3 ms·
Hmm it didn't seem horribly misleading to me, either before or after reading the article. They are trying to stop state investigations. The title doesn't say an
by dahart 9y ago
Hmm it didn't seem horribly misleading to me, either before or after reading the article. They are trying to stop state investigations. The title doesn't say anything about Big Cable paying off anyone, that's jumping to conclusions not stated in the title.
There is a uniform national standard set by the FCC, but we have lots of federal laws that exceed or are exceeded by state laws. I'm not sure I understand why this would confuse consumers. I'm also not sure how big of a bandwidth measurement difference there can be, the article didn't elaborate on that... what different ways are there to measure or enforce 50Mb/s, and how far apart can they get? Is the problem more about what 50Mb/s means, or is it more about the differences in sustained bandwidth requirements?
How does this whole argument change if states agree to use the exact same measurements and criteria the FCC uses, but retain the ability to monitor and prosecute violations independently?
I feel like the subtext, reading between the lines, is the cable companies don't care about the "patchwork" problem, they just want less enforcement. The FCC can't cover everything, and they don't have that much power to stop cable if cable breaks the rules, especially in localized areas. Nor do they historically exercise that power unless things have gotten really far out of hand. Having states retain the ability to watch their own backs seems like a good idea to me.
- FireBeyond 9y ago> what different ways are there to measure or enforce 50Mb/s, and how far apart can they get? Is the problem more about what 50Mb/s means, or is it more about the differences in sustained bandwidth requirements? And, in the egregious New York case, it's not just about "oh, congestion might mean we get unfairly dinged", it's things like Charter selling (renting) D1 / D2 modems that are physically incapable of more than twenty per cent of the "up to" speed they are charging the customer for. "Here, pay for 100mbps Internet. Your modem cannot deliver more than 20mbps, but you're not supposed to know that. And when the FCC called us out on it, we avoided a fine by saying we'd replace those modems. And then we didn't." And the FCC / cable lobby is wondering why states feel the need to go around them??