6 ms·
How totalism works
- nosound_badday 9y agoIt doesn't help that a lot of it isn't illegal.
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 9y agoWell, it's worse than that. Irrational belief systems are actually generally considered to be worthy of respect, which makes it culturally difficult to do something about the cases where the effects of those beliefs are extreme.
- ue_ 9y agoI personally respect them for if I did not respect them then it would be an affront to freedom. As much as the concept of "tolerance" is criticised (more recently from those people who, I think rightly, are tired of only being "tolerated") I think that people should be allowed to believe whatever they want to believe. I think the problem is when mockery of such systems is disallowed. I don't know about other religions, but the Buddhist approach has been to neither become prideful and puffed up when one congratulates one's religion, but not to lose one's temper or become sad when one criticises it. In the former case one should say "yes, you are right, well said". In the latter, one should say "no, you are wrong, here is why..." Unfortunately I can't find the citation in the Buddhist Pali Canon at the moment despite searching for what I thought were the keywords, though what I say is probably what one might expect from Buddhism.
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 9y ago> I personally respect them for if I did not respect them then it would be an affront to freedom. First, please distinguish respect for the person from respect for their beliefs. A person's beliefs (as long as those do not include the intent to harm others) should have no effect whatsoever on what rights they have, and on being accepted and treated as a human being equal to all other human beings in society. That is respect for the person. However, when a scientologist believes that Xenu's army dropped hydrogen bombs into vulcanoes in order to free the thetans from their bodies (or whatever exactly the story is, theology is not my expertise), there is absolutely no room for respect for that, it is bullshit and should be called out as just that. And there is one very important reason for that: Respect for those beliefs by society is one factor that keeps people trapped in these belief systems, which is very much the opposite of freedom. There are more than enough people who will tell you that they wished someone had shown them earlier how ridiculous and irrational the beliefs they were indoctrinated into were instead of validating it by pretending it was worthy of respect, because they could have started earlier to live a life free from a completely irrational fear of hell, for example. Respecting ideas that suppress people's free development does not contribute to freedom. > I think the problem is when mockery of such systems is disallowed. Well, yeah, but that is directly interlinked with the idea of respect for irrational belief systems. Mocking something is inherently not respecting the thing.
- literallycancer 9y ago>As much as the concept of "tolerance" is criticised (more recently from those people who, I think rightly, are tired of only being "tolerated") I think that people should be allowed to believe whatever they want to believe. In my mind, respect is something that's earned rather than expected. People should be able to believe whatever they want, but as soon as it affects anything they do, any such "respect" becomes counterproductive. E.g. respecting anti-vaxxer beliefs, how would that even work? Would you rather be in a crisis situation with a person who will pray for your well-being instead of actually helping you when it's needed?
- dsr_ 9y agoRight/wrong and legal/illegal are only related to each other, not identical. The difference between informed voluntary weird behavior and non-informed compelled behavior is not necessarily obvious. Consider the boot-camp experience of joining the armed forces: is it right? Is it legal? Is it different in kind or degree from a cult indoctrination?
- CalChris 9y agoSounds like Scientology and a dozen other isms. However, why after freeing yourself from something so insipid would you then dedicate a PhD to studying it? That's insane. It's like getting out of prison and setting up a lean to tent next to the prison wall.
- chris_st 9y agoI dunno, seems brave to me. I think she's trying to shed light on something horrible, to help others. Hope it helps...
- gbhn 9y agoI've known people who have left groups not as intensely controlling as this, but very controlling. There is typically a very long period where they aren't directly controlled by the group, but are very much still "engaged" in the sense that their interests still intersect quite a bit with the group. (Wanting to spread warnings, rescue people they know, etc.) I'm sure there's a psychological model for this, but I think that's why there's so many "ex-XYZ" groups. Leaving is both abrupt and lengthy. Especially so, I imagine, for a group so totally psychologically consuming.
- gumby 9y agoShe is doing important work. The attachment theory is just as applicable to emergent phenomena than Nazism or death cults. Just consider those (depending on your PoV): "violent radical leftists"/"idiotic racist Trump supporters" -- just announcing such labels requires a strong binding to what you consider the "opposite" (and correct) view.
- rwmj 9y agoI wonder if this is a "bug" in humans, or serves some evolutionary purpose -- perhaps in keeping small tribes together.
- fallingfrog 9y agoFrom what I've read, the tendency to form cliques or tribes goes back to the hunter-gatherer days, while heirarchy and authority are a newer development that appeared with the first large agricultural societies. We've all been indoctrinated from birth to a culture of authority to some degree or another, but it continues to feel oppressive to be told what to do all day at work. So you tell people that you're providing them an escape from all that, that you're going to set them free, but the habit of reflexive submission is so ingrained that you can use that urge to enslave them more completely.
