4 ms·
The arguments for segregated cycle tracks (physical barriers) rather than cycle lanes (paint) can be answered by one question: "Would you let your child cyc
by michaelt 9y ago
The arguments for segregated cycle tracks (physical
barriers) rather than cycle lanes (paint) can be answered
by one question: "Would you let your child cycle here?"
Where I live, when segregated cycle tracks meet T junctions the layout is often like so:
| C |
----------------------------------| a |--------
Cycles ◅ | r | ▷
----------------------------------| s |--------
divider | |
----------------------------------- Δ ---------
Cars
-------------------------------------------------
This means cyclists using the segregated path have to stop to give way to cars at every T junction - whereas cyclists who don't use the segregated path can maintain a constant speed, with joining cars giving way to them.
This leads to a demographic split in cyclist behaviour. For children and cyclists who aren't in a hurry, the segregated path is more friendly - but for 'serious' cyclists and people in a hurry, staying on the road makes more sense. Especially if there's a high density of T junctions, which isn't unusual in some urban areas.
Fortunately, in my country there aren't any laws that force cyclists into bike lanes, so it generally isn't a problem. But any urban planner who wants 100% of cyclists segregated from traffic is going to have a difficult time on their hands :)
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Freak_NL 9y ago> This means cyclists using the segregated path have to stop to give way to cars at every T junction That is a very car-centric design. In the Netherlands these kind of junctions within city limits tend to give the bicycle path the right of way. Bicycle lanes are also mandatory when they are provided; this makes everything a lot safer for all parties concerned.
- rorykoehler 9y agoThis always infuriated me. Cyclists are treated like second class citizens even when designing cycling infrastructure. Then we get yelled at for riding on the road. On top of this often the cycling lanes on the edge of main roads also double up as puncture hazards making it risky to use them.
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoWhy? It's pretty universal that smaller crap yeild to bigger crap. Forklifts yield to service trucks. Service trucks yield to heavy equipment. Heavy equipment yields to bigger heavy equipment. Big heavy equipment yields to trains. Trains yield to ships.
- Nav_Panel 9y agoCars yield to (much smaller) pedestrians, though. Clearly this model needs some work.
- ghaff 9y agoDepends where you are. The city in Asia where I am at the moment turning cars pretty clearly don't yield to pedestrians walk signs notwithstanding.
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoOnly in areas where pedestrians specifically are given the right of way (e.g. crosswalks). Outside of specific structured instances like that small yields to big. Of course if you just ignore that you don't have the right of way and just go people will slam on their brakes for you because that's the least costly option for dealing with the situation. It's like taking a left turn across traffic. Some people may stop and let you go if they deem it appropriate but the burden is on the you to turn when it is clear to do so, not on them to stop.
- allendoerfer 9y agoIt is exactly the opposite in Germany. When you make turn on the road, pedestrians and cyclist have the right of way, even though they also will cross a road (the one you are turning into). It is the key principle in German traffic laws: You have to pay attention to what smaller and weaker vehicles are doing. Even when you are technically right, you can still be hold partially responsible for damages caused.
- antisthenes 9y ago
- skrebbel 9y agoThis is solved in the Netherlands, pretty much universally, by making the cars coming in from the side wait for the bike lane as well: | C | -----------------------------------Δ Δ Δ---- Cycles r ----------------------------------- s --------- divider | | -----------------------------------Δ Δ Δ--------- Cars ------------------------------------------------- So if there's a bike lane, it counts as part of the car road in terms of right of way, even if it's separated by a divider.
- FussyZeus 9y agoThis is how it's done in my area of the US, but I can tell you American drivers almost universally ignore where you're supposed to stop at a T junction, especially when turning right. It's maddening, multiple times I've had to leave the bike lane into traffic to get around a vehicle that isn't where it's supposed to be. I've never seen anyone get pulled over for this either because cycling isn't recognized as a "real" thing police need to take care of. In short: The issue in the US anyway I think has a lot more to do with culture than with road safety and structure. If people gave a shit we'd make it work, but few here do (at least around where I live, northern midwest.)
- phicoh 9y agoVehicles turning right is a big problem in the Netherlands as well. Not so much that they block intersections, but that bikes going straight have priority over the vehicle turning right, bikes take priority and then get in an accident. It doesn't matter who was right if you are dead. In my experience, separate bike lanes are great for long stretches of road without intersections. Also quite safe on intersections with traffic lights if the bikes have their own dedicated time slot. (That's not always the case) But when bikes going straight are encouraged to pass right turning vehicles on the right, it becomes a serious risk.
- FussyZeus 9y agoEvery time I cross in front of a car I have both hands sitting on the handlebar brakes. On one occasion I actually had to kick the car, someone started moving forward while I was right in front, I kind of bounced off the bumper with a foot and managed to maintain my balance. Thankfully didn't mess up their car, and they got out of the car to make sure I was alright. It's not hostility very often, it's just not paying enough attention to things that aren't cars.
- baldfat 9y agoMy City, Allentown, PA was going to do that with two one way roads roads that travel East West. Making the two roads 1 lane each. Got shot down hard. Instead they placed share road markers. After being flipped off, beeped at and treated like I should die I never bike in my city.