2 ms·
Looking from within the AI/ML field, I don't think that state actors (or the major tech megacorps) are somehow special in terms of progress in a manner that mak
by PeterisP 9y ago
Looking from within the AI/ML field, I don't think that state actors (or the major tech megacorps) are somehow special in terms of progress in a manner that makes them unmeasurable.
Yes, they have certain datasets that are somewhat larger/better than those available to the research community and somewhat easier access to larger clusters of hardware. However, that's generally a minor and (more importantly) predictable advantage - I may not be able to train as good a model of X as Google does because they have more data and hardware, but I can estimate that their model is likely to have e.g. 20% lower error rate; which gives a meaningful advantage in product quality but doesn't really enable anything conceptually different.
Yes, there are certain technologies that are developed by them and not yet published, but looking at all the competition, what is seen in the products they build, and and what is seen in what state actors are funding/attempting to buy, they're not significantly beyond what is known to the public, at there seems to be no more than 6-12 months lag between when a capability becomes available and when it's seen by everyone else. It may take more than that for others to replicate, but within 6-12 months, people would have a general idea on what it'd take to replicate and what are the limits of such capabilities.
Yes, the bigger actors may have invested lots of effort to polish things that are important to them - so if you're seeing a researcher's proof of concept held together by duct tape then you should keep in mind that somebody can have a reasonably working prototype of that hidden in their labs; but if you're not seeing anything close to a proof of concept in the research community (or at least claims "we know how to make a proof of concept quickly if there was funding for that"), then the capability doesn't exit yet; somebody may have unpublished results but that's included in the "6-12 months advantage" I mentioned above.
Regarding user rights, IMHO you don't need to worry about still unknown capabilities of ML/AI but instead about how (and how widely) they'll apply and deploy ML/AI capabilities that are already well known. E.g. there's no question that we can run face recognition to everyone seen by a sufficiently high quality camera and try to match those places to social media profiles; all serious state actors definitely have such a capability iff they are willing (and have the funding/manpower) to build and run the required infrastructure. Whether they will do so is a question of economics and politics, not about AI/ML tech. In order to massively (ab)use something, it needs to have a certain technological readiness level; and there's a long gap between invention and sufficient maturity for that.