as certain that it's not available locally. Just the other day I needed a new vacuum and decided to get a specific Miele model. Before ordering I wanted to see if I could get it immediately in a 30 minute drive radius and contacted several stores that were featured on Miele's list of retailers. Poor websites all over the place. So I sent an e-mail to all of them, asking if could come by later and pick up the specific model if it's available. No store replied within the day, none of the stores had the model which I was looking for, which wasn't very niche either. Didn't matter - later that day I ordered from Amazon and had it delivered the next day via Prime. I'm sorry, but when it comes to information, selection, availability and convenience there's simply no local competition for e-commerce.
- Spooky23 9y agoAmazon like most consolidators can still prosper amoungnst the ruins. I grew up in a rural mostly farming community. The farming part started dying when I was in school in the 90s. Now it's throughly dead. People are still surviving, but the "rich" folks are teachers, cops, and government workers who commute an hour to the state capital. When you drive though you can see the decay -- unpainted house here, barn with a hole in the roof there, dollar general store popping up over here. It's the inner city replicated in the countryside. There's more misery than there was 20 years ago.
- HillaryBriss 9y agoit's interesting that the 'rich' folks are government workers. maybe that's the employment model of the new normal in a LOT of places. it makes me wonder if, really, that's the model that has always been the norm, historically. i mean, when i think about the civil service jobs in the UK, or the true original civil service jobs in China going back centuries, i see a system where the brightest, most motivated minds compete for a limited number of government job posts - because those are the best jobs available. occasionally in history, there are times when the private sector offers paths to affluence for the masses, but mostly, that's not what happens. mostly, we're trying to get a legally protected, high-benefit position in government. most of the time, historically, that's the most lucrative path.
- kesselvon 9y agoGov't workers can't be outsourced overseas and they're usually able to pay well. This is why after an industrial base is wiped out, the only people making a decent salary work for the state. But these towns are going to keep getting wiped out until we free up the concentration of capital that favors dense urban areas
- coolgeek 9y ago> until we free up the concentration of capital that favors dense urban areas What is this supposed to mean? Is "favor[ing] dense urban areas" somehow wrong? What dark force is driving this concentration of capital? What is necessary to free it?
- devoply 9y agoWell you can't discount online shopping either. But yeah the local economy is a system set up like that. You have a main industry which has most of the money which then trickles down into the rest of the local economy via jobs at the big companies with the money. When those big companies disappear then there is little money left in the system. These sorts of towns soon disappear as young kids leave the city when they grow up to other cities with big companies that can give them adequate salaries.
- throwaway91111 9y agoI'm not seeing how you can discount Amazon, although i don't disagree with the gdp of the area dropping also contributing.
- losteric 9y agoIt's a vicious feedback loop that arguably does involve Amazon and other global retailers / manufacturing chains - although I wouldn't say they're at fault. Consumers are locally optimal buyers, we go for the cheapest goods on the market. Over time, international imports have been undercutting America-produced goods. At first, it was American companies that simply outsourced raw materials... then manufacturing, assembly, service centers, and now even R&D. All because consumers were chasing the locally optimal ROI. Rational consumers were undercutting their employers, which in turn forced their employers to cut labor, wages, or automate. That steadily drives down the purchasing freedom of employees, like a frog in a slowly warming pot of water. In turn, consumers are even more driven to seek out the cheapest goods, which are still international, and which continue the feedback loop that ultimately undercuts themselves. Eventually, we end up with an economy that cannot distribute wealth among the middle/lower classes due to large labor market inefficiencies (such as the difficulty adults face cross-training into/between knowledge-based fields)... All while the 1% and 0.1% continued building up tremendous wealth, buying a disproportionately loud voice in politics and public opinion. Amazon and Walmart are centralized manifestations of this issue, but no one person is to blame. This problem has been building for decades as America has refused to publicly invest in itself. As I see it, we need significant public investment in order to get back on track: * Infrastructure (water, energy, transportation esp. light rail), creating short-term jobs that improve regional economic competitiveness and reduce consumer debt * Higher education + adult cross training, restoring an efficient free labor market and voter literacy * Advanced R&D (incl. but not limited to space+energy), researching and commercializing new fields of industry to replace automated/exported ones We don't need to raise taxes. Start by cutting back excessive military funding. For perspective, we just spent ~$17.5 billion/10 years on one ship - the USS Gerald Ford supercarrier. Its defense ROI is questionable; counter-terror operations and force-projection against lesser states does not warrant a supercarrier (renovated carriers / allied regional airbases are sufficient), and potential threats punching at our level (China, Russia) would employee asymmetric warfare that makes carriers irrelevant (think: smart missile barrage, fast attack submarines, or maybe just propaganda). $17,500,000,000 could put 523,000 Americans through a 4 year private education or 1,750,000 through public state colleges. This sum is also equivalent to 30 years of fusion research funding, tripling the Seattle Link network, and 8x the the BART expansion to Santa Clara. Perhaps you have better examples, but these already offer better ROI than a war ship. There's plenty of fat that can be trimmed or reallocated from our $598,000,000,000 / year federal military budget.