3 ms·
Nicely done. We can certainly compare notes. I still encourage you to work or observe poll sites on election day. Soup to nuts. If you work it, you'll get trai
by specialist 9y ago
Nicely done. We can certainly compare notes.
I still encourage you to work or observe poll sites on election day. Soup to nuts. If you work it, you'll get training, see how the Australian Ballot is supposed to work. It requires many hands, eye balls, proper accounting.
I'm not so worried about identity theft for in person voting. Just doesn't (didn't) seen to happen much on the west coast.
I vigorously opposed closing our poll sites in favor of all mail postal balloting (WA state). With ballot scanners and electronic adjudication of ballots (changing records in the database per "voter intent"), it's roughly equivalent electronic voting machines, with some new vulnerabilities added (eg tabulating ballots as they arrive, effectively a pre-count).
As various members of the election verification network (EVN) determined, auditing elections is infeasible, impractical, and does little or nothing to increase confidence or certainty.
The gold standard for our form of elections, which I continue to advocate, is the Australian Ballot. In place of auditing, use physical chain of custody. (As you likely know, election administration is not banking, where they have double entry bookkeeping.)
---
To truly fix our election integrity woes, we need to do two things.
First, replace our first past the post (FPTP) with a more robust voting system. Like approval voting (for executive races) and proportional representation.
Second, adopt universal voter registration, with automatic updates. Were our government to use any one of the number of existing demographic databases (facebook, seisent, choicepoint, NSA, etc) then we'd know in near real-time who was eligible to vote. And save huge money doing it.
- rattray 9y agoCertainly agreed re; approval/proportional/similar. I'm not sure what you mean regarding the EVN. They provide auditing services, don't they? Also recommend auditing paper ballots here: > Conduct post-election audits before certification of final results > Without voter-verified paper ballots, effective audits are impossible. From their top ten list: http://editions.lib.umn.edu/electionacademy/2016/09/08/evns-top-ten-list-on-election-security/ http://editions.lib.umn.edu/electionacademy/2016/09/08/evns-... My impression is that SF actually uses a ballot designed for chain of custody accounting, but doesn't use it whatsoever in practice because of the effort involved. I may be wrong on this. But "many hands, eyeballs, proper accounting" is unfortunately not available for our elections in most areas. Happy to chat more about this - email is in my profile!
- ClayShentrup 9y agoEven better than Approval Voting. http://www.equal.vote http://www.equal.vote