4 ms·
What's wrong with Flash Cookies?
- civild 16y agoFlash Cookies are also quite often used for "stuffing" by unscrupulous affiliates for all of the reasons mentioned in the article.
- imurray 16y agoI don't use any flash applications that I want to store anything. In the past (in linux) I did: rm -Rf ~/.macromedia && touch ~/.macromedia which stopped flash creating the ~/.macromedia directory and being able to store anything on disk. This caused problems with the odd rare site that insisted on storing things, and the BBC iplayer would become unresponsive. Now I call my browser from a shell script which deletes ~/.macromedia whenever I close it.
- robin_reala 16y agoiPlayer is currently requiring Flash cookies, but long term they say they want to transition to not needing them: http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/bbcinternet/2010/06/lso_flash_cookies_and_media_pl.html http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/bbcinternet/2010/06/lso_flash_coo...
- Tichy 16y agoMy experience with trying to disable cookies was that the (Flash) web became unusable. All sites with Flash content would just keep nagging and nagging.
- dhimes 16y agosomewhere on this site I posted my aliases for dealing with this problem ( http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1401118 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1401118 )
- borism 16y agohow to disable flash cookies http://www.google.com/search?q=disable+flash+cookies http://www.google.com/search?q=disable+flash+cookies
- rythie 16y agoOne problem is that turning them off means that you get lots of prompts in flash to allow them individually.
- skymt 16y agoIt seems like all these problems could be solved by tighter integration with browsers: add hooks for browser privacy features to NPAPI and support them in Flash. Adobe seems to already be heading that way with the new private-browsing support.
- sounddust 16y agoThe Firefox "Better Privacy" extension can delete these when you close the browser, or better yet on a timer, every few minutes. This allows you to use Flash sites that rely on them without most of the privacy issues. (Note: don't play any long-term Flash games with Flash cookies disabled).
- m0tive 16y agoI also use this. Here is the link: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/6623/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/6623/
- DeusExMachina 16y agoAs a side note: "This means that if, for example, you use the private mode to browse pornography..." I like that private browsing is recognized for it's primary purpose without the usual hypocrisy (like: "private browsing is useful when you browse for presents for your family and don't want to spoil the surprise"). We all know why private browsing is there. What I also find quite funny is that Apple was the first one to introduce private browsing. The same Apple that now wants to "free people from porn" (quote from a Steve Jobs email).
- dhimes 16y agoThat's a good point, but the first time I had a need for it was when my wife was searching for "breast cancer treatments," and the search popped up for one of the kids. That caused some grief because they thought that "mommy" was sick. She wasn't/isn't, she was just doing some research, but we had a bit of a tense time. porno was from a different machine :)
- michaelfairley 16y agoI've actually found it immensely useful for being able to log into a different Gmail account without signing out of my primary.
- aarongough 16y agoThat's exactly what I use it for as well.
- xenophanes 16y agoThat's what other browsers are for ;p
- ZeroGravitas 16y agoI think point 2 is no longer true if you're running Flash 10.1 and Firefox, Chrome or IE.
- stevejalim 16y agoIf you've got 5 mins (make a cup of tea) there's a quick talk and live demo about this here, from Oxford Geek Night 17 (http://oxford.geeknights.net/2010/feb-17th/ http://oxford.geeknights.net/2010/feb-17th/): http://ogn.s3.amazonaws.com/16-DavidSheldon.mp4 http://ogn.s3.amazonaws.com/16-DavidSheldon.mp4
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- dhimes 16y agoThis has been around for a very long time (2005 or so). They were originally called Persistent Identification Elements. Have a browse: http://duckduckgo.com?q=persistent+identification+elements&v= http://duckduckgo.com?q=persistent+identification+elements&#...
- troymc 16y agoI use Flush by machacks to delete my Flash cookies. I think it's for Mac OS X only. http://machacks.tv/2009/01/27/flushapp-flash-cookie-removal-tool-for-os-x/ http://machacks.tv/2009/01/27/flushapp-flash-cookie-removal-...
- senki 16y agoI don't understand point 4. Why restore the redundant HTTP cookie?
