3 ms·
I'd love to compare the results of this final analysis with the FUD that I remember coming out following this crash on Reddit et al with a series of people sayi
by dmix 9y ago
I'd love to compare the results of this final analysis with the FUD that I remember coming out following this crash on Reddit et al with a series of people saying 'I told you so'.
Complex systems of risk mitigation tends to get pushed in the media as an ideal solution to these accidents well before the complete facts come in. Common sense precaution is typically ignored in this culture of total risk adverse superiority that floats to the surface after these events and would ultimately result in very few of these experimental products, which drive innovation, being tested (as is clearly the case in many risk adverse cultures such as Japan and Switzerland).
With any early adopter's of automation whose success is partially dependent on human intervention (ie, flying planes) having stories of failures of incentives to know when or not to actually listen to the warnings provided by the interface over your own intuition is helpful not only in training but also in the design of these systems.
To not expect a certain degree of these types of failure situations where the system largely acted as intended is naive and ultimately defeatist.
I hope the drivers realize the risk they are engaging in here and take appropriate behavioural change as a result but I can't imagine many formal systems that would practically be effective here at deterring these situations other than maybe adapting educational training and the content of the warning systems.
- CydeWeys 9y agoAs someone who doesn't own a car but is often a cyclist or pedestrian, I don't want to be reliant on drivers' (potentially lacking) common sense for my safety.
- dmix 9y agoThat's why when I bike daily in Toronto I take full lanes where it's obvious there isn't much room for bikes on the side or cars are turning right. I also pass on the left when cars will clearly be turning right on a green or red light. I'm amazed that this is a rare thing for a biker to do, when it should be common sense, but it's always best to design systems for the lowest common denominator. Still I'm amazed so many bikers put so much trust in other cars and assume they are looking into to their mirrors when they turn or merge. The best advice I've heard as a cyclist is that it's safest to assume no driver is paying attention and act accordingly. This is common sense precaution. When it comes to designing automated driving systems there is also a safe assumption that common sense (by other people) isn't expected to a certain degree so prepare for edge cases. But in the particular case I'm not sure what you can do beyond running those 7 warnings before the crash. All I said is that the language used and severity of the warnings could be tested in experiments as well as considering the marketing of the efficacy of the systems to early adopters of alpha systems. Basically eliminating over confidence in existing oversight mechanisms.