9 ms·
I'm on ltsb for my business laptop and it stinks. Id rather have random issues with a few upgrades than be stuck without new features and get almost no bug fixe
by alkonaut 9y ago
I'm on ltsb for my business laptop and it stinks. Id rather have random issues with a few upgrades than be stuck without new features and get almost no bug fixes. New features I get for my home machine are missing on my job laptop. New dpi handling improvements coming Nope, not in ltsb.
It appears to get security fixes only - few bug fixes.
For example, the LTSB start menu is completely broken - there is no search on it and it takes 3-4 seconds to show. Presumably related to the lack of Cortana, but who knows. In any case, it's been a widely reported bug in ltsb for a long time and it's a pretty fundamental feature in windows.
I could see the point in being on the LTSB branch of windows 7 because that OS is done. But windows 10 isn't nearly finished yet and very rough around the edges. Being on LTSB of such an old Win10 release is like being on the release day version of a AAA game while everyone else runs the fixed version that came out 3 months later.
- problems 9y ago> It appears to get security fixes only - few bug fixes. For example, the LTSB start menu is completely broken - there is no search on it and it takes 3-4 seconds to show Install Classic Shell. Practically mandatory to run Windows since 8.
- billforsternz 9y agoSeconding this. I was reluctant since I prefer vanilla installations if at all possible. But my concerns vanished immediately after install - it just works and the start button actually becomes useful again. I used ninite.com. Of course.
- xpclient 9y agoYes, Classic Shell highly recommended.
- cm2187 9y agoThe way you describe your start menu pretty much accurately describes my full patched windows 10 pro. Not sure LTSB is the problem.
- BinaryIdiot 9y agoWhat type of computer are you running Windows 10 on? I've had multiple computers running Windows 10 (even a low end tablet) and I've never seen this start menu issue. I've also not seen it on any computers in a retail shop. Not saying it doesn't happen or you're lying but I've never seen it and I've used many low and high end Windows 10 computers so I'm curious what the cause could be.
- reitanqild 9y agoRandom lagging on Windows is common. My new Dell laptop often lags when opening the start menu. My previous lenovo stuttered from time to time. My HP before that would block for 200-700 ms every 30 seconds, causing lost keystrokes, until I uninstalled HP power manager. I guess signature editions and Surface are better.
- alkonaut 9y agoWhen I have the start menu lag, it's because the search service isn't working. If the start menu takes 3 seconds to show that correlates 100% of the time with the search function not working either.
- reitanqild 9y agoSo just reset the search function or something then?
- alkonaut 9y agoI have googled solutions like this for months. Happy to try one more.
- reitanqild 9y agoI don't have a general solution but for older versions of windows there was latency mon or something (similar exists for Windows 10 but I have forgotten the name). This might help you identify the culprit. The way I use it is I start latencymon (or similar), Running that I'll then stop applications one by one and see if the latency spikes disappears. If that doesn't help next I'll stop services one by one. If it is software related you should find it this way - usually Windows is quite stable in itself and it is "just" a misbehaving driver.
- CamperBob2 9y agoWindows is an operating system, not a game. Many of us don't necessarily want the latest bells, whistles, unlockable achievements, and optional DLC, and we resent having them shoved down our throats with no input in the matter. And as for bug fixes, many of us were perfectly satisfied with the stability and even the security of Windows 7. Hence the appeal of LTSB.
- dlp211 9y agoHere's the problem. Windows is for everyone, the vast majority of people will run Windows on their desktop and laptop PCs. The vast majority of people also know nothing about computing and OS security. The vast majority of people will rely on someone that is "computer savvy". If Microsoft had an OS that met the needs of what probably amounts to < 1% of the total market; that is people that want to, and know how to manage updates; it would be abused by those "computer savvy" people and by extension ultimately wind up in the hands of people that have no business running it as an OS. Then we end up with a whole bunch of computers that will fall victim to the next "Wanna Cry" and you know who people will blame, Microsoft for not keeping their device patched and secure. Disclaimer: I work for Microsoft as part of the Windows org, but generally do not work much on the OS or its applications and the opinions I put forward are mine and mine alone.
