3 ms·
Personally, while I understand that this is nothing illegal, I think it's terribly wrong. We just handed everyone, including the 5% of society who tend towards
by falcolas 9y ago
Personally, while I understand that this is nothing illegal, I think it's terribly wrong.
We just handed everyone, including the 5% of society who tend towards sociopathy, a nicely tagged, collated (and yet probably slightly inaccurate) list of minorities.
Hate women? You have a nice list which includes the names, addresses, and telephone numbers of all those women.
Hate muslims? Boy do I have just the list for you. Blacks? Republicans? White muslim men who live in the same neighborhood as you?
Let's omit the sociopaths for just a moment, and let's look at the ad networks. Can you picture how much more accurate a picture those companies have of you now? They no longer have to guess at your age, ethnicity or religion - they now know. What could go wrong when that list of "legally" collated data gets combined with the RNC leak, and is subsequently itself leaked?
So no. It's probably not illegal to compile these lists. It's probably not even illegal that it was released. But it was, for certain, a damned immoral thing to do, and there will be consequences.
- cookiecaper 9y agoOne of the weird effects of the internet is that stuff that used to be considered obvious and self-evident is now treated as very sensitive. For example, no one used to consider their gender or race "private" information; rather, it was nearly impossible to interact with another human without these things being self-evident. Not many years ago, there used to be a book distributed far and wide with the names, address, and phone number of virtually everyone that lived in your city. This was accepted as normal and routine, and you had to specifically opt out of being included.
- falcolas 9y agoThe difference is in the scope. Back when phonebooks were widely used, there was no automated way to correlate those records with other records to create a highly specific list of all Asian women who live in a four block radius of a specific address. You could walk around and find some of them, but that would take a significant amount of time and effort. Phones were also not capable of interrupting you while you were out of the home, nor were they capable of receiving short messages on your dime.
- nostrademons 9y agoI don't really disagree that this is a shitty data breach, but on the consequences, I'll point out that the 5% of society who tends to sociopathy already have much lower-effort means to target minorities: Hate women? Look for boobs. Hate muslims? Look for brown skin. Hate Republicans? Look for MAGA hats. That these are inaccurate signals is irrelevant: haters gonna hate, and I really don't think they care whether the brown-skinned person they're harassing is actually a Muslim, they just want a target for their anger. As for ad networks - they already have much more accurate models of age, ethnicity, and religion than the RNC has. There's a lot more money involved in targeting ads, and so they've put a lot more effort into it than political consultancies. Worrying about them is like closing the barn door after the horse is out.
- falcolas 9y ago> lower-effort means to target minorities It doesn't get much lower effort than downloading a list, popping it into Excel, and sorting on a column (I'm willing to bet that some hate groups are already doing this and will release very specific lists to their membership). And with phone numbers and a couple of bucks, you don't even have to leave your house to send them hate messages by the thousands. Haters gonna hate - far too flippant a phrase to describe those who emotionally and physically assault their targets. As for the ad models - the RNC release has a very specific DOB, location, gender, and phone number. Some of these the ad network could guess at, but this provides concrete data.
- nostrademons 9y agoIt gets a lot lower effort than downloading a list, popping it into Excel, and sorting on a column (really, how many non-techies would do that?). Get on the subway, find girls with brown skin, start screaming obscenities, pull knife when confronted, murder. Look, I don't want to minimize the impact of hate or harassment on victims. It really is terrible, and should be challenged whenever possible. I do want to inject some realism into the discussion of the likely consequences of this breach. The people who would go out and harm other people because of their ethnicity or religion don't particularly care if they get the ethnicity or religion right. (I'm reminded of a time when I was carrying my wife's purse while she went shopping in a nearby store, I walk by a pickup truck, and the guy inside is loudly muttering "Fucking faggots" over and over again. And then I met my wife in the parking lot, give her a kiss, hand her back her handbag, and he laughs a big "Ha-ha!" of relief and drives off.) And the people who would do mass harassment over the phone have much easier ways to get this data, like e-mailing their state voter registry and asking for it.
- lol214365 9y agoBecause minorities were so hard to find in the US prior to this... You know what? Let's keep those minorities at a safe distance from those evil racists. Let's build the wall!