5 ms·
Windows is an operating system, not a game. Many of us don't necessarily want the latest bells, whistles, unlockable achievements, and optional DLC, and we res
by CamperBob2 9y ago
Windows is an operating system, not a game. Many of us don't necessarily want the latest bells, whistles, unlockable achievements, and optional DLC, and we resent having them shoved down our throats with no input in the matter.
And as for bug fixes, many of us were perfectly satisfied with the stability and even the security of Windows 7.
Hence the appeal of LTSB.
- dlp211 9y agoHere's the problem. Windows is for everyone, the vast majority of people will run Windows on their desktop and laptop PCs. The vast majority of people also know nothing about computing and OS security. The vast majority of people will rely on someone that is "computer savvy". If Microsoft had an OS that met the needs of what probably amounts to < 1% of the total market; that is people that want to, and know how to manage updates; it would be abused by those "computer savvy" people and by extension ultimately wind up in the hands of people that have no business running it as an OS. Then we end up with a whole bunch of computers that will fall victim to the next "Wanna Cry" and you know who people will blame, Microsoft for not keeping their device patched and secure. Disclaimer: I work for Microsoft as part of the Windows org, but generally do not work much on the OS or its applications and the opinions I put forward are mine and mine alone.
- throwaway2048 9y agoIts great we have father Microsoft that knows best for all of us. Paternalism ensuring we can't hurt ourselves on the pointy bits.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- xg15 9y agoStandard counter-argument: Then be respectful of the trust people (voluntarily or not) place in you and don't abuse the update channel. The problem is that Windows updates have gotten a bad reputation which is partially justified by the tracking and nagware during the Windows 10 transition. If the reputation gets too bad, then even non-computer-savy people will start to turn off updates - with even worse consequences for security.
- dlp211 9y agoMicrosoft started by doing what every other OS maker was already doing by collecting telemetry (note: they weren't selling it). A minor community of users caused a massive uproar about the telemetry coming off the device despite the fact that you could always turn it down to basic level which was essentially crash dumps and the info we need to not push you a bad update. But MSFT listened and provided additional privacy controls AND they made it so that you have to go through them on upgrade and install. If you continue to bash on a company even as it makes attempts to listen and respond to its users, then there is no reason for the company to continue to listen.
- wfunction 9y ago> despite the fact that you could always turn it down to basic level which was essentially crash dumps Crash dumps contain memory dumps, right? Memory dumps can contain passwords and other sensitive data, right? Whom are you trying to fool?
- dlp211 9y agoWhich MSFT has been collecting since Win XP SP2. There are plenty of other OS's that do the same thing and plenty more than don't. If you are that paranoid, you are more than welcome to not use Windows/not work at a place that uses Windows/not use your passwords and usernames when using Windows.
- wfunction 9y ago> Which MSFT has been collecting since Win XP SP2 Didn't they let you disable it though? Unlike what you just claimed is the case in Win10? > you are more than welcome to not use Windows Yes, and people would avoid upgrading to Windows 10 because of this, if you didn't shove it down their throats. Which is of course why you had to do that in the first place.
- dlp211 9y ago
- hedora 9y agoThe number of people I've met that are happy about new Windows 10 features outnumber the ones that would rather stick with win7 + security updates (without the privacy invading stuff). The ratio is 5:1 if I ignore "computer savvy" people. (Actually, it is 5:0, but I'll be generous to MS on this). If I include tech savvy people, the ratio goes up. I don't know any "normal" users that voluntarily upgraded to Win 10, though I don't know any that successfully blocked the upgrade either. From what the article says, and based on their comments to me, the normal users I know would all prefer LTSB to consumer Win10.
- wfunction 9y ago> The number of people I've met that are happy about new Windows 10 features outnumber the ones that would rather stick with win7 + security updates (without the privacy invading stuff). And what about Windows 8.1 (with classic shell, not Metro)?
