3 ms·
The dementia argument is compelling; is a criminal missing all of the memories from his criminal past still a criminal? Punishment makes no sense when the punis
by jeroenhd 9y ago
The dementia argument is compelling; is a criminal missing all of the memories from his criminal past still a criminal? Punishment makes no sense when the punished doesn't understand what they're punished for.
As for the other elderly, although there is not much of a risk that these elderly prisoners will fall back to a life of crime, they are still there for a reason. One of the prisoners used as an example has been convicted of a sex attack he committed when he was 68. Another prisoner used as an example has committed several serious crimes, each worse than the last. He's been given multiple chances to better himself; he didn't, so he has to face the consequences.
We can hardly stop punishing criminals "because they're too old". The whole idea of a prison is that you get less freedom and luxuries than the people outside. Putting prisoners in a special home would give them the same (and for some people, even more) luxuries than the elderly outside the prison have.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- sgift 9y ago> We can hardly stop punishing criminals "because they're too old". Actually, here in Germany, that is possible. You can be "vollzugsuntauglich" which means being unable to be in prison. Mental sickness is one of the reasons. Others are not as clearly defined, but old age is a common one. (For those interested: §455 StPO, I didn't find an English translation with a quick search)
- biofox 9y agoIt depends where you fall on the issue of rehabilitation vs punishment. Being inclined to utilitarianism, my personal view is that if a person isn't a risk to society any more, we probably shouldn't be using resources to prove a moral point. Maybe house arrest would be a good compromise for elderly prisoners?
- rlpb 9y ago> rehabilitation vs punishment There's also protection (which I think you allude to) and deterrent. If life no longer "means life", will that increase criminality because there is less of a deterrent? I'm not taking any position on this; just pointing out that it should be considered in addition to rehabilitation, punishment and protection.
- dvtv75 9y ago> If life no longer "means life", will that increase criminality because there is less of a deterrent? For an answer to that, have a look into New Zealand's criminal law system. Life there means, I think, about 15 years.
- jankotek 9y agoThere is a law that every business/office needs to be accessible for a wheelchair. Why prisons should be an exception?
- honestoHeminway 9y agoIts really problematic, there is a special kind of dementia which - sort of rots the moral decision making part of the brain. There was a previos HN article on it. So what do you do with a individual which is intellecutal highly capable, but completely unable to make a moral decision.