- throwaway2048 9y agoIts great we have father Microsoft that knows best for all of us. Paternalism ensuring we can't hurt ourselves on the pointy bits.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- xg15 9y agoStandard counter-argument: Then be respectful of the trust people (voluntarily or not) place in you and don't abuse the update channel. The problem is that Windows updates have gotten a bad reputation which is partially justified by the tracking and nagware during the Windows 10 transition. If the reputation gets too bad, then even non-computer-savy people will start to turn off updates - with even worse consequences for security.
- tomc1985 9y agoI'm on LTSB for my home desktop and I love it. Kind of bummed Linux support isn't available but otherwise I love being left alone. slmgr -rearm works for a year :)
- midnitewarrior 9y agoLTSB is meant for kiosks, embedded systems, and other business applications where a non-changing OS is important. If you put this on a laptop for daily use, you're going to have a bad time.
- technion 9y agoBut that's precisely the problem. This article even calls it "Windows 10 without the cruft", and there's this misinformed view everywhere that you can "strip down" and accordingly "make faster" Windows by using the LTSB. And before you know it, everyone wants to. There are forum threads with people buying home desktops and being upset that they didn't get LTSB because "Cortana uses RAM I want for gaming". LTSB is a victim of poor marketing. It should be called "kiosk edition" or something to make some of these things really clear to people.
- justin66 9y agoAs the article notes, "there’s no legitimate way for the average Windows user to get it." These are people who are going out of their way to shoot themselves in the foot. Marketing has nothing to do with it, whatever misinformation they're getting is coming from third parties.
- PhasmaFelis 9y agoWell, it's also a matter of poor OS design decisions. People wouldn't be so desperate for a "streamlined" version of Windows if the default version wasn't so Godawful crufty.
- scrollaway 9y agoThey're not shooting themselves in the foot, they're being shot at by Microsoft and are desperate for that to stop, they make mistakes and trip in the process. I have two PCs: My main workstation is Arch Linux, my gaming PC is Windows 10. The difference is radical, W10 is absolute garbage for gaming. Every time I turn it on, it takes a solid 10+ minutes (sometimes way longer) updating itself. When I launch a game, sometimes out of nowhere it's going to start using all my bandwidth to download updates and I have no way to stop it other than kill the process using the task manager (it does come back a few minutes later though). It's nonsense. I have no control over what it's doing.
- Spooky23 9y agoYou want "Current Branch for Business". A lot of IT people missed the boat on that, as the guidance from Microsoft is garbage. The whole Windows 10 thing is a real shitshow. They solved a problem ("Gee, I wish I could update Windows features quarterly!") that nobody had and created yet more complexity.
- pks016 9y agoBut here's my experience using LTSB. I need an OS which has almost no bugs and fast performance. Neither I need new features nor the windows apps and store. I just need an OS for running office, certain software in my low end laptop. And imo LTSB is best option for me. I was previously on Windows 7. It was very fast with no problems. Then I updated to Win 10 and my old laptop was not compatible with it. I ran into lots of issue e.g. over heating, display problem, drivers problem, hang sometimes etc. But then I give LTSB a try and it works very well till now. Regarding start menu, I would say mine is faster(1-2 sec) in search operation than my friend's who has regular Win 10. (I have Dell vostro 2520 i3-6GB ram)
- alkonaut 9y agoI think part of my problem is that I develop Windows desktop software and my customers will have more features than I in their Win10. I absolutely need every last new feature.
- russdpale 9y agoI wonder if there is some policy group settings that are configured wonky? I have ltsb and I wouldn't trade it for any other version of windows, ever. If I couldn't use LTSB I would use linux. Im usually a few years behind on games so it might not affect me as bad.