5 ms·
A chef who’s debunking detox, diets and wellness
- al_chemist 9y agoThis guy links detox, diet, wellness, Brexit and Trump. That's typical "we are wise, they are stupid" stance.
- epx 9y agoThe guy lost me when linked home-cooked food with misogyny.
- emodendroket 9y ago"Sugar is good, even though it's high in calories yet doesn't make you feel any fuller, because you need calories to live" seems like an odd claim too, given that we don't live in a society where most people are suffering from insufficient caloric intake.
- throwaway91111 9y agoAnd yet, i still need quick calories to catch a bus in the morning. Amazing!
- emodendroket 9y agoYeah, nothing wakes you up in the morning like a Coca-Cola.
- throwaway91111 9y agoCalories aren't directly related to arousal to my knowledge, aside from needing to feed ones self. My point being: you're ignoring obvious benefits by hyperbolizing having a piece of toast to put something in your stomach before leaving the house.
- benchaney 9y agoYour previous post makes it sound like you are consuming a significant amount of sugar in the morning, so i don't really think GP is hyperbole.
- emodendroket 9y agoI imagine most people (surely me) are mostly thinking of added simple sugar when they talk about avoiding sugar, and not the carbohydrates in a slice of toast. But really I don't see the benefits as entirely "obvious" to having toast rather than, say, eggs.
- smt88 9y agoThat's a social issue/argument. Does it make his scientific claims invalid?
- devoply 9y agoWell it does not seem to me that he's making any scientific claims, just opinionated claims. Which is his right, just as much as it's might right to voice my own opinionated claims as a eater of food.
- smt88 9y agoHe makes many claims that are based on science (e.g. nutritional value of various ingredients, health effects of food processing, etc.) Do his social views make his analysis of those studies invalid?
- devoply 9y agohttps://www.newscientist.com/article/2098199-lets-ditch-the-idea-that-only-home-cooked-food-is-good-for-kids/ https://www.newscientist.com/article/2098199-lets-ditch-the-... Apparently it's a thing, and just shows this whole line of thought has sort of jumped the shark...
- emodendroket 9y ago> It found that home-made meals based on 408 bestselling cookbook recipes for infants and young children are not always healthier than ready meals and convenience products. In fact, on many measures they seemed less healthy: they tended to have a lower vegetable variety per meal and were more likely to exceed maximum recommendations for energy and fat content. Is that representative of what the average person cooks?
- watwut 9y agoCookbooks are probably not representative of actual cooking, but it is hard to judge whether average cooking is healthier. It is impossible to judge how much less healthy it would be if people who are cool not cooking for children switched to cooking. It is good point through, not everything that comes in can is bad for you.
- emodendroket 9y agoRight. I guess the claim has always been that if you made it you know what's in it and you're less likely to unwittingly consume an extreme amount of sugar or whatever. I don't know how accurate that is.
- belorn 9y agoOne of the biggest problem I had with that statement is how extremely unscientifically it was. Home cooking don't take a constant amount of time and vary based on what food you make and how many people there is in the household. Some people like me do once a month cooking where you dedicate almost a whole day per month, usually a day on the weekend. If you are a single person then you might not even need to cook that often.
- TwoBit 9y agoAren't keto diets about making you more satiated and not about nutrition? I thought I've read that people have done a better job losing weight on such diets.
- mistermann 9y agoMost anything I've read most people's "stats" (cholesterol, blood pressure) improve once on a keto diet.
- akytt 9y agoWhere did you read that? How many were in the sample, how long was the diet, was it a double-blind test, what was the significance of the find? That's exactly his point: people write a lot of stuff on the internet that they believe or think is true. It might even work on them because of placebo efect. But it does mean these statements are facts.
- mistermann 9y agoThe burden of proof is identical on the other side as well, so until then the conclusion is null and all we have are anecdotal stories, of which there are a lot. It's interesting to see the emotional attachment naysayers have to low carb diets. I can understand advocates having an emotional attachment due to how it has changed their lives in a positive way, often after years if not decades of failure, but the strong emotional response it invokes in people whose lives are literally not affected in any way but are for some reason strongly repulsed by the very idea, almost as if there is something within the human psyche. Very interesting.
