3 ms·
I see this chilling effect manifested sometimes on HN as well. People will create throwaway accounts to comment on certain subjects. An example - there was a d
by bogomipz 9y ago
I see this chilling effect manifested sometimes on HN as well. People will create throwaway accounts to comment on certain subjects.
An example - there was a discussion a couple of days ago about FB and I questioned why a commenter felt the need to create a fake account simply to comment on FB. It turned out they weren't even a current employee but an ex-employee.
- 20170619-2 9y agoon HN, the mods are directly responsible for the chilling effect. they censor anyone who doesn't tow the company line, or has any kind of strong dissenting opinion. this is achieved by shadow bans, single-IP bans, and then finally by flagging every single IP they've ever logged in under as blacklisted for new account creation. i cycled through 3 or 4 accounts with multiple-thousand-points of karma, but in the end i just stopped giving a shit. this sort of amateur-level banning may work against your typical troll, but on HN, the end result is you're wiping out diversity of opinion, because although the people on here are smart and resourceful enough to get around any ban that happens over the internet, at some point it just becomes not worth it just to express your opinion -- that's how censorship actually works in the real world. at the end of the day, YC is a VC and has interests to protect.
- bogomipz 9y ago>"on HN, the mods are directly responsible for the chilling effect. they censor anyone who doesn't tow the company line, or has any kind of strong dissenting opinion ..." What is the company line exactly? Is it just maintaing agreement with YC-backed companies? I hadn't heard about the shadow bans, are they only on submissions or commenting too?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- 20170620-5 9y agoI was wondering why no-one was voting or commenting my highly dissenting replies here. Now I have the answer.