3 ms·
The IT department in my company seems to have HR people doing interviews with exactly these kinds of questions and consistently hiring a very specific type of p
by maxxxxx 9y ago
The IT department in my company seems to have HR people doing interviews with exactly these kinds of questions and consistently hiring a very specific type of people. Especially the architects and managers are very good at impressively "explaining" tech things to non tech people but they can't get anything real done. As soon as it gets detailed they have no clue. It feels like you are dealing with a group of actors who pretend to be tech savvy.
- watwut 9y ago> Especially the architects and managers are very good at impressively "explaining" tech things to non tech people Isn't that exactly the job for those two positions?
- mamon 9y agoIt certainly is HALF of the job. But they can be good at this, and still suck at the other half, which is actually getting things done. There's also similar case with guys whose positions are described as "evangelists" - some of those guys have been doing conference talks for so long that they cannot go past "hello world" stage for any technology that they claim to be experts in.
- watwut 9y agoYeah, evangelism is separate skill too. Good talkers and good coders are rarely the same (through it is certainly possie! )
- maxxxxx 9y ago"Isn't that exactly the job for those two positions? " It's one part of the job. But they can't talk to tech people because they don't seem to know anything real. Especially one guy sounds like he read a book "Enterprise Architecture for Dummies" and now he repeats words like "Integration patterns" but he can't give you a straight answer when you want details. It's a really weird situation.
- watwut 9y agoGotcha. Such people can do quite a lot of damage.
- justaman 9y agoWhen interviewing its immediately clear who is from IT and who is from HR. If HR outnumbers IT or IT isn't present at all, my interest in the job instantly declines to near zero. I wouldn't want to be on a team with people who can do well in an interview answering pedantic questions but can't perform in practice which is what you will end up with if HR does all the hiring.
- ryandrake 9y agoMaybe I've gotten lucky, but through my career and various bouts of job hunting, I don't think I've ever encountered a company where HR (in most cases a recruiter) did more than a super-basic phone screen. They make the initial contact, find out if I'm actually interested in the job, and then the actual interview is with 1. the hiring manager, 2. his/her peers, and 3. peers of the role I'd be moving to. I've never encountered a situation where someone from HR is asking me technical or behavioral questions. Is this really that common?
- maxxxxx 9y agoThank God it's not very common. But this article seems to encourage HR people to ask this kind of questions.