5 ms·
Getting Googled by Your Doctor
- dontreact 9y agoI wish there was a way to explicitly consent for all my health data to be free and public for any purpose.
- intopieces 9y agoBe careful what you wish for. Making such information free and public could open you up to all kinds of tracking and discrimination, not to mention higher costs for insurance or credit. Anonymize it and I'm there, though this certainly would not help in this situation described by this article.
- lettergram 9y agoDon't forget, they just ruined any opportunity for their children to also have a anonymous genome. Literally, if there is some hereditary disease, they may have just made it so their kids can never get affordable insurance -_-
- Houshalter 9y agoIt's been illegal for awhile for health insurance companies to use genetic information. And now they can't even discriminate against any preexisting conditions.
- intopieces 9y agoBut how would you know if they had? My insurance bill doesn't give me a breakdown of how they decided my premium. And how do you know that they won't be able to in the future? Healthcare regulations are subject to the whims of the current government.
- kelnos 9y agoFor now: the final ACA replacement bill isn't quite ready for a vote. The final language may end up allowing for discrimination against preexisting conditions. It's not unreasonable to suggest that laws protecting against use of genetic information could get repealed someday either.
- toomuchtodo 9y agohttp://www.personalgenomes.org/harvard/sign-up http://www.personalgenomes.org/harvard/sign-up Disclaimer: I am a participant; my genome and health records are public.
- chopin 9y agoCongratulations, you published the genome of all your relatives. Did they consent?
- toomuchtodo 9y agoMy genome is mine. While I'm aware of the negative consequences sharing my genome causes others sharing large portions with me, the benefits outweigh the negative consequences.
- mike-cardwell 9y agoSo they didn't consent?
- toomuchtodo 9y agoI don't require any other consent, legally or moraly, besides my own.
- lettergram 9y agoAlthough I agree we all have our own moral code, and you literally don't need anyone's consent to do anything. The consequences of your actions can be far reaching and perhaps some future version of yourself can come to terms with the fact - it is likely immoral by your future code of ethics, to give out personal data on your family members without their consent. You can't change giving out data, while your morals can change. That is why being conservative with your data is beneficial. Your future self may change their mind.
- eveningcoffee 9y ago
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 9y agoHow is that not illegal due to the simple fact that you are disclosing to a third party who your patients are?
- jlarocco 9y agoHow?
- bluejekyll 9y agoI suppose they mean through search history and the fact that google and other search engines would have access to that.
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 9y agoThe question of "history" really is secondary here. What's forbidden is not that people you tell information about your patients write it down, what is forbidden is telling them in the first place.
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 9y agoBy typing it into their search form and sending it to their server, and especially on "social networks" by the further (non-)interaction with the person?
- jlarocco 9y agoWhen a person searches for another person's name, I don't think there's any way for Google to know what the connection is between those people.
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 9y agoImagine you were a sort of "librarian of world-wide knowledge" that people would call to ask all kinds of questions they had. Imagine there were this one person who asked you a lot of questions about all kinds of mental health problems, and then also quite a lot of names of people, in particular during working hours. Are you telling me you wouldn't possibly get the idea from that that a significant proportion of those people would be their patients? Or are you saying that as long as there is no absolute certainty, sharing of medical info is perfectly fine? So, there shouldn't really be a problem with a doctor publishing the medical file of a patient in the local newspaper ... after all, how should the reader be certain that it's not just a fake of someone the doctor doesn't even know?
- kakarot 9y agoSo what I got from this is that police feel like they can search your home without consent over a facebook profile photo. Nice. He should have requested help from the ACLU, sued the person who made the call that he needed to be forcibly taken in, and sued the police department for illegal search, while making the case VERY public. I was wrongfully committed once by a vengeful relative (not even blood) who deceitfully pretended to be my guardian, making up shit about my state of mind. The government is still hounding my mother about the medical bills, which she refuses to pay because she did not even find out what was going on until I was committed and could not be released. I was kidnapped from her house and was led to believe we were going somewhere else. Next thing I know, a police officer is at the car window telling me we can do this the easy way, or the hard way. I take this kind of intrusion on personal liberty to be especially heinous.
- alsetmusic 9y ago> He should have requested help from the ACLU, sued the person who made the call that he needed to be forcibly taken in, and sued the police department for illegal search, while making the case VERY public. While I agree with you in principle, it should also be noted that some people may not want their mental health treatment to become a matter of public record. It may affect their future in unpredictable ways (employment, relationships, legal disputes, etc). It could be used against them down the road.
- kakarot 9y agoThat's the unfortunate truth... so he should have gone after a large settlement, citing that very reason.
