4 ms·
I don't think this is very compelling. The example given (searching for a particular Marriott) works flawlessly in Google and I can get at much more informatio
by jgrahamc 16y ago
I don't think this is very compelling. The example given (searching for a particular Marriott) works flawlessly in Google and I can get at much more information than Open Graph tagged sites will give me.
What problem is this solving?
- izendejas 16y agoWhat facebook is trying to build is not a search engine. Rather, I believe they're building more of a recommendation engine. As your friends (in theory) begin to "like" a bunch of stuff on the web, next time you do a search for hotels, the hotels your friends "liked" will show up. The meta data for each site/artist, etc you like will also give them (in theory) enough data to recommend not just on what your friends like. Whoever unlocks the magic in the data and offers a compelling, personalized experience will rule the next decade.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- bad_user 16y ago> As your friends (in theory) begin to "like" a bunch of stuff on the web, next time you do a search for hotels, the hotels your friends "liked" will show up. The ranking algorithm used by Google most definitely factors in the clicks that webpage received ... and they can also calculate if a user is satisfied with a certain result (if not, that user will get back to the search results page). Google has all the data it needs for me to view the hotels my friends liked. Not only that, but it has better data ... when one of my friends says he likes something on Facebook, that's mostly a vanity / ego-inflating action (oh, look at me, I'm so great for liking this stuff). When one of my friends clicks on a hotel link in Google, though, the recommendation he gives is implicit, not explicit. The problem with Google is that they have a lot of noise (they are the first target when webmasters want to become visible, so every piece of shit on the web is crawled by Google). And in the battle of spam versus Google, spam is winning. If you don't believe me, try searching for interesting stuff to read in a certain area (like ruby on rails) on http://delicious.com http://delicious.com. The same principle applies, with the difference being that delicious doesn't index the content on those pages and it also doesn't have a lot of spam ... so if you're searching for clear tags, like "data mining", you're going to get pretty good results, simply because bookmarking a link on delicious is not ego-inflating. So, IMHO ... one day a better search engine will emerge from social networks, but it's not going to be based on any "like" button.
- Aaronontheweb 16y agoI think Facebook is vastly overestimating the number of people who are actually going to go out and "like" stuff.
- sanj 16y agoThe effort of Liking is easily an order of magnitude less than creating a link, which is what (nominally) Google uses. And I'd SWAG that an order of magnitude more people are capable of Liking than are even able to create a new link.
- Aaronontheweb 16y agoThe effort to implement a like button on a site is an order of magnitude more difficult than implementing a link.
- steveklabnik 16y agoActually, it's not. Instead of an a tag, it's an iframe where the link is passed in as a parameter. It took me approximately 90 seconds to implement from looking at the docs to deploy to one of my sites.
- jonknee 16y agoTechnically 90 seconds is an order of magnitude more difficult than making a regular link. Not a huge hurdle, but I don't need to read any docs or go fetch embed code to make a link.
- steveklabnik 16y ago... I guess it's also because I'm using Rails, so I'm already generating links via a helper function. So I wrote another, one line helper that does the wrapping. So that initial 90 seconds is amortized over every new Like button I add, because I use like_url rather than link_to. Also, often like buttons are used on something like stories, so you're only adding the code to one template, and now you have tons of like buttons all over.
- sanj 16y agoClicking on the link doesn't take you to a Facebook page -- it takes you to the TripAdvisor page, which is chock full of additional information. That page may also tell you if you have friends that have "liked" that property, which is not available via Google. Full disclosure: I work at TripAdvisor and I led the Like project where we were a launch partner for Facebook. I don't think that there's anything left that I can't talk about; I'm happy to answer question. ps. And yeah, we're hiring to make this stuff more better.
- paul9290 16y agoProblem this solves; making search more relevant & personal.... Further whose advice and opinion holds more weight for you in regards to where to stay in Hawaii, best restaurant, etc? Your network of friends/family/contacts or a search engine? Who holds more influence over you for vacation spots, restaurants, experiences with businesses? Some examples I can think of now of how this is a better form of search. Though Google wins for me when needing directions, queries on pieces of history and the like; things your friends do not know but would tell you to search Google. Overall i don't get the whole business mantra "What problem does this solve," when creating a start-up. SOme of the biggest sites on the web (Facebook or Twitter) were not solving any problem - rather they created new ways for us humans to communicate.