3 ms·
There is no future in software designed for limited CPU and low memory. Moore's law all but ensures that it'll be completely irrelevant. Symbian was designed
by wvenable 16y ago
There is no future in software designed for limited CPU and low memory. Moore's law all but ensures that it'll be completely irrelevant.
Symbian was designed for even weaker devices than I used when I developed for it years ago. As a developer, you're dealing with technology designed for hardware that simply doesn't exist anymore. When you have enough hardware to deliver what people want (like a full web browser) you have enough hardware for a decent OS.
- hcho 16y agoOnly that batteries don't tend to obey Moore's law. All other being equal, a smaller battery means not only lower BOM but also more freedom in physical desings of the devices.Not everyone likes to have a device size of a brick. The UI offerings of manufacturers are converging to not being a differentiator. When that point is reached the war will go on how well your software manages the limited resources.
- wvenable 16y ago> Only that batteries don't tend to obey Moore's law. My current smartphone is massively more powerful than my old Symbian smartphone and gets better battery life as well (and is smaller). We've seen massive gains in the power consumption of components inside computers and phones. > When that point is reached the war will go on how well your software manages the limited resources. That's never been true. Nokia is losing the smartphone market to a company that ported their desktop OS to a phone! The original Palm OS is no more because it was designed for devices of the day, not for devices of the future. What is considered "limited resources" changes daily and it doesn't matter how well your OS handles them if nobody bothers to write software for it.
- davidw 16y ago> There is no future in software designed for limited CPU and low memory Uh, what do you think the whole "embedded" thing is? What happens is that things get cheap enough that they tend to find new uses. For example, in the phone world, making more features available to the phones that billions of not so wealthy people in China, India and Africa might aspire to own.
- wvenable 16y ago> For example, in the phone world, making more features available to the phones that billions of not so wealthy people in China, India and Africa might aspire to own. Except the software doesn't get any cheaper. The whole argument is that Symbian is hard to develop for because it's designed for hardware that frankly doesn't exist anymore. The software is more expensive. Android is cheaper for other manufacturers to use than Symbian is for Nokia.
- davidw 16y ago> hardware that frankly doesn't exist anymore That is simply not true. Nokia still churns out tons of phones that don't even run Symbian, but S40, which is another step down. And they sell like hotcakes, too, even if the profit margins aren't huge. And they'll continue to sell well for the immediate future. Clearly, Nokia has lost its grip on "the future" and isn't very competitive with things like Android and the iPhone, but to deny that the biggest chunk of the cell phone market exists is a bit absurd.
- wvenable 16y agoYes, they sell mobile phones -- devices that make calls with an address book. The biggest selling feature of these devices is that don't do anything else. However, A smartphone that doesn't do anything else isn't very smart. Where's the market for Symbian here?
- davidw 16y agoThe phones capable of running Symbian, but not so capable of running heavier systems like Android, will get cheaper, and thus be able to reach a broader market, or new niches.