6 ms·
This looks like trucking's version of off-shoring. You get paid to train your replacements. If you don't train them, someone else will. It's a no win for the
by mc32 9y ago
This looks like trucking's version of off-shoring.
You get paid to train your replacements. If you don't train them, someone else will. It's a no win for them. They don't have pull or unions that commuter train operators have so it's not like they'll get to ride along and supervise the autonomous vehicle, in the long term. Instead, there may be an ops center somewhere in TX where operators intervene remotely when an irregular operating pattern pops up. Those will be fewer operators.
- infecto 9y agoI am not a trucker but from what I understood from other truckers is that this can be seen as a benefit to them. There is a lot more effort as a trucker in managing the cargo than the driving. Lots of paperwork at pickup, drop off and in between checks. There is effort to ensure the security of the cargo. I think the expectation is that wages would stay the same and truckers stop driving and start managing. Keep in mind wages are already fairly low.
- eduren 9y agoYup, end-of-the-line logistics would be an easily transitioned to stopgap measure. Some former truckers would be able to stay local and handle loading/unloading. Not as many as are currently on the road, but every little bit of transitioning helps.
- vkou 9y agoWages might stay the same, but half of them would lose their jobs. Wages are a trucking firm's biggest expense. Why would a firm go out and buy a bunch of expensive self-driving trucks, so that they could pay the same number of people the same wages.
- mertd 9y agoYou assumed that the trucking volume will stay the same when the cost goes down significantly.
- vkou 9y agoIf the cost of electricity halves, will you start using twice as much electricity? Halving the cost of transporting goods will not double the demand for transporting goods. Consumer budgets are fixed, and transportation is a very small fraction of the price of goods that consumers buy. Dropping the cost of transport by 30%, because you only need to employ half the truckers, will not double demand. Unlike the before-after world of trucking, air travel, container shipping, etc, there isn't a mountain of businesses that suddenly become viable when long-haul costs get slashed by a third.
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoIt won't double it but it will be close in some locales. It would also slightly decrease the cost of a heck of a lot of things.
- vkou 9y agoExactly which categories of businesses are sitting on their hands, going 'Golly - we'd make and sell so much more of our product, if only shipping & handling were 30% cheaper'? What fraction of the economy do they make up? What if efficiency gains are not 2x, but 10x? What if you'll only need to employ one trucker to do the job of 10? Do you think demand for trucking will go up 10x? This isn't a web framework.
- TJ-14 9y agoEverything that you buy online, in a Walmart, or is otherwise manufactured a city away from where it's sold? Trucking costs are built into most products. My grocery store sells apples from California. If the cost of trucking them to me goes down, those apples will decrease in cost and they will potentially sell more apples.
- Spooky23 9y agoShipping probably cost less than the plastic container. Automation of driving is all about making people with lots of capital richer. Efficiency is just the dream -- this stuff will dramatically increase costs of shipping as capacity is constrained.
- infecto 9y agoSomeone still needs to accompany the truck. Sure perhaps in the distant future this is not true but at least for the generation of current truckers a person will still be necessary. Yes wages are the biggest expense but I think the big pushed for self-driving trucks is 1) Reduced liability 2) Trucks can be operating nearly 24hrs a day. 3) Greater fuel efficiency. So sure some will lose their jobs but I think half is overly pessimistic.
- HeyLaughingBoy 9y agoKeep in mind wages are already fairly low In comparison to a computer programmer, yes. In comparison to the nationwide average, no. https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=3&cad=rja&uact=8&ved=0ahUKEwi5vMKdsdLUAhVo74MKHVVTDHAQFgguMAI&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.truckdriverssalary.com%2Fhow-much-can-you-earn-your-1st-year-as-a-trucker%2F&usg=AFQjCNHrhbzA9AlajalycKMf_eI2Jie2vw https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&c... I can immediately think of one (retired) truck driver I know who comfortably raised a family of 6 on a single salary.
- boomboomsubban 9y agoYou linked a site that makes money on convincing people to spend money getting a CDL, not really a reliable source. Very few truckers are doing well, even your source wages aren't that great for most positions when you add in the other costs. And USA Today had a piece last week about one working unsafe hours and making as little as $.67 a week. https://www.usatoday.com/pages/interactives/news/rigged-forced-into-debt-worked-past-exhaustion-left-with-nothing/ https://www.usatoday.com/pages/interactives/news/rigged-forc...