- stevenh 9y agoI despise how someone who makes a false accusation always has the upper hand over the accused. People need to develop a healthy distrust of unconfirmed sources, especially in the age of Photoshop, face- and voice-swapping neural nets, and extreme trolling.
- 9y ago
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jauer 9y agoI wish there was a way to give a psychologist all my online tracks (down to Slashdot posts when I was 12), context of what I was thinking around the posts, and along with the usual story of my life. Then diff it against "normal" and provide advice--"because of X you seem to react Y so maybe try Z".
- quanticle 9y agoDear god, I hope there isn't. While my online persona is pretty much the same as my real-life persona, I know quite a few people who have more than one online identity. I would hate to have someone characterized with a mental illness because their psychologist came across their old tumblr or livejournal.
- busituykdu1222 9y agoThe disagreement between the two of you is kind of paralleling an emerging debate over trends in mental health assessment research. Right now, there are large grants (from the federal government) being dispersed to develop systems to basically scrape patients' social media info and smartphone data (including things like GPS, accelerometer data, etc.) to predict outcomes. There's other related research going on too. Traditionally, assessment methods work more like an instrument: you introduce a stimulus and record a response. I don't think that's going to change, because of various advantages of that sort of data, but the utility of other types of data is being actively discussed. You have privacy issues like are being discussed here, but there are also practical issues like: what if your severely mentally ill patient doesn't have a Facebook account they use regularly? What if they don't even own a phone, or use it, which common? Looking for patients on the web isn't uncommon. It's not really so much your depressed office manager, it's your patient who is being court-ordered for some service because they pulled a gun on their girlfriend and used the butt of it to knock their 2-year-old over. Imagine that they come in, and you're supposed to be monitoring their danger to self or others, and aren't willing to say much to you, and won't consent to have you contact a third party, or don't even have a third party to contact. If a situation arose where you could find something on Google, would you refrain from searching it? What about an online public government-run database? What about reddit? What about Facebook? Where do you draw the line? Should the courts be ordering that psychologists and psychiatrists be able to scrape your phone? Install an invasive monitoring app? What if you haven't been convicted yet? What if you aren't charged with anything, but have been deemed incompetent to make your own medical decisions?
- TazeTSchnitzel 9y agoI wonder what privacy law, particularly outside the US, says about this.
- notadoc 9y agoI find it hard to believe most doctors have the time to casually google patients.
- true_religion 9y agoPsychologists usually have self-imposed limits on the number of patients that they see in total.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Kenji 9y agoNever ever publicly tell stuff like that you're suicidal. It's a recipe for disaster. People think they have to send police after you, lock you up and put you under watch - mostly causing more harm and problems than good. They actually think that it is morally okay to violate your freedoms in this situation. Get help - the best way would be to talk to someone face to face. Don't post morbid stuff on the net, you worry everybody crazy.
- Houshalter 9y agoAre you saying it's not morally ok to stop suicidal people? You really wouldn't even if it was your friend or loved one? Would you want them reading comments like this, telling them to keep it secret?
- Kenji 9y agoYes, that is what I am saying. My respect for self-ownership and individual choice runs so deep that if someone truly wants to die (not as in voicing suicidal thoughts as a cry for help, but actually wanting to die), I'd respect that. If someone has the right to live, they should have the right to die. As for telling them to keep it a secret (at least to the public) - that is not because I would mind. It's just an advice to protect themselves because society tends to react to this stuff in extremely retarded ways.
- eropple 9y ago> if someone truly wants to die (not as in voicing suicidal thoughts as a cry for help, but actually wanting to die) Explain to me how you differentiate outside of the relatively clear cases, such as physician-assisted suicide? Using "retarded" as a pejorative--we're already not in a good place. But I'd like to hear your reasoning, if it exists.
- kelnos 9y agoI think it's really hard, if not impossible, to make that determination, and that's the moral hazard. There are also people who believe that any desire to commit suicide is a mental health issue that can and should be fixed. I think it's reasonable to always err on the side of caution, since obviously we can't (yet) reverse death, so there's no going back in the case where the causes of the suicidal feelings can actually be fixed. But I also believe in self-determination: if you really are determined to end your life -- for any reason -- you should be allowed to do so. So I guess I'm personally somewhere in the middle: try to stop suicide attempts, but if, after getting help, the person still wants to end their life, maybe you should just respect their wishes and let them go, as hard as doing so may be.
- rdiddly 9y agoAs a social media self-exile I have to laugh at the (emphasis mine) "increasing openness of our lives, which we increasingly spend online..." Who's this 'we'? If someday I'm unfortunate enough to have to see a doctor, and they Google me, they'll find nothing. What happens then? Will they have to do their job using only the information I specifically provide them? Horrors.