6 ms·
There is no way to study 4chan. It's like an electron, if you measure it, it's position will change and you'll be back to the start. the majority of /pol/ post
by AndrewKemendo 9y ago
There is no way to study 4chan. It's like an electron, if you measure it, it's position will change and you'll be back to the start.
the majority of /pol/ posts (about 84%) are either neutral or negative
They are looking at a board full of "trolls trolling trolls" as they like to put it and then coming to the conclusion that everyone is negative. The leap then is when it comes to tying it to hate speech in the same context as would be elsewhere.
“Nigger” is the most popular hate word, used in more than 2% of posts, while “faggot” and “retard” appear in over 1% of posts.
I submit, based on my experience with /b/ in the past, that there is a different context behind the use of these words on 4chan versus the rest of the world. In fact in both of those cases a poster, typically "OP" is called one of those terms, viscerally and without thought for content or demographic makeup (largely because it's not known). So for example if you post a picture that is silly or not particularly relevant then a string of "OP is a faggot" comments will commence in an almost ritualized manner.
Further, it's only in the rarest cases that someone from outside of 4chan finds their way to any one of the boards (not crawled by google AFAIK) and then posts something, not understanding the community, it's like metafilter in that way. It's a self selected group of trolls, hackers and curious people. So I think this study comes to the wrong conclusions:
However, we are confident that our findings can serve as a foundation for interesting and valuable future work exploring fringe groups like the alt-right, hate speech, and online harassment campaigns
Extremely doubtful. 4Chan would be considered a "Chaotic Neutral" character. They do terrible stuff and great stuff, but no group can harness it for their own purposes. "Not your personal Army" is a common theme - which the study didn't even pay attention to. If the group smells blood they will attack, no matter who it is or what cause, "4 teh lulz." I mean that's where "Anonymous" basically originated.
This is a great example of how embedding yourself into a culture is the only way to understand it - which these researchers didn't do.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- formula1 9y agoWhile I appreciate the idea that nature is hard to predict. We have seen many cases where nature has a predictible flow. Now, predicting it and influencing it are two different concepts. And while a board based on mania and joy of free thought may be predictable, influence it may be more difficult due to an effective way of self preservation and reliance on truth based entertainment
- aphextron 9y ago>Extremely doubtful. 4Chan would be considered a "Chaotic Neutral" character. They do terrible stuff and great stuff, but no group can harness it for their own purposes. "Not your personal Army" is a common theme - which the study didn't even pay attention to. If the group smells blood they will attack, no matter who it is or what cause, "4 teh lulz." I mean that's where "Anonymous" basically originated. I think this sums up 2012 4chan perfectly. However things have changed drastically. There is an extremely rigid, narrowly defined viewpoint of alt-right Trumpism there now. If you do not fall in line with it, you will be ostracized and targeted for attack. Before it was all about the 'lulz' and attacking people for no good reason. It is now an organized right wing hate machine with a very specific ideology.
- nathanasmith 9y ago>I think this sums up 2012 4chan perfectly. However things have changed drastically. There is an extremely rigid, narrowly defined viewpoint of alt-right Trumpism there now. If you do not fall in line with it, you will be ostracized and targeted for attack. Before it was all about the 'lulz' and attacking people for no good reason. It is now an organized right wing hate machine with a very specific ideology. /pol/ is almost entirely satire. The fact that so many people are falling for said satire makes it even funnier.
- Shaanie 9y agoThere are plenty of people that do not see large parts of /pol/ as satire. In fact, I wouldn't be surprised if a majority of the posters on /pol/ largely agree with the general culture. It's interesting to me that you assume that it's entirely satire because that's not at all the view I have, nor the view of my friends who regularly post there.
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoI was a light browser of /b/ and /pol/ in the early run up of the election and watched how they basically took the joke idea of Trump and ran with it because so many people were incredulous. When Trump started gaining some steam it leaped over to reddit and took on it's own life, but from what I saw on /b/ it was just about "rustling jimmies" of anyone who would respond and ramping that up because of the chaos it would cause. I suppose that it's possible that some kind of right wing hate machine took over, but more than likely it's just an amplification of the past. Those clowns posted and discussed nazi/gore/anti-feminist/boxxy crap since literally forever.
- rublev 9y agoThese researchers will never organically reach 4chan because they are most likely well adjusted people. They have no need for such a community.