3 ms·
> I said that FP16 performance is at least 60x worse, which it absolutely is. OK, I didn't think that's what you meant because it's a rather silly benchmark to
by modeless 9y ago
> I said that FP16 performance is at least 60x worse, which it absolutely is.
OK, I didn't think that's what you meant because it's a rather silly benchmark to use as it artificially disadvantages the 1080. FP32 deep learning performance on 1080 Ti will usually be ~half of P100's FP16 performance. FP16 is an advantage, but not a 60x advantage, and the 15+ 1080 Tis that you can buy for the price of one P100 are going to be far faster in most deep learning scenarios (admittedly at a higher power/etc cost).
> Comparing the P100 and 1080Ti as if the latter is the consumer version of the former is not useful. They are profoundly different chips.
I couldn't disagree more. The chips are similar enough that most deep learning applications could run on either. Really the only reason to choose P100 for deep learning with the ridiculous prices Nvidia is charging would be memory capacity and bandwidth with the FP16 advantage.
- tanderson92 9y ago> > Comparing the P100 and 1080Ti as if the latter is the consumer version of the former is not useful. They are profoundly different chips. > I couldn't disagree more. The chips are similar enough that most deep learning applications could run on either. Really the only reason to choose P100 for deep learning with the ridiculous prices Nvidia is charging would be memory capacity and bandwidth with the FP16 advantage. Sure, but there are more applications than just deep learning which is where things get fuzzy. The P100 and 1080TI are fundamentally different for anything relating to FP64. I think the point of the GP is, or would hope it is, not to collapse comparisons to the case of deep learning when things like scientific computing make the comparisons necessarily more nuanced.