4 ms·
If they did, I would hope people around them recognized that their conflation of neurotoxins in water and largely benign electronics makes very little sense. I
by steve_adams_86 9y ago
If they did, I would hope people around them recognized that their conflation of neurotoxins in water and largely benign electronics makes very little sense.
I think I understand the sentiment, but I don't think the three are the same. And if they had similar results, hypothetically, they would be for entirely different reasons.
edit: I'm interested to know more about peoples' concerns about smartphones and other devices emitting harmful radiation. I've never seen anything conclusive at all, but my girlfriend is positive research will eventually reveal something, for example. Very curious if anyone knows more about this. Perhaps I'm totally incorrect.
- trhway 9y ago>conflation of neurotoxins in water and largely benign electronics makes very little sense. dopamine addiction coming from and through the benign electronics may count for something.
- eli_gottlieb 9y agoYou can't get addicted to dopamine; dopamine mediates one vector of addiction. It conveys something like reward prediction-error or precision of action-based prediction errors. Without it, you can't concentrate; with too much, you're forced to concentrate without control over what you concentrate on.
- steve_adams_86 9y agoI agree with that to a point. It does count for something for sure, but I think the analogy breaks down pretty quickly from there. I don't want to be pedantic or overly demanding of the statement either though. I just thought, when I read it, that the issues are much more complex than that, and the analogy overly simplifies the matter. I'm a big fan of electronic devices, and a huge believer in them being a medium for addiction and escapism. But I think societies need to look at the root of that issue rather than dismiss any medium for dopamine addiction as harmful (as harmful as lead in your water in this case). That becomes extremely subjective, and maybe not worth pursuing because I admit, I'm not educated on the matter. I simply believe that (based on my experiences) the misuse of electronics will often stem from a lack of stimulation, satisfaction, and/or engagement coming from other aspects in life. There is too much room for this form of addiction in modern life in many parts of the world. If we blame the devices, we fail to blame ourselves for better educating ourselves and striving to develop society in such a way that people feel they have better things to do than escape into a screen. I'm totally open to being called out as clueless or full of it - that's just my take on things. It's a very fascinating conversation, but probably not a great one for the internet. I worry I'll come across as thinking I'm an authority on this stuff or something, when it's quite the opposite.
- ABCLAW 9y agoThe root of the issue is our neural biochemistry. Are societies are expected to re-engineer our brains rather than put addiction in context? Or are they expected to create societies where our reward pathways are firmly under their control? I like having fun games to play too, and I'd be upset if someone stopped my dopamine drip too. That said, lets not pretend there isn't a wave of weaponized addiction sweeping through the software design world. What other solutions exist to that problem?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- freeflight 9y ago> If they did, I would hope people around them recognized that their conflation of neurotoxins in water and largely benign electronics makes very little sense. Right now we consider these electronics, and their emissions, largely benign but that doesn't mean that's actually the case in the long term. Think about the amount of wireless stuff constantly going on around you: GSM, EDGE, UMTS, LTE, bluetooth, several WLAN standards, radio, satellite and so on. Humanity has never been blasted with that much EM radiation before and the blast is constant and pretty much ever-present. I find it hard to believe that all those EMR don't have any effects at all on living things. Sure, we get doses of it anyway from space and the sun and so on, but that doesn't mean that adding our own won't make the doses cross a threshold. Wouldn't be the first time humanity underestimated the long-term effect of something just to realize, a couple of decades down the line, "Oopps.. wasn't as healthy as we thought".
- yjftsjthsd-h 9y ago> GSM, EDGE, UMTS, LTE, bluetooth, several WLAN standards, radio, satellite Non-ionizing, regulated dosage. Maybe we'll discover they were dangerous, but evidence doesn't support it so far.
- freeflight 9y ago> regulated dosage Of a single device, but how do we account for the accumulation of the dosages when there are literally dozens of those devices constantly around us? Let's also keep in mind that we haven't been living like this for very long, 10-20 years ain't really that big of a timeframe. For all purpose and effect, this is a rather recent development in human history. That's stuff bad dystopian sci-fi stories are made of: 30 years from now developed countries will reach "peak ERM" and people's brains suddenly start shriveling to raisins ;)
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- dxhdr 9y ago> Non-ionizing Non-ionizing radiation can have adverse health effects, e.g. UV light.