- fallingfrog 9y agoSo to me it looks like the friction between the desire of the individual to not be controlled, and the requirement of civilization that they do what they are told, is a fundamental flaw that can never be reconciled, and will always create an opportunity for a charismatic leader who will say, I will set you free- but first, I need your unquestioning obedience.
- sebastianconcpt 9y agoGood piece. Also Posmodernism and Nihilism create this context in mass making narrative and hysteria be the new source of life meaning (which they never provide). Due to nihilism it really isn't life meaning so the psyche is desperately set to seek political meaning externally i.e. the collective and "fight for social justice". Which is endless and unattainable but the seeking desire fills the gap. Simultaneously, posmodern techniques erode values and logic so reality becomes "maleable" (so the guy more vulnerable to be manipulated into "mass of manouver", "useful idiots", etc). This way people is set in a downward spiral of all kinds of marxist self-victimisms (blaming the 100% of oneself miseries to any external "structure" which is trendy to attack at any given epoch). Is sad to see people falling into this.
- ue_ 9y ago>Also Posmodernism and Nihilism create this context in mass making narrative and hysteria be the new source of life meaning Have you read anything by Adorno, and Guy Debord's Society of the Spectacle? This kind of thing is taken from a different direction, looking from the perspective of how the capitalist mode of production has shaped society. >so the psyche is desperately set to seek political meaning externally Nihilism doesn't mean you have no goals, or that you can't make your own meaning. It only purports that there is no meaning to our lives in general. Perhaps the only forces contrary to this are religions (and to be clear, by no stretch do I think religion is a Bad Thing). Your meaning can come internally, or perhaps some people just find they don't need a meaning. Your claim doesn't really fit that well with others, as in the past (and still in the present) non-nihilists sought meaning outside their own lives, such as by having children to "leave something behind". Although what you say may seem true, I don't think it is all that much, and I think you're overstating the effect that postmodern thought has had. The "fight for social justice" is not about reaching a utopia, it is about improving conditions; arguably most political ideologies are fights for some kind of social justice. If you really want to relate this to Marxism as you have, I must note that Marx considered Communism in the same way in The German Ideology: Communism is for us not a state of affairs which is to be established , an ideal to which reality [will] have to adjust itself. We call communism the real movement which abolishes the present state of things. The conditions of this movement result from the premises now in existence. >Simultaneously, posmodern techniques erode values and logic so reality becomes "maleable" What's wrong with this? It seems that you are attaching a cultural connection to postmodern thought, one which need not necessarily exist. The "erosion" you speak of happens through deconstruction (to my knowledge), which I think can be used as a powerful tool. The state of things, if it is worthwhile, ought to stand up to the test in my opinion. >This way people is set in a downward spiral of all kinds of marxist self-victimisms This is an uncharitable and frankly incorrect vision of Marxism. It's not about blaming your miseries on others, it's about looking to see the functioning of the system we live in. Marxism is a method of analysis (having spread from its birth in political economy right round to literature to geography) and as such it doesn't imply certain conclusions from the outset. If it were as self-victimising as you claim, it would have to start from that position. But it doesn't; Marx's analysis starts with political economy in general. Through analysis, Marx claims to have found interesting facts: the functioning of value, the theory of surplus value, and from this the exploitation of the proletariat. You misunderstand the Marxian structure model; he does not present the base and superstructure to be things to blame, but rather as any person would see, the explanation of how our relationship to our means of sustenance (i.e how we are able to live, literally) shapes all other aspects of our lives in what we see as culture in general. One last point: Marx was not really a utopian socialist (like Robert Owen was), and you'll find no shortage of Socialist thinkers who will re-iterate that Socialism is not some pill that you swallow and everything is fine. As I'm sure you'd agree with me, it's worth arguing against such ideologies. But Marxism is not one.
- empath75 9y agoI feel like sean spicer and Kelly Anne Conway might want to read this.
- rjeli 9y agoHere's a chilling story from a local cult currently operating in the Bay Area: https://www.facebook.com/confessionsucberkeley/posts/882903461742282 https://www.facebook.com/confessionsucberkeley/posts/8829034...
- TazeTSchnitzel 9y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EBK5aKOr2Fw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EBK5aKOr2Fw
- cousin_it 9y agoDoes the US have more cults than European countries? Or is it just that US folks who leave cults are more vocal about it?
- kovrik 9y agoWhat strikes me is the fact that many people can definitely and clearly believe that 'cults are bad and dangerous', but be religious at the same time! It seems weird that people can't see that church and cults are basically the same thing.