3 ms·
Not very surprised, the game has been a trainwreck in the making from the beginning. Total scope was just way too overambitious, and people weren't going to plo
by TulliusCicero 9y ago
Not very surprised, the game has been a trainwreck in the making from the beginning. Total scope was just way too overambitious, and people weren't going to plow hundreds and thousands of dollars into spaceship jpegs forever.
- norswap 9y agoPrecisely, and this has been painfully obvious for a long time. Not even to me (I don't really follow the game) but to a few people whose opinion I respect, including multiple video game journalists.
- shadowmint 9y agoCare to qualify that? I'm not following this at all, but I can't see anything particularly obvious that's a 'train wreck'. They have a game. It's playable, if not particularly good. Some people are playing it (or something? Someone is posting gameplay videos anyway). I have zero investment in it so I don't really get it; I see a lot of unhappy people making :( faces. Games take time and money to make. They're making it. It's not done yet. They're keeping in touch with people and releasing regular updates. I mean, what do you want them to do? Not make it? Make it faster? Communicate more? Communicate differently? That's really good compared to some crowd funding people... isn't it? ...? Where's the drama?
- strathmeyer 9y agoThe problem comes with advertising and selling products that they haven't made yet.
- quakenul 9y agoThe drama basically arises from where common people are a good source of funds but actually terrible investors, giving personal money by impulse, usually without being equipped with the industry insight to evaluate the risks, or fully accepting there are risks because they are too emotionally invested in the product.
- sillysaurus3 9y agoMaybe so, but it's probably important not to enact regulations preventing people from doing this. Otherwise we'll lose all the things that Kickstarter et al. helped create. Anyone who's loved the game Undertale will tell you that was a fine use of their funds. But games like that wouldn't be possible without unsophisticated investors throwing their money at it in small quantities.
- wcummings 9y agoThere's a lot of stuff on Kickstarter that looks a lot like fraud, I think people see this as part of a trend. You don't have to ban it, just give the "investors" more recourse.
- LMYahooTFY 9y agoWhy is it the hip and cool thing to call the entire project a train wreck without any actual supporting evidence? Half the subreddit seems to be die hard acolytes while the other half seem to be extremely bitter vets of a game that hasn't been launched. The biggest game development project ever, with extraordinary transparency, and shoddy bloggers are still making money throwing out talking points about how it's a train wreck barely half way through development. Again: without any actual proof. However, if there is any, I will gladly change my opinion.
- gdulli 9y agoThey successfully got the evidence scrubbed from the internet. That must have been expensive. http://www.oneangrygamer.net/2017/03/controversial-star-citizen-articles-removed-from-the-escapist/27419/ http://www.oneangrygamer.net/2017/03/controversial-star-citi...
- LMYahooTFY 9y agoThe article ends with a disclaimer saying it's all inconclusive. It "must have been" nothing or anything. Maybe they actually reached a mutual agreement. Who knows. What it must be is an expensive and elaborate scam that is in league with moon landing conspiracies.
- resf 9y agoYou're right about one thing, it's a "game development project", it's not a game.
- LMYahooTFY 9y agoAre you implying anything? It's a game that's not complete. What of it?