4 ms·
tl;dw Thanks for the summary, tl;dw is right. It's preposterous and sad that the Principal Designer on Firefox values the time of his users so little that he t
by pvg 16y ago
tl;dw
Thanks for the summary, tl;dw is right. It's preposterous and sad that the Principal Designer on Firefox values the time of his users so little that he thinks a 7 minute unskimmable, unlinkable, unindexable, unexcerptable, bandwidth-heavy video (best viewed full-screen, lest you miss a pixel of detail or are tempted to look at some thing of lesser import) is a better way to communicate this change than some text and a few screenshots.
- ugh 16y agoWatching videos feels a lot more comfortable to me than reading text. If I have the time I would always prefer it to reading. As such I think it’s quite over the top of you to use words like “preposterous” and “sad”. There are downsides to it, sure, you described them quite well. It would certainly be best to have both but detesting videos on principle seems a bit preposterous and sad to me.
- pvg 16y agoWell, you have more time and patience than I do and that's fair enough. Video is wonderful so the notion that I 'detest it on principle' is silly. As I said, I can't paste from a video, no search engine can do anything useful with a video, there's no way for me to skip you earnestly telling me things I don't care about in a video. Using video for something that could just as well be conveyed in text and images is a sort of worst of both worlds. More than that, it actually breaks the web. Without linking, excerpting, indexing, there is no web. So I still think the Main Designer Kahuna of Firefox (a web browser) demanding 7 undivided, full-screen minutes of my attention is preposterous and sad, for anything short of 7 minutes of intricate interpretive dance or other information otherwise unsuitable for text and images.
- tomlin 16y ago- How will we show them the tab placement? - How will will show how App Tabs work and how they will look? - How can we explain to the user that the tab display preferences are not locked? - Show users how App Tabs will work and look with UI overloading. - Why we choose to use internal UI over platform. All of these can be displayed with some JPGs/PNGs and a bit of sultry text, but it probably made more sense to compile a video since some of these elements are best shown, rather than described.
- pavel_lishin 16y agoSure, but it would have taken a fraction of the time to also provide screenshots and some explanatory text.
- tomlin 16y agoOf course, but the risk of misunderstanding is eliminated. Screenshots are great, but the misunderstanding is still possible. The point is moot, really. Who cares? They took the time to illustrate a few points. There wasn't any jive, grandstanding or hyperbole. For someone who learns through visuals better, I appreciate the extra effort.
- pvg 16y ago"Sultry" means something other than what you seem to think it means.
- tomlin 16y agoIt's not meant to be taken literally, obviously. Cool your jets, dude.
- pvg 16y agoThere is no way it makes sense, literally or otherwise. Learn to write, dude.
- tomlin 16y agoMy use of the word "Sultry" will go down as possibly one of the worst uses. You (Peter Gadjokov, me thinks) and your HN persona are now forever attributed to petty point outs and hopeful karma bait. Congrats to that.