5 ms·
"Where breaking the law benefits everyone, we should lose respect for the law." In this case, it doesn't benefit everyone, especially not everyone equally -- i
by toss1 9y ago
"Where breaking the law benefits everyone, we should lose respect for the law."
In this case, it doesn't benefit everyone, especially not everyone equally -- it benefits Uber massively, and only incidentally benefits customers, and basically rips off the driver's time and investment.
That said, you're resting on the point that this kind of thing can occasionally bring about marginally beneficial change faster than legal methods.
What you are arguing is that "startups" should be allowed to freelance the rearrangement of benefits in our society and ignore the law in doing so. You want the rule of entrepreneurial people to override the rule of law.
Yet, this is a society and country built on the rule of law.
And yes, the rule of law is much more cumbersome than the rule of men/women.
What you argue for is tantamount to anarchy, or at best rule by (economic) warlord.
It may seem like a good idea at first, but it is a rapid path to a broken society.
- dv_dt 9y agoThough it conflicts with other desirable principles, I think that without Uber, almost all of the innovation benefits from ride sharing would not have been pursued by the existing taxi industry. Customers have benefited directly and indirectly from the presence of Uber. While one does need to maintain a "rule of law" to maintain society, but I would argue that the application of that is not wholly a precise mathematical or computational execution of laws. There needs to be a human-based fuzzy medium in that rule, the binary and complete enforcement of the laws as the definition of "rule of law" is both an unattainable standard and a terrifying goal. That little human buffer isn't 'anarchy', it's a needed degree of freedom needed to prevent tyranny becoming a friction that grinds up the entire machine of our society.
- toss1 9y agoThe elements of "fuzzy medium", "buffer", human judgement should of course always be included in any justice system. That does not justify deliberately and systematically exploiting the slack in the system for your own benefit and to the detriment of others. Uber was and is not civil disobedience. Its business model was to exploit every bit of available slack in the system to its own benefit and to the detriment of everyone else. Notice how the typical driver only lasts a few months there. This is flatly unethical, and the broad-based unethical slime came right from the top in the form of scandal after scandal, which finally sunk the CEO (and rightfully so). And NO, the ends do not justify the means. Especially not when the means are a massive unethical and exploitative company being built to accelerate by a few years the hidebound practices of a minor industry for a minor improvement in the occasional transportation convenience of urban hipsters. And, while it of course had the minor benefit of accelerating improvement in the taxi industry, it also destroyed the business value of those in the industry, many of whom are aspiring small businesses whose retirement (value of medallion) is now 6-figure debt. It has also probably torched billions of investment capital that could have gone to other more productive and ethical uses in the technology industry. (my bet is that Uber is in a death spiral.) Moreover, it was completely unnecessary for it to have been so unethical. Merely remaining as a proper and ethical ride-sharing service as it (purportedly) started, would have created similar innovation at a more moderate pace. Again, the ends do not justify the means. Not in this case and not as a general rule. I recommend taking a few ethics courses or reading a few philosophers.
- Jabanga 9y ago>it benefits Uber massively, and only incidentally benefits customers, and basically rips off the driver's time and investment. This is a very paternalistic attitude toward the drivers, who are choosing to drive for Uber because they perceive it as being the best option available to them. It's also been an incredible boon to customers. >What you argue for is tantamount to anarchy, or at best rule by (economic) warlord. This is scaremongering. People being free to engage in voluntary economic interactions in no way resembles the violent imposition of warlordism. It's the regulatory enforcement agents running sting operations and fining people and impounding their cars that are engaging in strong-arming tactics that break the peace. Remember what the foundation of law is: https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2016/06/enforcing-the-law-is-inherently-violent/488828/ https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2016/06/enforci... It has no place restricting voluntary economic interactions.
- ubernostrum 9y agoThis is a very paternalistic attitude toward the drivers, who are choosing to drive for Uber because they perceive it as being the best option available to them. Ah yes. They obviously think this is the best of all possible worlds. If they were given the option to do something else -- say, work as high-paid software engineers -- they'd obviously choose not to, and continue driving, because they've rationally evaluated the plethora of fulfilling career options available to them and settled on driving for Uber as the one which brings them the greatest overall happiness. Or perhaps they live in an economic system structured to disadvantage large numbers of people and leave them without many, if any, fulfilling options so that people like you can sit back and declare that a realistic choice was available to all of them, and they chose low-paying jobs (sorry, "independent contracting arrangements") with poor work conditions, thus making it entirely their fault and no-one else's.
- Jabanga 9y ago>Ah yes. They obviously think this is the best of all possible worlds. I didn't say they think it's the best of all possible worlds. I said they think it's the best option available to them. Making that particular relationship they've chosen to enter illegal, because you think it is not sufficiently lucrative for them, is not going to help them. The other options on the market are not going to improve by virtue of low pay options being made illegal. Every price level, including wages, is driven by supply and demand. Impositions like the kind you're advocating cannot possibly provide more benefit than harm, because they do not shift the demand curve to the right through an increase in the aggregate demand for labour. Only increases in productivity can do that. >If they were given the option to do something else -- say, work as high-paid software engineers -- they'd obviously choose not to, and continue driving, because they've rationally evaluated the plethora of fulfilling career options available to them and settled on driving for Uber as the one which brings them the greatest overall happiness. This is an extreme strawman. I never said they wouldn't exploit a better option if one were available. I said the best option available is the one they took, and making it illegal is not going make better options appear. >Or perhaps they live in an economic system structured to disadvantage large numbers of people and leave them without many I don't see any evidence that the economic system is designed through a conspiracy to disadvantage them. Market institutions like private property rights have facilitated a massive increase in wages for the typical person over the last 400 years. What you're advocating will slow wage growth. In fact, like the link I provided shows, the type of occupational and business licensing you advocate for is a major cause of growing income disparity. It has exactly the opposite effect of what you intend. >and they chose low-paying jobs (sorry, "independent contracting arrangements") with poor work conditions, thus making it entirely their fault and no-one else's. You're not helping them by making that option unavailable to them. It's a misguided paternalistic mindset to think that you are. By all means offer them the training so they can work as a highly paid software engineer (if you can), but don't take away their existing options out of a belief that you know better than them what's in their own best interest.