- hedora 9y agoI'm the only one I know with 8.1. Metro is fine, from what I can tell. There are zero complaints about tiles in the start menu. It's more "WTF is it doing in the background?" (usually ram, hd or isp issues, or maybe random candy crush / lock screen spam) Next: "I can't rely on it working, since it stalls for seconds on end" Followed by: "Can you turn all of the data collection / spam off?" And finally: "I guess I'll just use my phone/tablet. That sucks"
- wfunction 9y agoHaha I see, interesting, okay thanks :)
- yuhong 9y agoReminds me of https://twitter.com/yuhong2/status/853704702705377280 https://twitter.com/yuhong2/status/853704702705377280 . As a side note, I should mention that Win10 1507 support has been extended an extra month at the time of this writing (Pro editions has the CBB option, Home don't). That June update has its own known bugs which MS will have to fix too. Also to OP: Be aware of the about box.
- gerdesj 9y ago"Here's the problem. Windows is for everyone" No it isn't. It's just another OS. My wife (who no-one would ever describe as a nerd) uses Arch Linux on her laptop. She doesn't really know that and does not care - it simply works. My support burden dramatically reduced when I removed the pre-installed OS. At the risk of sounding like a complete wanker: I will almost certainly know more about Windows than you will ever want to know (but I have never had source code access). I used to be able to get around 620Kb free RAM available on DOS 6 (nee Quick and Dirty OS) without resorting to QEMM and have dealt with all the weird shit that your employers have chucked out since then. At some time in the early nineties I discovered there was choice. Your employer was no longer the only game in town. Ok there was Acorn and Apple and stuff. Nowadays, I see your employer as a bit of an inconsequential (with history) hindrance to progress - soz Cheers Jon PS My firm is also an MS "partner" sigh
- syrrim 9y agoLTSB comes with security fixes, and therefore is not susceptible to wannacry and similar exploits.
- Spooky23 9y agoThat argument held water until you consider that Windows 7 exists, and had Microsoft invested in building that platform in a sane way at any point in the last upgrade instead of going off the rails (again) with Windows 8 and making Windows 10 something that looks like legacy windows, life would be simpler. For my employer the solution to this problem for higher end users is easy -- Apple.
- Spooky23 9y agoThat argument held water until you consider that Windows 7 exists, and had Microsoft invested in building that platform in a sane way at any point in the last upgrade instead of going off the rails (again) with Windows 8 and making Windows 10 something that looks like legacy windows, life would be simpler. For my employer the solution to this problem for higher end users is easy -- Apple.
- izacus 9y agoThere's a difference between "latest bells" and having basic bug fixes like proper response to HiDPI screens and working start menu.
- CamperBob2 9y agoI don't have a high-DPI screen, so that's neither here nor there. And nobody running Classic Shell is complaining about not having a working Start menu. Those complaints are all coming from people with a stock Windows installation.
- izacus 9y agoWell... good for you for not having a modern laptop or screen? O.o Not sure what your point here is.
- CamperBob2 9y agoI do have a modern screen, but regrettably for the fortunes of the Windows team, it's on an iPad.
- stinkytaco 9y agoIt might be here or there to some of us, I think that's the original poster's point. It's great that LTSB works for you, but even then you are applying third party software to get it to basic functionality. I'm curious why you don't run Windows 7? It doesn't EOL for 2 1/2 more years.
- CamperBob2 9y agoTo be clear, I do run Windows 7. I'm a one-man shop, so Microsoft won't sell me a Windows 10 LTSB license at any reasonable price.
- alkonaut 9y agoThe thing is - you like Win7 because is basically Vista with years of polish! It's done. I'll be perfectly happy with an LTSB version of Win10 but right now Win10 is where Vista or Win8.0 was. If you run Win10 now you will want that first year of polish. I'm forced to run Win10 and my home machine (which is on the fast insider ring) is so much better than my ltsb machine. If I were risk averse or preferred stability then I wouldn't run Win10 at all, I'd do Win7 for another year, until there is an LTSB version of what Win10 is now at the most recent builds.