- taneq 9y agoThe hourly wages are very low. Some truckers earn decent money because they work insane hours.
- Spooky23 9y agoTrucker wages are not low. It's a middle class job in many cases and a decent semiskilled job in others. Most of those roles managing bullshit at the head end will go away as the robot fleets consolidate and the current carriers die off. Customers will have to take or leave on whatever terms the carrier demands -- just like the old railroad days.
- bluGill 9y agoIt doesn't help that human drivers are fundamentally unsafe (even if you restrict the discussion to sober drivers). Making computers safer than human drivers (not perfect) is enough for me to restrict human drivers to private tracks. I am not the only person who has lost a loved friend because of a careless driver.
- throw2016 9y agoThere is no data to make this assertion about computer driven vehicles. There is little basis to declare human drivers 'fundamentally unsafe' given the proportion of accidents pales in comparison to the gigantic volume of vehicles on roads worldwide over varied road and traffic conditions. It can be speculated automated vehicles may require constraints on roads in which case it becomes apples to oranges. And human drivers equipped with the kind of technology and sensors on self driven cars would be much safer.
- adrianN 9y agoHumans have only two eyes and terrible reaction times. They also get distracted easily and tend to act emotionally often. There is little data to show that computers are better drivers, because currently they aren't, but they lack human weaknesses and are safer than humans in many other situations (planes, trains...).
- bicubic 9y agoNo, there's just not enough data. While computers lack human weaknesses, they bring a slew of new ones. Computers have no situational awareness, no context, are vulnerable to hacking, respond in predetermined ways which can be manipulated or abused, etc. There just is not enough evidence to make the claim that ubiquitous autonomous cars will be any safer than human drivers on shared roads. There are many known unknowns and who knows how many unknown unknowns left to discover and mitigate with this tech. https://techcrunch.com/2017/03/17/laying-a-trap-for-self-driving-cars/ https://techcrunch.com/2017/03/17/laying-a-trap-for-self-dri...
- kushti 9y ago
- vlunkr 9y ago> it's not like they'll get to ride along and supervise the autonomous vehicle You don't think so? Seems like an unmanned truck would be a great target for theft.
- tdb7893 9y agoIt's a little harder because you can lock it with a pretty significant lock, it's generally moving, and it has a ton of location and camera data. If the police are notified of your exact position when you start the robbery it's probably hard to get enough stuff to make it actually worth the risk. The hard part isn't getting the truck to stop (which is trivially easy now), it's actually getting stuff and getting away with it.
- Retric 9y agoThese trucks often have 1,000,000+$ worth of cargo. That's worth a fair amount of risk and effort even if you lose 80% of it on the black market that's still better than most robberies.
- lhuser123 9y ago> These trucks often have 1,000,000+$ worth of cargo. That's true, but the problem is which one? Most of them are dry vans that you don't know what's inside, and/or not worth the risk. My loaded trailer was once opened and they didn't touch the merchandise. The only loss was the lock.
- stale2002 9y agoSure, but you could also just rob people NOW. Just go on an open stretch of road in the country side with a firearm and open fire through the truck windows. A truck driver isn't going to be able to defend themselves. You might argue that this doesn't happen because criminals are afraid of getting caught by the police and sent to jail. But, if anything, the risks would be even greater for a self driving truck that has dozens of always on cameras recording, GPS tracking, and an emergency police call system.
- 9y ago
- dx034 9y agoI think the concept looks good. They will still use truckers for some parts of the trip (and will have to do so for a while). The good thing is that those truckers can work 8 hour shifts close to home. And it won't really be a topic for outsourcing because the latency would be too high, so control centers will have to be somewhat close to the truck (at least same continent). Semi-autonomous driving of trucks could change the job for the better. It would cost a lot of jobs but then again, few people become truck drivers because they love being on the road for days. For most it's a job and they'd be happy to take another one. And there is currently little evidence that no new jobs would come up as they always have for past disruptions.