5 ms·
>They'll take the jobs if you pay well enough. Taking a job and doing it with sufficient attention/quality/skills/etc. are two different things. No money would
by trhway 9y ago
>They'll take the jobs if you pay well enough.
Taking a job and doing it with sufficient attention/quality/skills/etc. are two different things. No money would make most of Americans working 110F strawberry field for any prolonged period of time. Even $1M/day - most would just quit after a week with cool $7M (at least i'd :)
Of course, the immigration system making illegals pretty much slaves is just a shame for a civilized society and has to be replaced with more humane system. We should value and respect people doing such hard and undesirable jobs. Practically it means at least minimum wage and all the labor laws irrespective of status (one of the effects otherwise is just breeding predatory employers and that drugs the society back and lower). And of course the minimum wage in US should already be 2x-3x what it is now (the current minimum wage in US is another shame for a civilized society)
- frgtpsswrdlame 9y agoActually I think $40/hr (obviously not a real number) would get quite a large labor migration to the strawberry fields. North Dakota saw a huge influx of out-of-work men when oil was booming.
- kelnos 9y agoSure, and then the price of strawberries goes up, and grocery shoppers complain and don't buy them. The US is addicted to cheap goods. In many sectors cheap goods can't be had without cheap labor.
- ng12 9y agoErhm, you can't be addicted to cheap goods if cheap goods don't exist. People weren't any less materialistic in the 60's they just had less cheap stuff to buy. Business push prices down to make more money not because they have to satiate rabid consumers.
- pm24601 9y agoYeap - A real shame if the CEOs had to take a lower paycheck in order to pay their workers more. Yeap - a real shame.
- ams6110 9y agoThere are probably some exceptions but in most businesses you could eliminate the CEO salary altogether and there wouldn't be enough savings to give "the workers" more than a very small raise.
- pm24601 9y ago[Former] Wells Fargo CEO John Stumpf made 473 times more than the salary of a median employee, according to Bloomberg. That ratio of CEO-to-employee pay puts Wells Fargo at No. 33 among S&P 500 companies and third highest among financial institutions on the list. He earned $19.3 million in total compensation last year. Add in the other highly paid C-level people in WFC and Split that with the median paid and below employees would mean about $3000/year. For a full-time teller making about $30K/year that is a 10% salary difference. I do call that much more than a "small" raise.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- cottonpicker 9y agoBut the median-wage Wells Fargo employee is a crook who defrauds Wells Fargo employees. It is not right that those employees should profit from abusing customers. Clearly, top-tier executives should be the ones to profit from this.
- pm24601 9y agoCorrection: > Wells Fargo employee is a scapegoat
- kelnos 9y ago
- cottonpicker 9y agoYou are exactly right. But who said that strawberries should be inexpensive and found in every fridge in America? What you have just acknowledged is that strawberries are not cheap. They should not be cheap. The real danger here is not that Americans will be deprived of strawberries. The danger is that some American who does not actually harvest strawberries will not be able to profit so much from strawberries. Their business will be in jeopardy. It is obviously bad for America when we drive businesses out of business. American business people need to be able to have somebody else do all the work very cheaply so that the American business person can profit. If nobody values your product enough to pay its true costs, the answer is to reduce costs by having somebody else work cheaper. If the free market doesn't support cheaper labor costs, you need to use some other method to reduce labor costs. Wielding control of immigration status is one tool to incent cheaper labor.
- louithethrid 9y agoThe slave system only prevents further automation
- jamesblonde 9y agoFrom experience of both Sweden and the US, levels of automation are an order of magnitude higher here in Sweden. Then again, taxi drivers, cleaners, and waitresses earn a living wage here and are respected members of society.
- euyyn 9y agoYeah, that's kind of his point, I understood: If you have to pay humane wages, you have a stronger incentive to invest in automation.
- louithethrid 9y agoIt also kills the human-robot job, where basically a normal human is taken and his brain is replaced for 8 hours with a mobile app, running a task.
- ABCLAW 9y agoYet somehow the mining industry doesn't seem to have problems paying highly trained people to sit underground for 10+ hours a day sitting around explosives and heavy machinery. Perhaps you should look up Woofing.
- sedachv 9y ago> No money would make most of Americans working 110F strawberry field for any prolonged period of time. Anecdotal counter-point: there are plenty of Americans making decent money in similar conditions working marijuana farms on the West coast during harvest seasons. I have met a few and they do not complain about the work.
- xxSparkleSxx 9y agoThis is the bubble you live in. I grew up in the Midwest and my white middle class brothers spent some summers in strawberry fields picking and in corn fields detassling (not 110F, but mid 90's). There aren't many immigrants there so you'll find tons of lower-middle/lower class white Americans in those jobs. Landscaping is mostly white, maids are mostly white, and construction work is mostly white. Becase most people there are white. Take a trip to the Midwest and see how the rest of the country lives.
- davvolun 9y ago> There aren't many immigrants there WHAT are you talking about? > Landscaping is mostly white, maids are mostly white, and construction work is mostly white I can't say anything about landscaping or maids, I've never noticed, but construction work is not mostly white, or at least, you can't simply discount the number of non-white construction workers. In my experience, immigrants in the Midwest are simply more segregated than in other places.
- xxSparkleSxx 9y agoIf you're talking "big" Midwest cities, yea there's definitely segregation. But go out into the sticks a bit or 30 minutes outside any city and it's mostly white. I grew up in the suburbs of one of the largest cities in my state (city pop. 110,000 - suburb pop. 25,000). If I go onto wikipedia it says my suburb was and still is 90%+ white (closer to 97% when I was growing up) and the city is currently 82% white, 1% asian, and 2.5% hispanic (and these numbers have become more diverse since 15-20 years ago when I was growing up). Visiting Chicago, St. Louis, Louisville, and other large cities in the Midwest will not give you a good idea how most people in the Midwest live. At least half of the immigrants or children of immigrants I met while growing up actually didn't do service work. No one wants to move to bumfuck nowhere with little diversity, little job opportunity, and no major hub for anything nearby. Lots of Asian immigrants that came due to a Toyota plant that was built somewhat close to my suburb, lots of Indian and Middle-Eastern physicians, and about 1/10 of the Hispanic immigrants seemed to own their own restaurant/chain of restaurants. It's seriously crazy how different the world I grew up in is compared to the one most liberal, coastal, upper-middle class people experienced (the bubble I'm in now). I really wish everyone on the coasts could take a year to live in the middle-of-nowhere flyover country, it's amazing how Americans struggle to even believe the experiences of their fellow countrymen in different geographic regions.