4 ms·
> Microsoft started by doing what every other OS maker was already doing I don't think "but everyone else is doing" is a good argument, but I'm not aware of e.
by xg15 9y ago
> Microsoft started by doing what every other OS maker was already doing
I don't think "but everyone else is doing" is a good argument, but I'm not aware of e.g. any popular Linux doing this. (There are some that do collect telemetry, but there is always an option to turn it off, if nothing else uninstalling the telemetry service)
> But MSFT listened and provided additional privacy controls
Yes, they used to provide 15 different options to configure the telemetry and none to turn it off. Now they offer 20 different options and still none to turn it off.
But those things aren't actually relevant to my main point. The technical details don't matter that much, because at the current time, Microsoft's reputation concerning updates has gotten bad enough that completely non-savy users are downloading dubious 3rd-party tools to disable updates for completely irrational reasons. This is a PR damage that Microsoft should be intereststed in fixing (for example by making the update process less forceful, more transparent and giving meaningful choice)
The actions during the transition and the current strategy seem to go in the exact opposite direction.
(Replying to this from another post[1] to simplify threading)
> But you have to think about it from MSFT's perspective. We are promising that if you move to Win10 you will always be up-to-date for the rest of the lifetime of Windows. You'll never pay for another upgrade/update. The benefit to MSFT is that if they get everyone over to 10, they only have to support a single core OS instead of backporting every single bug and security fix.
Actually, no, I don't have to think of it from Microsoft's perspective. I can think of all kinds of reasons why this strategy is beneficial to Microsoft - but this misses a lot of ways where it csn be absolutely not beneficial to the users:
First, this implies that "being up to date" is something users always want - an assumption that e.g. users of legacy software that doesn't work on Windows 10 can savely reject.
Then there is the scope of updates that seem to not just include bug fixes and adjustments to standards but new features, deprecation of old features, UI changes and even new applications. (E.g., I think the Creator's update installed some kind if 3D paint thing on my machine that I never requested).
This is demanding constant energy from users to manage and gives the impression of a system that is in constant flux and that cannot be trusted. You can manage functionality X by setting Y? Who knows, maybe it's all different after the next update...