5 ms·
The reasons Washington can't come up with real solutions are simple: ideology and money. A big chunk of Washington firmly believes that socialized medicine is
by mikeash 9y ago
The reasons Washington can't come up with real solutions are simple: ideology and money.
A big chunk of Washington firmly believes that socialized medicine is evil, and they will fight it. It doesn't matter what the facts are, it's part of their identity at this point.
For the rest, the desires of insurance companies and similar get in the way. For example, the main, perhaps only reason the ACA didn't include a public option is because Joe Lieberman, Senator from a state where the health insurance industry is huge, refused to vote for a bill that included it and his vote was required for passage.
If lawmakers wanted to fix things, it would be easy: study the systems of other first-world countries and incorporate the things that work best into ours. But "something that works well" is way down on the list of priorities.
- humanrebar 9y ago> For example, the main, perhaps only reason the ACA didn't include a public option is because Joe Lieberman, Senator from a state where the health insurance industry is huge, refused to vote for a bill that included it and his vote was required for passage. ...there were 40 other senators who were not voting for the ACA. The bill didn't, and still doesn't, have enough popular support. You can't blame one play on a lost game and you can't blame one voter for a lost ballot. Doubling down on employer provided healthcare with additional mandates didn't help their case.
- pc86 9y ago> you can't blame one voter for a lost ballot You can't do this in popular elections but you can absolutely do it in the legislature where everyone has a different constituency, policy portfolio, campaign contribution history, etc. Lieberman wouldn't vote for a bill with a public option, full stop. The math worked out such that Lieberman was necessary. Ergo, Lieberman killed the public option if there was no other Senator for whom the existence of a public option would have changed their Nay to a Yea. There was not, so you can absolutely lay the lack of a present day public option for health care in the US at his feet.
- humanrebar 9y agoI think you're letting Congress as a whole off to easy by scapegoating one senator. A more bipartisan bill that included a few Republicans could have been passed instead.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> A more bipartisan bill that included a few Republicans could have been passed instead. Assumes facts not in evidence, notably that there is any bill oriented to the policy objectives the ACA sought to acheive that Republican Senators would have supported at that time, and (for relevance regarding the responsibility for the absence of a public option in the ACA) that such a bill would include a public option of the type Lieberman opposed.
- mikeash 9y agoNo such bill existed. You might as well say that things would have been different if there were leprechaun senators.
- mikeash 9y agoI can and will blame one voter for a lost ballot. Republicans controlled 40 seats. Democrats controlled 58 and had two independents who mostly leaned their way. They needed all 60 of those votes to pass something. Lieberman was one of those independents, and he explicitly threatened to filibuster any bill that included a public option, while the other 59 accepted it. Republicans were going to vote against the ACA no matter what it contained. That means they had no power over the content of what got passed. Lieberman had huge power over the content.
- humanrebar 9y agoNo faction should force through a marginally popular, sweeping change by the skin of it's teeth. This is one of the reasons why the Constitution and amendment process exist. The Supreme Court ruled that the passage of the ACA was technically OK (I disagree, but that's moot I guess) but they didn't rule whether it was wise. I'm saying given the political and practical mess on this issue, it was unwise. I think partisan finger pointing is likewise a bad idea.
- mikeash 9y ago60% shouldn't be considered "skin of its teeth" and historically wasn't. It only is now because the Senate has become fairly dysfunctional. I don't see how it's "partisan finger pointing" to explain why the lack of a public option is the responsibility of a single independent senator. It vaguely fits for stating that the 40 Republicans were never going to vote for any form of the ACA, but that's really just a statement of fact.
- pc86 9y ago> study the systems of other first-world countries and incorporate the things that work best into ours The problem with this line of thought is that the US is orders of magnitude larger, more diverse, and more complex than most European nations. For any single European nation I'd wager at least two of those are the case. But we have a way to do this already without massive Federal overhauls - allow individual states to do what they want. This means the decisions are made closer to the people, so California can do what California wants while Mississippi can do what Mississippi wants. It also has the side benefit of California not paying for services in Mississippi. Personally if one of the US states offered non-employer-based, single-payer healthcare I would move there in a heartbeat. If it's as successful as proposed, it would not take very long to most states to offer something similar. At that point, depending on individual implementations, it would be much easier to extend it to the Federal level.
- glhaynes 9y agoIf it's as successful as proposed, it would not take very long to most states to offer something similar. IMO this isn't clearly true. Lots of states (especially those that currently have the worst health care outcomes) seem far more driven by the ideology that has caused their problems than by this kind of pragmatism. Example 1: the ACA's Medicare expansion. Hell, it might even work the opposite way: proof that something worked in California could end up as an argument against it. "Candidate x wants to implement the same sort of government health care system that's taken over California. This November, send him a message that we don't do things that way here."
- pc86 9y agoThat sounds like democracy working. Democracy means as many people as possible get the government they want. This get progressively easier as the government gets more local. Overall people are much happier with local, then state government than the federal government.[0] If the people Mississippi don't want single-payer health care, and the people in California do, I'm in favor of a system that gives both of them what they want. [0] http://www.people-press.org/2012/04/26/growing-gap-in-favorable-views-of-federal-state-governments/ http://www.people-press.org/2012/04/26/growing-gap-in-favora...
- justicezyx 9y ago> socialized medicine When you put this word here, they succeeded. Socilized has a special meaning here, and it's installed through near 5 decades of propaganda (number could be wrong, you get the idea). WHY pooling the society's resource for health care is "socialized"?! WHY WHY WHY WHY... When anyone examine this idea, everything falls apart. WHY? I don't know, and I will surprised anyone knows.
- gizmo686 9y ago> WHY pooling the society's resource for health care is "socialized"?! Because it is pooling some of societies wealth into the government to distribute as a good. The only difference between this and full socialism is that this does not extend to the entire economy. Also, keep in mind that a self proclaimed socialist is currently the most popular politician in the US.
- mikeash 9y ago> WHY pooling the society's resource for health care is "socialized"?! Because that's what the word means.