3 ms·
“Yanez was acquitted and Philando Castile is still dead -- a man who did nothing more than try to comply with an officer's orders.” That’s a bold claim. If we
by azinman2 9y ago
“Yanez was acquitted and Philando Castile is still dead -- a man who did nothing more than try to comply with an officer's orders.”
That’s a bold claim. If we watch the video, we can see the officer repeatedly saying “stay away from the gun.” It’s not clear what’s happening, but I can at least say I don’t know for sure what did in this tragic case.
- michaelmrose 9y agoSeems to be pretty clear that the officer was paranoid and shot him without any real reason other than in the officers imagination.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- 3131s 9y agoYeah, it's clear that this shooting was wrong. Yanez came into the situation with false notions about Castille, and the situation escalated very quickly because of it. It has been pointed out elsewhere that Castille did not follow the recommended protocol for alerting the cop to his firearm, but then again Castille had been pulled over 50+ times so maybe he got a bit casual. There was confusion over Yanez's statement of "don't reach for it", given that Yanez had told him to produce his wallet shortly beforehand. The escalation happens in about 5 seconds from "don't reach for it man" to rapid-fire shooting. Castille's demeanor is not at all threatening yet Yanez stated that he thought Castille didn't care about human life because there was a marijuana smell in the car and Castille's daughter was also in the car. That said, cops are asked to do a difficult job and to enforce bad laws that pit them in a war against certain communities. The laws need to change, then fewer police and civilians will die needlessly.
- michaelmrose 9y agoPeople die without violating any law and in fact without any reason at the hands of the modern day gestapo we jokingly call a police force. The only thing that needs to change is prosecuting police officers who shoot civilians without good cause. Instead the system protects them then nut bars get angry for the right reasons but at the wrong people. Then we end up with not only dead civilians but also dead cops because some angry individual decided to ambush and kill the nearest representative of the boys in blue. This like as not kills decent people who wanted to help their community and as a nice side effect makes cops more fearful and therefore MORE likely to shoot more innocent people which riles up the populace and makes them more likely to shoot cops. The only way to short circuit this bad day is for federal authorities to punish the cops that communities wont. Unfortunately with the current administration that is laughably unlikely. Up next a bunch more dead people.
- zkms 9y agoYanez fucked up, hard. He was clearly on edge and nervous from the start, put himself in a bad position, and the verbal commands he gave were utterly atrocious. He asked for proof of insurance and ID, and then once Mr. Castile informed him of his weapons permit, Yanez said "don’t pull it out". However, to someone who isn't intending on pulling out his concealed-carry weapon, "don't pull it out" does not adequately and unambiguously signal "stop moving". Mr. Castile was obeying the command to show his ID and also had acknowledged the order not to pull out his gun. Yanez did not even entertain the possibility that Castile might not be reaching for a gun -- and the phraseology Yanez used is indicative of that. Had Yanez wanted Castile to stop moving altogether, he should have issued an unambiguous command to that effect; such as "stop moving" or "hands on the dashboard" or "put your hands out the window now". Yanez got himself all worked up and panicked before even making contact with the people in the car, issued verbal commands that were obeyed to the letter, shot up a compliant person, and then gave weird excuses about the smell of marijuana during questioning. Yes, someone in Castile's position could have stopped moving altogether when hearing "don't pull it out", but it really shouldn't be up to people stopped by police to try to reverse-engineer an officer's intentions and de-escalate the situation to avoid being shot by a nervous policeman. Obeying commands should be sufficient to not get shot up.
- azinman2 9y agoWhen you have a cop repeatedly yelling at you to stop pulling out a gun, it’s pretty clear the situation is getting intense. After the second time, you’d figure whatever you’re doing is wrong and at that point you’d stop... especially with all the police shootings as a black man. Regardless this is all us trying to put ourselves in that situation when none of us were in it, the videos don’t conclusively show what he was doing, and the officer wasn’t worked up / nervous from the start – he started off very calm. We can only speculate on the situation, without living it and fully seeing it how can we judge one way or the other? Clearly there’s a larger problem with so many black people in prison and killed by cops in this conntey, but to do justice you have to look at every situation individually.
- zer00eyz 9y agoAnd when they don't shoot them they get fired: http://www.post-gazette.com/local/region/2016/09/11/Weirton-fired-officer-who-did-not-fire-at-man-with-gun/stories/201609090080 http://www.post-gazette.com/local/region/2016/09/11/Weirton-...
- thanksgiving 9y agohttps://archive.fo/pIUYu https://archive.fo/pIUYu > Jack Dolance, an attorney for the Williams’ family, said that how and why Mr. Mader was fired “is pretty clear evidence of their policy and that the way they feel [the shooting of Mr. Williams] should have been handled. Not only do they think he should have been shot and killed, but shot and killed more quickly. " What in reading between the lines for why they acted the way they did is money. My guess is the city administration believes a shot and possibly dead police officer would cost them x monies and that a black man holding a gun doesn't have much of a recourse especially if he is dead.
- electic 9y agoNot sure what video you are looking at but there is a released dash-cam video and also a Facebook Live video and at no time did he ever reach for the gun. In fact, he had his seatbelt on. He did the right thing and even let the officer know he was legally allowed to carry a gun.
- azinman2 9y agoI’m talking about the dashcam video. You can’t actually see in the car, so we don’t know what he was doing with his hands or why the cop repeatedly yelled what he did.
- SwellJoe 9y agoMultiple people said he was not reaching for a gun, including the other officer on the scene. "He's not reaching for it" can be heard in the video, and Castile himself says, "I'm not..." before being riddled with bullets, and the last thing he said was "I wasn't reaching for it". Nobody thought he was reaching for a gun, except (maybe) the dangerously unhinged officer who shot him.
- boolosboolos 9y agoI see people making similar arguments quite a bit. In this case it's important for everyone to consider that the instruction, “stay away from the gun" does not mean: "do not move", "do not look for your license", "keep your hands were I can see them", etc. Philando likely was complying with the instruction he had been given, the officer unfortunately wanted him to do something else.
- azinman2 9y agoYou say “likely was” but how do you know? None of us do. All I can say is that I can’t judge the situation one way or another.
- shawnz 9y agoYou can't be serious. Just because there is the possibility that someone might not be complying does not make it acceptable to kill them. The officer admitted that he saw no gun and there was no reason for him to make the uncharitable assumption that Philando was trying to attack him.
- jldugger 9y agoIt's a weird edge case, since we know virtually all of the facts of the event (an officer shot and killed the person with intent to do so), so let me ask you directly: is doubt about whether the victim was reaching for a gun reasonable here? Because that's the standard to apply.
- shawnz 9y agoNo, it is 100% not reasonable to assume that someone is going to attack you just based on the fact that 1) they claimed to be legally carrying a gun and 2) they moved their hands after being asked to grab something. How is this even up for debate?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- dguaraglia 9y agoYeah, you can also clearly see the officer shooting a fifth, sixth and seventh time, because you never know how many bullets you need to stop a person, right? The officer panicked. Whether he saw something he deemed suspicious or not, he was clearly not trained or ready to deal with the situation at hand. We need to stop excusing deaths. Period.
- patrickg_zill 9y agoNot excusing Yanez, however from my understanding the training he would have received, would definitely have told him to fire multiple times, possibly to keep firing until the gun was empty. This is standard practice for police.
- tibiapejagala 9y agoWhich is kind of ridiculous, because now he has to reload while the second person in the car can grab the gun. I mean, if the cop was actually thinking that the people in the car were trying to kill them.