4 ms·
So the Intel won with the ugliest instruction set and Microsoft won with the ugliest OS. "Ugly" is apparently an overrated design disinclination.
by pmarreck 9y ago
So the Intel won with the ugliest instruction set and Microsoft won with the ugliest OS. "Ugly" is apparently an overrated design disinclination.
- KGIII 9y agoI have wondered about that. I have programmed. I am not skilled enough to warrant calling me a programmer. I did so out of necessity, I kinda hated it most of the time. But, I hear this about Intel's instruction set - at a number of tech sites. Intel got their start making memory (SRAM). They had Moore and Noyce, as I recall. Anyhow, I am not qualified to opine on instruction sets. I am curious as to where it went 'wrong.' I accept your declaration as being likely true - I've seen it echoed elsewhere. But, if you know, do you happen to know where (perhaps even why) it went wrong? I have tried the mighty Google, by the way. It was no help. I may have not had the correct search terms. I am a mathematician, I only programmed (retired now) out of necessity. In fact, I hated computers for the longest time. I am just curious about the history of where they went so wrong that so many people complain about it.
- kartD 9y agoThis is a basic summary of why it sucks. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=276471 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=276471
- KGIII 9y agoThank you. I understood most of that. I'm still curious as to 'where it all won't wrong.' If such info exists, of course.
- kartD 9y agoIt didn't, it's ugly because of backwards compatibility. It was cheap(transistor and engineering-wise) for Intel to add instructions in the 80's to 90's timeframe since it reduced instruction size, so they added a tonne of them. Now it looks ugly, but Intel can't reduce it because some obscure program may break.
- KGIII 9y agoAlright, thanks.
- JetSetWilly 9y agoThat tells me why it sucks from the perspective of a compiler writer in 2017. But it doesn't tell me if it sucked in 1979 in an era when ask was much more frequently hand-written and there were many more physical constraints and trade-offs. x86 seems often to be judged by later innovations like RISC. But that wasn't a thing in 1979 and sucks for hand-writing anyway - perhaps you want more complex and non-orthogonal instructions in 1979.
- kartD 9y agoSomeone who is familiar with the 70s and 80s will have to chime in, but I'm not sure how popular it was with assembly writers then (I don't think it was).
- FullyFunctional 9y agoAs someone who wrote a reasonable amount of assembler, my first exposure to RISC (SPARC) nearly blew my mind; so easy to learn and much less struggle to write well. I never understood the attachment to arcane ISAs.
- gp2000 9y agoYes, for better or worse ugly is definitely a 2nd-order predictor of success. I guess "ugly" is a fair assessment of the 8086 at the time. Certainly the 68000 was a much cleaner and orthogonal architecture. On the other hand, I'd rate the 8086 at least as good as if not better than other contemporary microprocessors such as the Z-80 and 6502. The 6809 was sweet but a 16 bit address space rooted it in the previous direction and the 68000 make it clear that the 6809 wasn't in Motorola's future plans. Sure, had IBM chosen the 6809 there surely would have been a compatible follow-on but I can't imagine even the stanchest IBMer to have that kind of hubris. But calling MS-DOS ugly at the time would have been unfair. It was as capable as any other microcomputer OS at the time in the home computer space. It was widely proclaimed to be a rip-off of CP/M so we might take that as a compliment and if you look at TRS-DOS, Apple DOS or whatever PET's used it was just fine. It'd be unrealistic to suggest and mini or mainframe OS was an option and Unix just wasn't there yet. If IBM had given Microsoft more lead time they might have went with Xenix which they did have out in 1981 for the Z-8001. I'm not so sure IBM would have been interested, though, as they wouldn't have an exclusive license to the OS. Not to mention that the overhead of the operating system was an important consideration. The machines didn't have much capacity to waste and whatever you picked it still had to perform well on a system with only floppy drives. Maybe that in itself doesn't rule out Unix but it sure cramps the design space. In both cases, CPU and OS, the ugliness really took off with backward compatibility to maintain. The 80286 was already being designed so it drove that deeper into the weeds and there was no way of bypassing MS-DOS compatibility once it anchored the marketplace. The only way forward was to improve the OS while keeping MS-DOS programs running and the whole OS/2 debacle only helped to delay that upward path. I mean, fair enough to say "ugly won" but some consideration should be given to the lay of the land when these long-term trends were set in motion.
- bluedino 9y agoThey both benefitted from piggybacking on the success of the Z80 and CP/M