- sargun 9y agoI lost ~60 lbs on a keto diet, but every stat was unsafe, and I felt awful in ways I'd never felt before.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- revscat 9y agoMy anecdotal experience is that I have lost ~15 pounds since I started keto a month ago, with no change to exercise habits. He may have a strong opinion, but I am not sure how based in science it is.
- emodendroket 9y agoWhat's dismaying about weight loss isn't that people can't manage to lose weight but that the success rates in keeping it off over the longer term (5 or 10 years) are extremely bad for just about every method except stomach stapling.
- taneq 9y agoThat's thanks (IMO) to the existence of a huge industry dedicated to convincing people that "a diet" is a temporary change in what you eat, after which you can once again throw restraint to the wind.
- watwut 9y agoNot only that. Many diets are not sustainable - you can't keep them long term and perform well enough on work. They work by keeping you with low energy which affects your performance. Plus you are miserable practicaly constantly while keeping them. The other reason is that they alter how your body works - meaning it is much easier to gain weight after dieting then before. You body adjusts to hunger by making fat reserves asap.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- emodendroket 9y agoI don't think so. Your body works hard to maintain stasis.
- taneq 9y agoIt really doesn't. Humans (like all animals) tend to do everything based on rates rather than absolute measurements, so setpoints drift all over the place with time.
- haburka 9y agoI mean obviously sugar is not toxic. I think most people that do low sugar and no sugar diets are aware of that. Instead, they understand that there's way too much sugar out there and it is very addictive. That's the issue with this kind of anti-homeopathy reasoning, it's mostly just an attack on non-scientists who have their own theories and claims. However, science has a lot of gaps, especially when it comes to nutrition. It's very hard to be precise with it.
- appleshore 9y agoIf you're on a low carb diet, sugar can give you a headache so in that way it does feel toxic. But is that just because your body isn't use to it?
- tzs 9y agoFor the year to date, I've gotten 33% of my calories from carbs (and 25% from protein, 42% from fat). 23% of the carbs have been added sugars, or 7% of overall calories. I know that's not actually a low carb diet, at least by the standards most people use when they talk about low carb, but it is quite a bit lower in carbs than what the average American eats. I've been eating this way since September 2015, and even this moderate reduction in sugar has been enough to cause a change in how I react to sugar. I don't suffer any adverse reaction, such as headaches, if I have something high in sugar. Well, at least nothing I have ever noticed. What has changed is that I just don't find anything particularly attractive about high sugar foods any more. For example, if someone brings in donuts for the office and I eat one or two it tastes OK, but it is nothing special. It's not really a treat like it would have been a a few years ago. I will now almost always pick a salty snack like potato chips over a sugary snack.
- akytt 9y agoScience has gaps because scientist do not know things. Non-scientist going "based on what happened to my cousin, this must have been what happened" is not going to fill the gaps in knowledge.
- 9y ago
- appleshore 9y agoThe traditional dismissal of detoxes is that your body naturally detoxes itself. If it was full of toxins, you'd be sick. Can anyone parse that with those who get mercury toxicity from eating too much sushi? And how is sugar an important building block of life? I'm presume he means calories are important, and he's not referring to glycobiology.
- majkinetor 9y agoToxicity, when fat starts to burn down, is well known phenomena in medicine. You can be poisoned and toxins can be 'stored' in fat for years, depending on their type, then one day when you start melting that you start to experience symptoms. > And how is sugar an important building block of life? Not very much, since there is no such thing as sugar deficiency and liver can make its own via gluconeogenesis. Unless you have impaired liver or are starving, sugar probably has little value.
- chiefalchemist 9y agoToxic or not, sugar is unnecessary. Just look around. It's not healthy, literally, to allow people to believe sugar is okay. The context matters. And in the context of most people's diet and lifestyle giving up sugar is probably the quickest and smartest thing they can do. Else, we have the status quo. Clearly, that's not working.