4 ms·
No, they are not a privilege. That section of the constitution is talking about the power of the congress.
by oh_sigh 9y ago
No, they are not a privilege. That section of the constitution is talking about the power of the congress.
- lisper 9y agoThe Constitution grants Congress the power to grant IP protection. Congress can elect not to exercise that power.
- oh_sigh 9y agoYes, the people grant the power to Congress. If Congress chooses to not use that power, then the people can put new congresspeople in office. By your definition, passing laws is a privilege too, because Congress can choose to not do it. Perhaps that's correct usage of the word privilege but I don't really see it
- lisper 9y agoI don't really want to quibble over terminology. I don't care what you call it, the point is just that it is not a Constitutional right on the same legal footing as the right (say) free speech.
- bmelton 9y agoPer Sable v. FCC[1], any restriction that is subject to examination of the content is subject to strict scrutiny. Strict scrutiny, where applied appropriately, would mean that the government is very unlikely to devise a restriction on content without being able to show that the content of the speech being restricted weren't tantamount to incitation, treason, etc. You're correct that Congress may choose not to exercise that power, but they are prevented from being able to exercise that power arbitrarily, and especially not on matters of obscenity or indecency without passing(failing?) the Miller test[2], which this clearly doesn't, and "The Slants" arguably satisfies none of the conditions. [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sable_Communications_of_California_v._FCC https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sable_Communications_of_Califo... [2] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miller_test https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miller_test
- lisper 9y agoNo one is disputing that the band has the right to call itself the slants, or any other offensive term they choose to use. But it is far from clear that they should be entitled to trademark protection for it, Sable notwithstanding. (Well, it's clear now, but it wasn't clear yesterday.) The government already exercises a lot of authority to control the content on the public airwaves, I don't see why trademarks should be any different. But I haven't had time to read the opinion yet. Maybe I will find enlightenment there.
- bmelton 9y agoI'm honestly convinced that, post-Sable, the FCC is poised to lose should anyone challenge their obscenity provisions, Miller test notwithstanding. Since then though, the FCC has been more prudent with what they go after, and the fines have are low enough that it serves everyone's interests to keep everything de rigueur. NBC doesn't want to have to worry about having to compete with smut on the public airwaves, or having to big against Pornhub in the next spectrum auction. Meanwhile, the FCC of course enjoys the presumption of authority over the airwaves with a quasi-plausible veil of content neutrality.