3 ms·
> The amount of work to even build the simplest game is monumental. It's not much different than writing and editing a novel, or composing, rehearsing, and rec
by munificent 9y ago
> The amount of work to even build the simplest game is monumental.
It's not much different than writing and editing a novel, or composing, rehearsing, and recording an album. The game industry is very much like the music and literal worlds these days.
You have a pack of companies (fewer and larger over time) and employees thereof who have figured out how to reliably generate cash. Think EA, big record labels, and big publishing houses.
Then you have a vanishingly small number of black swans who beat the odds, get huge, and make a ton of money (usually with the help of the above giant corporations). Think Bieber, Notch, and J.K. Rowling.
And then you have an enormous sea of people toiling in anonymity who will never find much money or an audience. That local band you see loading in at your corner bar. Every game not on the front page of Steam. Self-published fiction on Amazon.
As long as everyone recognizes what group they are in and are OK with it, I don't see the system as being intrinsically bad. Unfortunate that things are so skewed towards the small number of celebrities, but not outright cruel.
Where it gets creepy is when you have companies in the first category sucking money from the last category by promising them that they are in the middle one and encouraging them to make shitty life choices based on that.
There's nothing wrong with doing your weird little creative hobbies without reaching fame or fortune. I've been in local bands and made shareware games. I've written and produced goofy videos. It is all super fun, and I highly encourage anyone to do it. But it would not have been fun if I hung my livelihood on income from them, or defined my person sense of "success" in terms of audience size.
- vvanders 9y agoIn terms of production(both in budgets and in mix of tech+creative disciplines) I feel like film is probably the closest analogy. Either way I agree though, it's a brutal space if you aren't aware of the 90/10 revenue split across the industry.
- waqf 9y agoThis; but it disappoints me that the market is so winner-takes-all (skewed towards the top). I wish — for artistic reasons, not socialistic ones — that the money that is making a few companies very profitable were instead making 10x as many companies survivable. Ten years ago we were promised that personalized recommendations and discoverability of the long tail would make this happen, and we're still waiting.
- MagnumOpus 9y agoThe expansion of the long tail has happened. However, global emancipation of internet access, software markets and programming literacy has also happened. So there are now way more people making a dime doing indie games (or youtube content, or selling weird long-tail diy stuff on ebay) - but a good majority of them will hail from China or south east Asia or Eastern Europe...