3 ms·
This is an interesting article, but the paragraph about religion was kind of weird: > One psychological benefit of religious belief may be that, in theory, a r
by eridius 9y ago
This is an interesting article, but the paragraph about religion was kind of weird:
> One psychological benefit of religious belief may be that, in theory, a relationship with God, with all its associated memories, can extend from early childhood through to death, and no matter where you are on the planet, it is there. As Aquarone says, “You can’t take it away – and it transcends where you are.”
Besides not even attempting to provide evidence that religious people were less likely to develop DID, it also just doesn't make sense. People talk about having a "relationship" with God, but it's not a real relationship. The article says having a relationship with a parent helps avoid DID because the parent helps you learn how to manage yourself, but God certainly isn't doing this. Similarly it talks about how being with people with whom you have plenty of shared memories can enhance the sense of an ongoing self persisting through the years, but you don't have any shared memories with God. This paragraph would make just as much (or rather, little) sense if you claimed to have a "relationship" with Mister Rogers, because you watched Mister Rogers' Neighborhood for decades.
- azrazalea 9y agoI mean, given their logic I think the Mister Rogers example would work too. The idea is having a consistent presence, I believe.
- eridius 9y agoIf you suffer abuse as a child from your parent, you still have a consistent presence in that parent. The idea the article was suggesting was that you need to have an actual relationship with someone.
- kodt 9y agoPeople may believe they have a real relationship with God though. People believe God speaks to them and helps guide them to make decisions. Also, would not God share the memories of every living person, being omnipotent and all? Perhaps believing it is a real relationship is enough.