5 ms·
It would at least enforce agreement about what is being purchased and how much each item costs. Not getting what you purchased would still have to be resolved b
by mikeash 9y ago
It would at least enforce agreement about what is being purchased and how much each item costs. Not getting what you purchased would still have to be resolved by other means, but it would avoid scenarios where I tried to buy something for $1 and got charged $5, or where I tried to buy 1 item and got charged for 10, or similar.
I don't know if that's enough to make it a compelling use case, but it's kind of cool.
- root_axis 9y agoSeems like paypal accomplishes the same thing. I have to explicitly agree to be billed a specific amount through paypal's checkout process and it is not possible for the merchant to bill me again unless I explicitly agree to a recurring subscription (and even then, the recurrence is managed by the paypal subscription API, preventing the merchant from receiving any more funds than what I explicitly agreed to)
- mikeash 9y agoI don't think any blockchain technology accomplishes anything that couldn't also be accomplished with a trusted third party. The innovation, if you see it that way, is always in doing things without any trusted third party.
- root_axis 9y agoThat's sort of side-stepping the point. if a trusted third party is a satisfactory solution for the problem then a more complex and obscure trustless alternative is not compelling. Additionally, your response is in the context of the question: "How does Ethereum help with retail?". Your answer is "it helps to avoid erroneous charges", but that doesn't answer the question of why Ethereum is a compelling option compared to a system that has already solved this problem without the inefficiencies of the blockchain approach.
- mikeash 9y agoYou seem intent on getting me to defend a point I'm not making. I'm just describing what Ethereum could provide here and what makes it different from other solutions. The closest I came to actually praising it in any way was calling it "kind of cool." I'm not actually attempting to say, in any way, that this is actually useful or the way everything should be done or anything like that.
- root_axis 9y agoI'm not intent on anything, I am just pointing out that your stated reasoning for why eth is useful in a retail context isn't compelling. It'd be like if someone asked "why is an iPad useful for web development" and you responded "well, iPads support bluetooth keyboards so users don't have to input code on a touch screen"... ok well that's true, but it's not compelling because keyboard input is already a solved problem without the need to confine your development environment to the limitations of a tablet.
- mikeash 9y agoNobody said anything about "compelling." The person asked, "How does Ethereum help with retail?" I answered. What exactly is your problem with me here?
- root_axis 9y agoOk... replace compelling with insightful or noteworthy. You're being pretty defensive and seem to be taking my responses personally. I'm discussing your reasoning, not your personality. This is a discussion forum, and as you stated, someone asked a question, you answered, and I explained why I find your answer to be lacking, it's as simple as that. I didn't attack you or insult you so I'm not sure why you perceive a simple reply to your comment as my having "a problem" with you. If you find mild criticism to be so harrowing you're more than free to ignore my replies at your own discretion.
- source99 9y ago
- mannykannot 9y agoIf you did not verify the code yourself, you are trusting someone.