5 ms·
And what does the world gain by Wikileaks leaking this for public usage? It will only become more ubiquitous. Microsoft already has patched the vulnerability.
by azinman2 9y ago
And what does the world gain by Wikileaks leaking this for public usage? It will only become more ubiquitous. Microsoft already has patched the vulnerability.
When will Russia, China, Israel, Iran, France, North Korea or other countries wares be leaked? Something tells me they wouldn’t even if they got it...
- fit2rule 9y agoWhat is the gain? We civilians no longer have to be victims to our out-of-control governments, who are no longer working to protect us, but rather their corporate interests.
- mavdi 9y agoI have no idea how leaking highly classified cyberwar toolkit helps that cause.
- tgragnato 9y agoI am very interested in knowing if there is an equally efficient alternative.
- fit2rule 9y agoThe alternative is a social system designed not to keep secrets, but reveal them.
- shakna 9y agoI don't think that is realistically practical. Currently you have several secrets you use to confirm your identity. The idea of the individual would need to be eliminated to remove all secrets.
- kakarot 9y agoIt's funny you say that. I've had a longstanding conclusion that my true individuality only arises from the secrets I keep. Even if these are benign and even sometimes silly secrets, even if no one would find them interesting, they are the only thing I have that sets me apart from others. This is another reason I feel anxious over creeping mass surveillance and the loss of privacy. It's a direct threat to my individuality.
- shakna 9y agoThe more I think about it, the more I come to one conclusion. An organisation only knows who an individual is by the secrets they share with each other. It doesn't matter what the secret is, it comprises the identity. It's why I get angry when I hear talk of backdooring/banning encryption. It's why the phrase "I have nothing to hide" is a ridiculous fallacy. Even the credit card in my wallet has multiple secrets to identify itself, and its ties to my account. Without secrets, you become a non-person, because you are incapable of proving who you are.
- briandear 9y agoWhich is exactly the goal in communist systems. Individuality is discouraged.
- shakna 9y agoEven there, you need some concept of isolating individuals, to assign work, allocate food and housing, etc.
- fit2rule 9y ago>The idea of the individual would need to be eliminated to remove all secrets. Well, this is good when it happens, on occasion, anyway. It's not a static value; sometimes such states as you propose are valuable/valued - other times, not so. This is not absolute, since you mention practicality. More specifically, since we are discussing governance, we must absolutely remove the individual from the occasion if we are to maintain a stable social construction, while at the same time strengthening the individuals position within either a fluid .. or rigid .. social structure. I personally believe modern government is holding us back. Lets just get this out of the way now. In the digital age, we don't need all the hierarchy; we simply need better apps. And I most certainly do not want my apps to have personality, if they are designed to ease the means by which I exchange, equitably, with everyone else using my app^W^W^Wwho is a member of my society... >The idea of the individual would need to be eliminated to remove all secrets. I believe this is a call-to-authority fallacy. You have not thought the original statement through; but rather acted as an individual unit of agency reacting to the pressure of the masses. Of course we will still have individuals; human bodies are made that way, and hopefully will stay that way for a long time yet. What we won't have is rock-star/evil-genius politicians, nor will we have much reason to keep secrets to each other, over who has rice and who has salt and who is on the way to Mars, and so on ...
- Ao7bei3s 9y agoFull disclosure ensures that vulnerabilities are known, taken seriously and eventually patched. It also levels the playing field.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- azinman2 9y agoIt was already patched. This just makes the world worse.
- fit2rule 9y agoIt educates the masses as to the nature of the lies of their society. This may not be good for "Americans", but it is good for "Humans". Do you think I really want to do business with an American company if I know they are liable to secret, hidden manipulation by their own government, while facilitating a facade of 'freedom'?
- mavdi 9y agoerm they could just have these verified by trusted 3rd parties and just mention they have them and not release them to Russian hackers. That's be the responsible thing to do
- wyager 9y agoMost people outside the security community don't believe that the government has the offensive capabilities it does. This is necessary proof.
- dogma1138 9y agoNo it's an unnecessary blabber, unlike the NSA leaks, these show that the CIA actually does what is supposed too. Targeted capabilities, not mass surveillance.
- sametmax 9y agoYou mean being able to do one cancel the ability to do the other ? That makes no sense.
- dogma1138 9y agoNo but we haven't seen mass surveillance in any of the leaks. All we've seen is specifically targeted capabilities with expiration dates. Penetrating air-gapped networks is exactly the capability one would expect from the CIA and its exactly the capability it should have under its mandate.
- sametmax 9y agoYou have a short memory if you don't remember PRISM.
- austinprete 9y agoPRISM was an NSA operation, so it's not clear how that is evidence against his claim that the CIA is more responsible with their cyber offense/surveillance than the NSA. If anything it seems to lend even more credence to his point.
- sametmax 9y ago
- tibarun 9y agoUsonians are so brainwashed by "american exceptionalism" that they can't even see how out of control their military/industrial complex has become.
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> Usonians What this?
- therobotking 9y agoPresumably it's a name for people from the US but I've never seen it before and it's not great.
- chalupa-man 9y agoIt's the word or similar to the word for the USA in a few languages, like Esperanto ("Usono": the USA, "Usonano": a USA citizen, "Ameriko" already being used for the continent and "Amerikano" for people from that continent). It was a term introduced in the 1800s without a lot of success, then after its use in Esperanto it was mildly popularised by American architectural legend Frank Lloyd Wright, who embraced the term and described his work as "Usonian architecture" and wrote at length about "Usonian character."
- na85 9y agoI've seen it occasionally used to refer to Americans, because technically speaking, any citizen of any country of North or South America is an "American", and yet citizens of the USA don't recognize this. To many, the implicit assumption that USA strictly equals America and vice versa is just another artifact of the arrogance built into US culture.
- mikeash 9y agoUse of the term "American" to describe US citizens is quite common outside the US. To me, the idea that this is somehow a manifestation of our cultural arrogance and not just a mundane example of the malleability of human language is just another artifact of how certain people really, really want to find more reasons to hate us.
- darkkindness 9y agoAre you arguing "other countries are not experiencing leaks -> leaks are harmful"? Sorry, I don't follow...
- azinman2 9y agoIt’s counter to the stated mission when it becomes entirely 1 sided and not beneficial. Wikileaks was meant to put an end to corruption, etc by revealing leaks across the world that benefit its local people. The biggest leak to do so lately, the Panama papers, wasn’t even by Wikileaks. What value are they providing?