2 ms·
> I feel like we are not gaining anything from this discussion Sorry about that. I'm frustrated, but I really am trying to be constructive here. > "Intuitive
by lisper 9y ago
> I feel like we are not gaining anything from this discussion
Sorry about that. I'm frustrated, but I really am trying to be constructive here.
> "Intuitively, the state of a system describes enough about the system to determine its future behaviour in the absence of any external forces affecting the system."
Right. So if your state describes the whole universe, that provides enough information to determine its future behavior because there is nothing external to the universe (by definition!)
> "State functions do not depend on the path by which the system arrived at its present state."
Right. However, because the dynamics of both classical and quantum mechanics are reversible, you can determine the past states of a closed system (like the universe) in exactly the same way you can determine its future states. (That's how we know, for example, that the big bang happened.)
> I think you might run into problems with the Heisenberg uncertainty principle when you try to determine the state of your system.
Right. That's why it's important to distinguish between classical and quantum mechanics. In classical mechanics there is a mystery about where the arrow of time comes from because the fundamental equations are all time-symmetric. Quantum mechanics (and more specifically QIT - quantum information theory) solves that mystery.
> "The science of thermodynamics is able to capture these generalizations as consequences of its claim that systems spontaneously evolve to future equilibrium states but do not spontaneously evolve away from equilibrium states."
This is not a solution to the mystery because it has to introduce this extra axiom about equilibrium states, which does not follow from Newton's equations. QIT is a better solution because the (practical) irreversibility of measurements can be derived from the basic axioms of QM. It doesn't have to be assumed.