3 ms·
> This article alleges that Assange deliberately broke opsec. Nadim's first-hand account of what happened says "Wikileaks did not out me as the source. An ind
by Natsu 16y ago
> This article alleges that Assange deliberately broke opsec.
Nadim's first-hand account of what happened says "Wikileaks did not out me as the source. An independent entity verified the logs, and I basically outed myself."
Source: http://db.nadim.cc/dtresp.txt http://db.nadim.cc/dtresp.txt
I'm inclined to trust the stories of those directly involved before any indirect accounts thereof, but that's my prerogative.
Does it count as being "outed" as a source if you want them to? If anything, it appears that they're doing this to protect Manning, their source. I'm not clear on how this can be some horrible breach of journalistic ethics or whatever if the sources agree with being outed to protect other sources.
The only ones getting burned here are Poulsen/Lamo and they're the ones who outed a Wikileaks source, Manning, who foolishly bragged to Lamo about being a Wikileaks source. I don't think Wikileaks can be blamed for not protecting him, because there's nothing they could do to prevent him from bragging.
The central notion that you can't trust Wikileaks to keep your identity secret doesn't follow for me. Wikileaks didn't tell Manning to go brag about his crimes to Lamo and they're leaking things designed to protect him (ibid). Lamo isn't, to my knowledge, a Wikileaks source. And Nadim gave them this data to help protect Manning.
What am I missing here, exactly? What's the OPSEC breach you're talking about? Leaking something Nadim asked them to leak?