3 ms·
what do you mean by real-Linux-on-mobile OS? isn't Android a mobile os running linux? I hope you meant real-GNU /Linux-on-mobileOS note: "Android is running
by c8g 9y ago
what do you mean by real-Linux-on-mobile OS?
isn't Android a mobile os running linux?
I hope you meant real-GNU /Linux-on-mobileOS
note: "Android is running Linux" is certified by Linus Torvalds
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoLinus has a vested interest in taking credit for the most prolific mobile platform. I don't think there is any common sense in the 'Android is Linux' argument beyond that though. As a software platform, it isn't even remotely similar.
- johannesburgel 9y agoAndroid is an operating system built on top of the Linux kernel project. "Android is not Linux but ${DISTRIBUTION} is" is just stupid, operating systems simply cannot be compared to a kernel.
- pjmlp 9y agoNot quite right, NDK applications are constrained in what they can touch and many syscalls have been removed.
- jacquesm 9y agoWhat does Linus have to do with it?
- c8g 9y agojust to mention what I am saying is not just my opinion.
- jacquesm 9y agoThat's not how it works though. Linux is a kernel, and Linus has all the right in the world to make that claim. It doesn't in any way strengthen your argument though because of the different userland. You are comparing apples (operating systems) with oranges (kernels).
- c8g 9y agosorry that I created confusion. I tried to tell that his "real-Linux" (kernel) already exists (I don't know if he meant (in another comment, he said that he meant userland) userland e.g gnu, freedesktop.org etc by "real-Linux")
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- maheart 9y agoI think you're nitpicking, and your comment does nothing to add to the discussion, but I'll say this: If I'd said "Linux-on-the-mobile", you could just as easily have said "Linux (kernel) is already on the mobile!". If I'd said "GNU/Linux-on-the-mobile", you could have argued that Termux[1] adds GNU tools to your Android phone. Half the things you'd expect on a "Linux" system (e.g. systemd, a Wayland compositor, X, DBUS, PulseAudio) are not associated with FSF/GNU at all. Without nitpicking, when you say "Linux" most people think "Red Hat" (or Debian, Ubuntu, Arch, etc), not "Android". [1] https://termux.com/ https://termux.com/