- jgrahamc 16y agoSo that you can track the user for as long as possible. Very useful if you are running an ad network.
- senki 16y agoBut it's unnecessary since you already set the Flash cookie.
- henry_flower 16y agoIn case user deletes that flash cookie, but forgets to clean the http one!
- gyardley 16y agoI suspect the use of Flash cookies will decline gradually as the use of HTML 5 increases, since a great many of them are just used to store volume settings for commonly-used Flash-based video players. That's not to say the use of Flash cookies by certain ad networks isn't completely obnoxious.
- MichaelGG 16y agoI found the Adobe page to manage these settings[1] to be somewhat funny. The notice underneath the Flash content says: Note: The Settings Manager that you see above is not an image; it is the actual Settings Manager. Click the tabs to see different panels, and click the options in the panels to change your Adobe Flash Player settings What's that say for the UI usability? 1: http://www.macromedia.com/support/documentation/en/flashplayer/help/settings_manager05.html http://www.macromedia.com/support/documentation/en/flashplay...
- code_duck 16y agoWhat I find odd about that page is how it reloads when you switch to different tabs. I thought... it was Flash? And it could just change to the new tab without the whole HTML wrapper page reloading?
- wanderr 16y agoIf you disable 3rd party flash cookies, that should eliminate all unwanted tracking. Meanwhile, flash cookies are useful for other things: Pandora uses them to keep you logged in forever, even if your session on the server dies (unless you log out), on our site we use it to store copious amounts of user data (such as music libraries) so that it doesn't need to be loaded from the server every time you visit. Flash cookies are also a win over regular cookies because they aren't sent along to the server with every single http request.
- arohner 16y agoDoes the FF extension click-to-flash mitigate this?
- code_duck 16y agoSure, that's why I have a cron job to delete /home/<user>/.macromedia/* every night.
- radley 16y agoThis particular issue seems to pop up every year or so and there is vast online info available on the topic already. But Flash-bashing seems to be de rigueur these days... Yes, Adobe is aware of some of the issues mentioned (we Flash pros cringe at the old Macromedia settings windows still in use) but some of his bugs are in fact features (such as being browser agnostic) that behave differently because it's simply different tech (like Mac vs Win). In all fairness, Adobe has their hands very busy these days with AIR, the new Flash player, and porting Flash to multiple platforms. If the old stuff works, they're not messing with it.
- raganwald 16y agoInteresting question: Can HTML5 localStorage be used to circumvent cookie controls in lieu of using Flash cookies?
- mbrubeck 16y agoIt would be pretty intrusive/noticeable, since the user has to opt in to allow the site to use it. So it's probably only a risk on sites that also make legitimate use of Web Storage. localStorage is subject to same-origin restrictions (so advertisers can't easily use it to track you across sites). And localStorage is handled like cookies when you use the private browsing mode in browsers like Firefox and Chrome, e.g.: "When the browser goes into private browsing mode, a new, temporary database is created to store local storage data; this database is empied, and is thrown away when private browsing mode is turned off." https://developer.mozilla.org/en/dom/storage#localStorage https://developer.mozilla.org/en/dom/storage#localStorage (This is true of Flash 10.1 also, but wasn't true for older versions.)
- pornel 16y agoIt can be used as alternative to cookies (HTTP cache can be as well), but it's not as easy: • local storage is limited to page origin. • It's part of the browser, so browser's standard privacy functions can affect it as well.
- adamdecaf 16y agoYep. Set data: window.localStorage.setItem(key, value); Get all data. // (Given that you have the "key" be numeric) /** * var setData = ['trackingID', 'trackingURL', 'trackingTS']; * for ( var i = 0; i < setData.length; i++) { * window.localStorage.setItem(i, setData[i]); * } */ var n = 0, items = [], count = window.localStorage.length; while (n < count) { items[n++] = window.localStorage.getItem(window.localStorage.key(n)); } /* return items; */ ----- Or, you can just set the items with trivial keys (id, timestamp, url) and get the values with window.localStorage.getItem([id, timestamp...]).