4 ms·
> that people are perfectly fine with Amazon being a conglomerate What is this supposed to mean? Is there supposed to be something inherently not-fine with a c
by TheSpiceIsLife 9y ago
> that people are perfectly fine with Amazon being a conglomerate
What is this supposed to mean? Is there supposed to be something inherently not-fine with a conglomerate? If conglomerates survive because they're better able to deliver goods and services more efficiently then great.
As another comment pointed out[1], we are surrounded by conglomerates.[2] Other conglomerates that have delivered things people love include, but limited to, Toyota; Yamaha; Mitsubishi; Wesfarmers; 3M; Alhpabet; Honeywell; Berkshire Hathaway. The list is expansive.
1. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14592612 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14592612
2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_conglomerates https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_conglomerates
- michaelt 9y agoIs there supposed to be something inherently not-fine with a conglomerate? Some people think they have a tendency to be inefficient, as high-performing areas of the business waste money subsidising low-performing areas of the business. And low-performing areas are insulated from free market feedback, like going bankrupt or investors leaving. Of course, some of this stuff is only obvious with hindsight. It was probably inefficient that Google Ads wasted money subsidising Plus and Wave; but probably efficient that Google Ads subsidises Gmail.
- sharemywin 9y agoWould the economy be better off if the money from google ads was paid back as dividends?
- mcguire 9y agoThe portion that paid for Wave?
- dragonwriter 9y agoIt's not about individual cases, but that having the businesses combined prevents investors from allocating capital between them, which is viewed as, in aggregate, less efficient as the allocation is a step removed from the market.
- TheSpiceIsLife 9y agoThis assumes that investors are efficient at allocating capital, or that individual investors are more efficient than institutional investors. As an obvious counterpoint: Birkshire Hathaway A more local example, as an Australian, is Wesfarmers who have persistently maintained strong brands in hugely diverse fields. As a welder by trade I'm willing to bet that the people managing these two conglomerates are more efficient at allocating capital than I, at least.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> This assumes that investors are efficient at allocating capital Yes, in aggregate, it does. Phrased another way, it assumes that the market is more efficient when different investments are unbundled and can be selected independently than when they are bundled. Note that I am not necessarily endorsing this charge against conglomerates, just clarifying what I see to be its basis.
- TheSpiceIsLife 9y agoI see your point, however: > And low-performing areas are insulated from free market feedback, like going bankrupt or investors leaving. This could be a net good for society as not all things societies like can necessarily be delivered by high-performing businesses.
- arvidkahl 9y agoIn my view, people have a strong tendency to question conglomerates, as they do with most large aggregations of wealth and power. On your list, I find many names that have been criticised for their acquisition strategies (and general corporate behavior). I meant to stress the familiarity that regular people have with small businesses in comparison to large megacorps.
- CuriouslyC 9y agoFrom the perspective of the voting/idealistic shareholder, conglomerates make it very difficult to influence the activity of a company, since any individual activity is a small portion of their makeup. Another problem with conglomerates is that big players compete in nonproductive ways. Large companies tend to actively lobby and influence regulations. The goal is generally to protect their business model (by limiting innovation), and it has been shown to have a very high return on investment. Having a broad base also gives conglomerates a lot of leveraging points in negotiations as well. Conglomerates also concentrate your failure points in the economy. Infrequent major failures are more painful than frequent minor failures. Besides, companies should not be "too big to fail." On the other hand, when conglomeration increases efficiency, it can be a good thing. As a result, if a market is stable and further innovation unlikely, conglomerates can be better for society than independent competitors, assuming sufficient competition to limit profit.