5 ms·
5 years ago for .Net was a very long time ago. Back then the only games in town were C++, java or .net. The former was for the hardcore, the other two were writ
by mattmanser 16y ago
5 years ago for .Net was a very long time ago. Back then the only games in town were C++, java or .net. The former was for the hardcore, the other two were written by programmers who had no clue what they were doing. You're just taking a memory of what it used to be like and comparing it to what you know in OSS today.
You're talking before the fairly meteoric rise in the standard of web programming over the past few years. Before blogs. When tables vs divs was an actual argument. When C++ was relevant in anything apart from high performance programming.
You're also talking about .Net 2.0, pre-LINQ, extension methods and MVC.
And reading your post makes it sound more that you have a chip on your shoulder about bad programmers more than anything else:
lazy, non-challenged developers
ASP.NET is a hulking piece of shit, anyone that tells you otherwise is lying and/or too stupid to realize it
other .NET developers you know are unchallenged nitwits without any sense of vision, any sense of craft. A bunch of me too dim wits who collect paychecks by copying and pasting their way to completion
redmond regurgitating drone army
There are lots of jobs in .Net or java. There's sweet fa for a crap programmer in OSS. Once you realise that is the reason you came across so many crap programmers, perhaps you can understand that there's nothing actually wrong with .Net, it was actually a pretty fucking big revolution. On the other hand you will still come across .Net programmers who think datatables are pretty funky, rely heavily on view state and bizarrely believe .Net controls aren't the spawn of the devil.
As for the rest of it, honestly, 'Win2K server admin', um, it's moved on man. Stop beating the straw doll. 'The world is open now', look a little more objectively at the world we actually live in. Did you even notice the iPhone come out a few years back? Or the Kindle? Or all the other closed source proprietary systems that a me too OS movement gleefully copies, badly for the most part. There's plenty of room at the table for both.
Yes MS have turned into a pretty crap company under Ballmer, but their language teams are still pretty damn good.
The reality is you've become a more experienced programmer. And somehow you're magically attributing it to OSS instead of just knowing more than when you were wet behind the ears.
- mkramlich 16y agoNo there really is a big difference in the culture, ecosystem and average programmer between the FOSS/Unix world and the Microsoft world. Individuals always vary sure. Exceptions to the rule, sure. But there is a very real difference between those two worlds. I'd say almost every programmer who has been around long enough, and exposed to both camps, realizes this. Do a survey of say the top 100 famous "elite" programmers in our industry and I bet the overwhelming majority would agree with this characterization. The evidence is out there. And yes, Microsoft has been trying to get more and more Unixy over the years, and more and more Appley, and I'll bet they continue doing that in the future. Good for them.
- Groxx 16y agoOr all the other closed source proprietary systems that a me too OS movement gleefully copies, badly for the most part. OSS and proprietary seem on opposite sides of support-systems and customer-facing systems. Proprietary > OSS for users' visual cortex, OSS > proprietary for everything supporting that top layer. I think part of it is that OSS UI reeks of design-by-committee. Which is something Apple has gotten ridiculously correct. UI needs to be unified and have a flow to it, something which you're more likely to get from a single (highly skilled) person than from a thousand.
- krakensden 16y ago> I think part of it is that OSS UI reeks of design-by-committee. I hate reading this. It shows little experience with with open source programs, and ignorance of how open source programs work. There are hardly any OSS projects with thousands of people- in fact, the only one I can think of is the Linux kernel. Most GUIs in the open source world are worked on by one or two people. Firefox is a good example. Ben Goodger and (one?) other person did essentially all the UI work. Now, it's true that there are a lot of open source programs with terrible user interfaces. Some of this is because of the strong connection between *nix and OSS, and the primitive toolkits available 15 years ago. Some of this is because it's written without an end user focus. Sometimes the authors don't care. Some of it just sucks. It's true that Apple has had a lot of success by paying a lot of attention to UI issues. But they're not only different from the majority of OSS software, they're different from the majority of proprietary software. Have you ever tried to explain to someone how to use Opera, or Internet Explorer? Word? Security products like Symantec? The world is filled with baffling crap, it has nothing to do with the licensing scheme. In short, I am bothered by your generalization because it I believe it to be untrue, and worse, unexamined.
- Groxx 16y agoWorked on by one or two people, but criticized and improved (and suggested, influentially) by many. Committee. The point isn't how many people write code for the UI, the point is how many people influence (or control) the direction of the UI. Just look at Ubuntu's interface preferences. Committee. Everyone wants an option, so they're all there. Perfect for alienating everyone who doesn't want all the options. I.e., 99% of the world. Look at <OSS program X> and poke around (especially the popular ones - try Open Office). You'll find bajillions of settings which prevent average people from going deeper and improving their experience. edit: granted, this is changing in a few areas. Rails, for instance, is convention over configuration - and look at how successful it's been. Mobile apps have been revolutionized by Apple's apps, and developers all over are rushing to mimic it. People are starting to learn, but it's a long way to the top, and the vast majority of the improvements seem to be originating from companies, not OSS groups.
- rbanffy 16y ago> 5 years ago for .Net was a very long time ago. Back then the only games in town were C++, java or .net. Wow! I was building sites with Zope by 2002. There were far better alternatives than C++, Java and .NET far earlier than 5 years ago. I did lots and lots of Perl since 1996 and some PHP thrown in around 2000. Only used C++ and Java when nothing else would do (mostly because of clients that had too much of the wrong Kool-Aid). Microsoft has been crappy for a very long time.
- eru 16y ago> Back then the only games in town were C++, java or .net. About what domain are you talking? Perl and PHP were also quite popular in web development as far as I can recall. And several others.