3 ms·
But I don't view that stock buyback as successful.[...]But we let the cash sit in the bank and worse we gave a lot of it back to investors in a manner that did
by yummyfajitas 16y ago
But I don't view that stock buyback as successful.[...]But we let the cash sit in the bank and worse we gave a lot of it back to investors in a manner that did not do much for the company.
Cash for investors? But doing nothing for the company? That's a good thing and more companies should do this.
The sole purpose of the company is [1] to increase shareholder value. If reinvesting in the company would bring above-market returns, then it's a good idea to do. If not, corporate leadership should increase shareholder value with cash rather than building an empire with other people's money.
[1] I ignore nonprofits and corporations with special clauses in their charter.
- yoseph 16y agoCouldn't agree more re increasing shareholder value. Also, a share buyback signals to investors that the company believes its shares are undervalued.
- davidw 16y agoI think the point is that if you're a startuppish company, you should still have "places to go" with your money in the bank rather than being "out of ideas", like RIM apparently is, as he mentions at the end.
- timwiseman 16y agoYou are completely right, but very few "startuppish" companies do buybacks. In fact, depending on how you draw the lines very few "startuppish" companies are publicly traded. It is possible for a more mature company to have truly reached market saturation in their area. Then they are left with the option of investing in R&D to try to make something truly new, trying to branch out outside of their current area, or distributing the profits to shareholders. These three stategies are not mutually exclusive and a company with sufficient profits can do all three. But both R&D and diverisifying can involving risking the money put into them (potentially even more than you put into them when you consider liability possibilities), so it can make a lot of sense for a mature company to directly enrish the shareholders, and a stock buyback is one way of doing that.
- dhimes 16y agoThe sole purpose of the company is ... to increase shareholder value The root of all evil, right there. I prefer companies whose sole purpose is to act as an engine of change for a better world. Even Drucker's (?) "sole purpose of a company is to get and retain customers" is better. My real problem with your quote (from Friedman is it?) is that when a majority, or even a vocal and persuasive minority, or people adopt that attitude it throws out a lot of the social constraints in place to keep people running the companies from doing things that harm us as a society. That is, "he was just acting in his own best interest" can be used to justify many acts that are selfish and short-sighted, because there are no social consequences of this. Even people of high personal moral standards are willing to give a pass to evil deeds because "he did what he had to do." I disagree.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoI'm not really sure how your comment is remotely relevant to my post concerning how a company should dispose of a cash surplus (buyback/dividends vs reinvestment). Could you explain?
- dhimes 16y agoI was commenting on the portion I quoted.
- pkaler 16y agoYou are conflating the words value and revenue. Change is a type of value. Time is a type of value. Happiness is a type of value.
- dhimes 16y agoYou are absolutely right. I was referring specifically to financial value. I bet I'm not the only one who makes this unconscious substitution, but you are nevertheless correct.
- loewenskind 16y agoI wish someone would have addressed this post instead of just downvoting. I wouldn't go as far as to say "root of all evil", nor do I think it's a companies responsibility to "make the world a better place" per se but "increase shareholder value" does usually end up meaning "current shareholders". That is, it seems to lead to short term gains at the cost of the long term.