It's that second statement that is wrong. If that is one of the foundations of the ID movement then it is on quite shaken grounds. Let's suppose god exists an

It's that second statement that is wrong. If that is one of the foundations of the ID movement then it is on quite shaken grounds. Let's suppose god exists and is extremely powerful and intelligent. The amount of information contained in the system god is vastly greater than on Earth. Thus by the statements you've made the probability of the god system being natural, that is not created by an intelligent agent, is orders of magnitude closer to zero than the system on Earth. OK, so ID people will claim that god is the sole uncreated intelligence, or uncaused event. But they are at the same point no -ID people are at. Namely, that very complex systems can exist without being created.