4 ms·
"Should the internet be archived?" This would be a great question to ask researchers in archaeology, anthropology, linguistics, history, etc. My own impressio
by pmoriarty 9y ago
"Should the internet be archived?"
This would be a great question to ask researchers in archaeology, anthropology, linguistics, history, etc.
My own impression is that the more data there is, the better for researchers. They can always weed out what they don't need later, but there's no way to get back information that has been destroyed or lost.
Also, in the past people have made some horrible choices regarding what's valuable and what's not. For all sorts of reasons, from political to psychological to social, they've done things like burn, discard, or destroy texts and artwork we now consider valuable but they did not. Often, what was considered valuable (like sacred texts) was not really as revealing about their daily lives as things they did not value and discarded.
So I'd really think twice before we discard any records. If there's some kind of serious pressing need to be selective (such as lack of space) that's one thing. But if keeping it more would not be a huge burden, I'm much more of an inclusionist than a deletionist.
- mindcrime 9y agoAlso, in the past people have made some horrible choices regarding what's valuable and what's not. For all sorts of reasons, from political to psychological to social, they've done things like burn, discard, or destroy texts and artwork we now consider valuable but they did not. Case in point: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doctor_Who_missing_episodes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doctor_Who_missing_episodes
- Consultant32452 9y agoDon't forget the original moon landing recordings. How could anyone have thought so little of those that we lost them?
- tdburn 9y agoThat's because we never really landed on the moon!
- ant6n 9y agoI see what you did here: trying to start one of those flame wars that future anthropologists will be as excited about as when they found that village garbage!
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ghaff 9y agoThey were effectively part of the data telemetry that was routinely erased given the cost of media storage. At the time, they were focused on the live broadcast. You'd have thought that someone at the time would have said, "Umm, we just landed on the moon. Maybe we should save all the artifacts that we can." But apparently no one did because we had the actual landing, moon rocks, and TV broadcast.
- chongli 9y agoThis would be a great question to ask researchers in archaeology, anthropology, linguistics, history, etc. We already know the answer to this one. Archaeologists are most excited when they find the village garbage dump. They learn far more about what people's lives were like by sifting through trash than by marveling at pyramids. Archive the internet: crayons, megaphones, Twitter flamewars, and all. What's trivial to us may be critical to archaeologists of the future. They'll be far more interested in how we actually live than in how we want them to see us.
- ghaff 9y agoMuch of Usenet nearly went into the digital dumpster and a fair bit did. In an article about this preservation effort, there's an interesting couple of paragraphs: We started dumping stuff that we thought was obviously of no future use, groups that specialized in a lot of talk and no substance, so to speak. For example, fairly early on there was a newsgroup about abortion which specialized in violent arguments.” That’s why not only the very earliest Usenet posts, before Spencer started archiving in 1981 (Usenet began in 1979) but even some of the posts in the 1980s are still lost. It’s too bad; today, wouldn’t more of us rather see what was being said about abortion in 1984 than sift through the arcana of bug fixes in systems that have probably been long since retired? “It was perfectly reasonable from the viewpoint of stuff that we might want to use again, but a little sad from today’s viewpoint,” Spencer admits. http://www.salon.com/2002/01/08/saving_usenet/ http://www.salon.com/2002/01/08/saving_usenet/
- nitwit005 9y ago> My own impression is that the more data there is, the better for researchers. The downside of this, is you end up with buildings full of things no one looks at. You can't hold onto all the world's art, history, and scientific samples, without eventually throwing some stuff out. It will probably never be cheap to store something like "The full set of all Facebook photos and videos", which means we'll probably end up keeping a sample of some of this stuff.
- dredmorbius 9y agoConsider that a large portion of the value in those works now considered valuable is their scarcity. There are achaeological artifacts (and paleontological ones) which are old, but not particularly useful. Price = Demand / Supply