3 ms·
It's pretty hard to block these sites because you have to know the domain name/information on each one. Assuming large-scale voluntary compliance, and I think t
by cookiecaper 16y ago
It's pretty hard to block these sites because you have to know the domain name/information on each one. Assuming large-scale voluntary compliance, and I think the chances are good that all the "big" producers will move over, it's much easier to just filter the xxx domain and be done with it.
Usually the idea is to keep it away from children because children will willfully look at it without understanding. That page that says "Absolutely DO NOT look at this if you're under 18" has no relevance to an under-18 year old.
It's the same reason we put all other restraints on teenagers; if they were capable of detecting trouble and reliably refusing to participate therein, then they wouldn't need all of the things that are in place to protect them from themselves, foremost among these being parents.
- jasonlotito 16y ago> It's pretty hard to block these sites because you have to know the domain name/information on each one. No, you do not. There are services out there that assist in this. http://www.cybersitter.com/ http://www.cybersitter.com/ http://www.netnanny.com/ http://www.netnanny.com/ http://www.cyberpatrol.com/ http://www.cyberpatrol.com/ http://www.asacp.org/ http://www.asacp.org/ Couple this with parental controls in Windows and Mac (I'm sure it has it), and you don't have to know each domain. > Assuming large-scale voluntary compliance, and I think the chances are good that all the "big" producers will move over, it's much easier to just filter the xxx domain and be done with it. There already is voluntary compliance amongst the the big producers, as well as the smaller ones. There is no incentive to attract children. These sites have already a vested interest in their current domains. Do you realize the cost involved with moving domains at the scale you are discussing? For what? To do what's already possible and being done? I'd be more worried about sites that you wouldn't think to place in .xxx and yet are in many ways worse (looking at you, reddit!)
- Groxx 16y agoAnd how about any of the infinite mirrors which aren't the big producers? And do they block RapidShare? Torrents? It's impossible to filter it all (maybe with strong A.I., but show me a porn filter that has that and I'll denounce this claim).
- jasonlotito 16y agoWhat nonsense are you talking about? What does Rapidshare or Torrents have to do with filtering out porn sites that would use the .xxx TLD? > It's impossible to filter it all And? .xxx won't change that. At all.
- Groxx 16y agoRapidshare hosts a lot of porn. If you're looking to filter the internet for the purity of person X, a random link could lead them through that and to porn. Q.E.D. Similarly, torrents are not always what they're advertised to be. And I wasn't implying it will change the filtering problem. Merely pointing out that it isn't easy, which you implied quite strongly. Schools have been struggling with it since they started (magazines behind books), and paying companies like those large amounts of money for woefully incomplete solutions.
- jasonlotito 16y ago> And I wasn't implying it will change the filtering problem. Merely pointing out that it isn't easy, which you implied quite strongly You're taking things out of context, and putting words in my mouth. This is a discussion of the .xxx TLD. My contention is that .xxx won't improve porn blocking precisely because of the reasons you mentioned. There are already tools that do a lot of work to block it, and .xxx isn't going to change anything. The sites that would use .xxx are already blocked. So, a porn sites are already blocked, and will use .xxx just to have it. It won't improve blocking. At the same time, .xxx won't block sites that don't play by the rules, and sites like RapidShare or Reddit, where you can find porn. That's what I've been saying.
- astine 16y agoNo, you do not. There are services out there that assist in this. http://www.cybersitter.com/ http://www.cybersitter.com/ http://www.netnanny.com/ http://www.netnanny.com/ http://www.cyberpatrol.com/ http://www.cyberpatrol.com/ http://www.asacp.org/ http://www.asacp.org/ Have you ever actually used any of these tools? They are horrible. They have a much worse cpu and network overhead than McAfee and aren't remote effective filters unless set to unreasonably restrictive settings. Proxies working on pre-compiled blacklists and whitelists are a better solution and the new tld could only help with this. Even if only new pornographic site were ever given a "xxx" tld, then it would save the effort of having to explicitly blacklist them.
- cookiecaper 16y agoThose services either use really crappy (many false hits both ways) and heavy heuristics to try and determine that a pornographic image was downloaded and block it before display AND/OR a known "blacklist". So while you can outlist the compilation of said blacklist, someone still has to add sites that were confirmed to contain the material. Both ways are inefficient and spotty. I admitted in my first post that you will never rid the internet of porn or make it completely unavailable to anyone. There is always a way around. But if the filter is good enough, unless the person is really determined, they will give up before they find its cracks. Also, filtration is great for preventing an accidental stumbling-upon and so on. A .xxx domain just makes sense, there's no reason not to do it. If you want to look at porn, you can find new sites by trying whatever, like, wallace_naked.xxx. You can filter for hyperlinks only to other .xxx sites. If you don't want to look at porn, you just blacklist the whole TLD and a great deal more work is done for you. Again, you're right that there will still be porn on .com. I don't think anyone believes that's going to go away. But it's just a matter of simplicity; a .xxx tld helps everyone either way, so what's the problem? I would be opposed to mandatory enforcement of this provision, but I think most legit porn producers will switch over for the citizenship points.